2020-07-28 PPS School Board Regular Meeting
District | Portland Public Schools |
---|---|
Date | 2020-07-28 |
Time | 19:00:00 |
Venue | Virtual/Online |
Meeting Type | regular |
Directors Present | missing |
Documents / Media
Notices/Agendas
Materials
2020 07 14 Minutes for Adoption (bc47408cdbdfabb2).pdf 2020_07_14_Minutes for Adoption
2020 07 21 Special Meeting Minutes for Adoption (fe7162b3381f728f).pdf 2020_07_21_Special Meeting_Minutes for Adoption
2020 School Renewal Bond Ballot Title - FINAL (1) (cd6d518a58497a81).pdf 2020 School Renewal Bond Ballot Title - FINAL (1)
2020 School Renewal Bond Ballot Title - FINAL 7.28 revised (992b7cbbc6ca6e50).pdf 2020 School Renewal Bond Ballot Title - FINAL 7.28 revised
BAC Memo to BOE 07.24.20 FINAL (e16b2c90dd28a975).pdf BAC Memo to BOE_07.24.20_FINAL
FINAL 2020 School Bond Renewal Package (9ad3e82a1a7cfc7d).pdf FINAL 2020 School Bond Renewal Package
PPS Reopening Board Work Session 7 28 20 (d1e0162b9ff8f3bd).pdf PPS Reopening Board Work Session 7_28_20
Staff Report - Bond Referral 7.22.20 (13475f9c0ebd7efe).pdf Staff Report - Bond Referral 7.22.20
Center for Black Student Excellence Resolution (8f794994297020e8).pdf Center for Black Student Excellence Resolution
Presentation (3b3ebffb0b2250d0).pdf Presentation
Minutes
Transcripts
Event 1: PPS Board of Education Regular Meeting 7/28/2020
00h 00m 00s
um the board meeting of the board of
education for july
28 2020 to order uh for tonight's
meeting
any item that will be voted on has been
posted as required by state law
this meeting is being streamed live on
channel 28 and will be replayed
throughout the next two weeks
please check the district website for
replay times and this meeting is
also being live streamed on our pps tv
services website
welcome to our viewing audience if you
are just tuning in
uh we have just had an update from staff
on the plans for fall reentry and we
know
how much families are anxious to hear
about what school will look like
for students next year so you can check
out that meeting
also on channel 28. and tonight we're
very excited because we get to vote on
the 2020 bond package
and hear an initial update on the 2021
board goals
we're going to begin however with the
consent agenda
and so members are there any items that
you would like to pull
um we will discuss those at the end of
the meeting and but on them then
so are there any items uh that we need
to pull from the consent agenda tonight
sure lowry um i have
uh two items that i don't we don't need
to pull them can i just state my
questions and they don't even have to be
answered tonight just put them in the
record
that sounds great yeah okay let's go
ahead and get the motion on the table
director
medwards and then you can ask those
questions
so moved second the consent agenda
so the two questions i'd like to have uh
just
answer for the record um later in the
meeting or
put them in the record is
on the transportation services to
district employees
we have a contract with safe
transportation
and my question is how is the training
that is part of our professional conduct
when we have unsupervised
interactions between adults and students
how is that training delivered to
the contractors so that's one and then
the second question
um is um what are the metrics
for success for equity for the center
for equity
and inclusion um for the contract and
both of them uh i'm supportive of both
contracts
like the answers to that and then one
last thing that ainsworth
office expansion i think should just be
clarified that it's not actually
expanding the office but their offices
for special ed
uh teachers to have meetings um versus
a expansion of an administrative office
so
i'm happy to have the questions answered
at the very end or next meeting
whatever whatever works for staff okay
so let's
uh can we have staff answer those via
email director brent edwards is that
acceptable
okay so staff could get those to
director from edwards via email that
would be lovely
uh miss bradshaw were there any changes
to the consent agenda i know we moved
and seconded pretty quickly there
i there nope there were no changes to
the conference agenda
then we don't have to redo the um motion
is there any further board discussion on
the consent agenda
uh yeah i've got a question um
in reference to the minutes it doesn't
look like my vote was recorded as
for board policy um
in any of the last two board meetings hi
nathaniel
um that is because the it's unofficial
and the new program we have doesn't have
a place to put it
so the overviews aren't complete yet but
when the overviews are complete they
will state your vote for each of the
items so it'll be in the discussion
it'll show your vote
right but it is that not also recorded
in the minutes that we are to approve
roseanne are you able to answer that i'm
not sure
they need to do that so we do not
approve the meeting overviews
but we can talk to uh talk to board
leadership to figure out how we can
uh work through this so that we can note
your
vote i think we can take that and come
back
nathaniel with uh with some further
thoughts and a solution on that
yeah all right thank you for raising
that student representative shoe
any other discussion on the consent
agenda
ford will now vote on resolutions
6147-36149 and the consent agenda all in
favor please indicate by saying yes yes
yes
yes yes all posed
please indicate by saying no
are there any extensions
the consent agenda is approved by a vote
of seven to zero with student
00h 05m 00s
representative shu
voting uh abstain
for the reason of yeah all right
thank you nathaniel
we now turn to student and public
comment and before we begin i'd like to
review our guidelines for comment
the board thanks the community for
taking the time to attend this meeting
and provide your testimonies public
input
informs our work and we look forward to
hearing your thoughts
reflections and concerns and our
responsibility as a board
is to actively listen board members and
the superintendent
will not respond to questions during
public comment but our board office
will follow up on board-related issues
raised during public testimony
public input emphasizes respect and
consideration of others
and we request that complaints about
individual
employees be rejected be directed
to the superintendent's office as a
personnel matter
if you have additional materials or
items you would like to provide to the
board or superintendent
we ask that you email them to
publiccomment
pps.net please make sure that tonight
when you begin your comment you clearly
state your name
and spell your last name you will have
three minutes to speak
and you will hear a sound at the three
minute mark which means that it is time
for you to conclude your comments
ms bradshaw who do we have signed up for
student or public comment tonight
we have mitchell kenny is our student
signed up
all right mr kenny okay hello
my name is mitchell kenny that's
k-e-n-n-y
and i am a senior at medicine high
school
and when i heard about the proposed four
class semester for reopening and
reopening in the fall i realized there
were some problems for ap
students such as myself and i think my
situation really
illustrates those prompts so normally
students in these classes would spend
most of the class learning all the new
material
and then have time to study before the
test in class
with class time dedicated to the subject
from the first day of school
to the day of the test however under the
four class semester an ap student would
only have the class for one semester
and they would lose the continuity of
studying that subject throughout
so for example if a student had the
class in the first semester they would
learn all the material
in that semester and then they would
take about a three and a half month
break
from the end of the first semester to
the test day where there would be no
allotted class time for the subject
and in the worst case if a student had
an ap class in the second semester
they would only have that three and a
half months to fully prepare for the
test which
is completely unfair to the student so
in my schedule
i had five ap classes planned for my
senior year
but because i have five under the four
class semester even with
optimal scheduling i would have four
classes to fully learn in the first
semester
and then not touch for three and a half
months and now
then i would have to fully learn another
class in that three and a half months
and this is the best case scenario where
my first semester is all ap
classes so options to help ap
students have already been mentioned but
in cases like mine
with at least five ap classes i think
those options
might look quite different the district
might ask me to
self-study a class or even drop them
to fit the schedule at benson
specifically
so in any case no matter what the
district would be asking
i think it's ridiculous and the problems
with ap
would be solved by reverting back to the
eighth class semester
so i know my situation is an extreme
example
but there are hundreds if not thousands
of other ap students in the district
who will face the same problems i will
because of the four-class semester
so i felt the need to come here and
speak against it
thank you thank you very much
for your testimony tonight uh we were
just
talking about that in the last session i
think you've heard part of that as well
uh ms bradshaw do we have any other
public comment tonight
yes andrew constantinescu
hi my name is andrew constantinescu my
last name is spelled
c-o-n-s-t-a-n
uh this is to superintendent guerrero
and portland public schools board of
directors
we the teachers and staff of james
madison high school enthusiastically
applaud your decision
to initiate a process to change the
names of schools throughout the district
we encourage you to stand behind that
process and remain committed
to naming our schools in ways that our
diverse group of students can be proud
of
as you know schools like james madison
high school have been honoring slave
owners
or leaders who have contributed to the
racial injustice that permeates in our
country's culture
00h 10m 00s
by now you hopefully know that james
madison for example enslaved over 100
people and he legalized the racist
dehumanizing and exploitative
institution of slavery
by placing it squarely into the heart of
our nation's constitution
this along with other acts that
dehumanized and targeted people of color
is hopefully well known to you by now
naming our school after him is a very
real problem
therefore we implore you to place our
school on a fast track to the standard
change process
rather than delay for multiple years we
appreciate the importance of
deliberation
we wholeheartedly agree that students
alumni community members
parents staff and other stakeholders
must be involved in the path to renaming
however we feel the utmost urgency for
multiple reasons
number one our school rebuild is on pace
to be completed at the end of the
2020-2021 school year
as part of the redesign the building
will be branded with a school name
logo and a mascot to best use taxpayer
funds in this process
it makes sense to be proactive in
renaming the school instead of waiting
until the rebuild process is finished
number two our students have been
engaged in a campaign to rename our
school for over a year and a half
already
they have researched james madison
pulled the student body made fact sheets
written school newspaper articles spoken
to community groups
created petitions engaged with alumni
met with administrators and even given
testimony to the pps school board
a lot of work has gone into this from
our student body
and it only shows that they are
committed to making this happen and
have been for over a year number three
because of the groundwork that has
already been started we believe that a
thoughtful process for renaming our
school
can successfully and respectfully be
completed within a year
we've already seen a similar process
happen within our own cluster
when rose city elementary merged with
gregory heights middle school in 2007 to
become roseway heights
as our school is one of oregon most
diverse
we call on you to please make our school
a part of your case study
rather than put our efforts at the back
of the line show the portland community
that you truly do stand behind your
commitment to support bypoc students
by adding madison to this initial plan
we stand ready to work with our students
parents alumni and community partners
this is only one piece and a broader
deeper effort we are committed to that
will help make our school more just and
more equitable
but it is an important piece we are
excited to commit to
right now and not at some ambiguous
later date
thank you thank you
ms bradshaw do we have any further
public comment
yes we have tim neiser
welcome tim
yeah so
my name is tim kaniser a n
i i live in the madison high school
neighborhood
my daughter attended roseway heights and
now attends madison high school
and i'm a teacher at madison as well
many portland
public school building names and mascots
came about
as a result of individual and
institutional racism
madison high school is one example
but i'm not here to discuss if the name
should be changed
of course it should be changed i'm here
to discuss when it should be changed
school buildings like ours that are
being modernized
and set to open in 2021 need to be
prioritized
names and images are being added to new
construction now
every month that passes means time money
and energy spent and wasted on new work
and materials and more time more energy
more money spent a few months later to
replace it
the madison high school remodel is on an
urgent timeline
renaming it should also be on one two
we can take this simple concrete step to
dismantle institutional racism
right now and we should renaming our
school
cannot become a long and distracting
process for our district
because there is so much more that we
need to be working on
to create a just and equitable education
for
all of our students please insist
that a new name is chosen for our school
in a timely manner
and by the people who are impacted most
immediately
thank you
thank you ms bradshaw do we have further
public comment
amina ali
welcome
00h 15m 00s
it looks like amina is still muted
miss bradshaw do you unmute her
sorry i am tech challenged oh no it's
totally okay
my name is amina ali and
my last name is ali
i i um have one son
who is a graduate of madison and i
have two children who still attend
madison
and i i really want to start this by
thanking the school board and the
superintendent for all of the work all
of the craziness that's gone on
um i can't even begin to imagine the
decisions that are having to be made
right now
but i have to say that when i heard
that the school board was acknowledging
the need for changes and
names of the schools i was
thrilled and then when i
heard that it would take three
to five five years for that
change i was immediately
deflated now
is the time i it just makes sense
when we look at a new building and new
construction
it just makes sense that this
is the time
hard-working teachers and students have
been working on this
literally for years now they're ready
to say to anyone right now in these
incredibly divisive times
that anti-racism has to wait three to
five years
seems completely backward to me
southeast portland needs a win
we need a win southeast portland it's
not just about madison as a high school
and the amazingly diverse population
that goes there
it's also about a community in southeast
portland that is suffering we have been
suffering
for a long time we do not get resources
as you well know
um we don't get resources when it comes
to
things like sidewalks and traffic
flights and
new business we need something to look
forward to
these kids that well know
the history of wilson wilson and madison
they know don't make them walk into a
brand new building
with an antiquated
racist name behind it it's called the
modern
modernization project and as we think
about modernization i think we need to
think about
philosophically what that means
it's not not just about new tiles and
pretty computer labs it's about
what the school means what are those
kids going to carry
on their gear and on their academic
transcripts
there needs to be a name that's
inspiring there needs to be a name
not of a racist not of somebody who
abused and kidnapped and tortured
children
this needs to happen now please consider
putting
madison with wilson as a test case for a
name change
southeast portland deserves it madison
community deserves it
and definitely ghost thank you
i'm one of those kids oh wait thank you
miss bradshaw is there a further public
comment
yes adam daniel
uh miss bradshaw i don't see mr daniel
on the list of participants oh maybe
he's one of the callers are you there
okay can we move on to the next comment
and try to connect with him
yes mia callaway
um can you hear me yes
okay great um actually adam daniel is
in the call i'm not sure why her um
connection isn't
working but if we can so sorry she's
she's called in
yes i'm so sorry i misgendered her we
will uh resolve the tech issue after you
are done speaking if that's okay
yes okay great i was just making sure
00h 20m 00s
that she would get her time to speak
um okay perfect hi everyone i'm nia
callaway that's
um my last name is spelled o
w a c-a-l-l-o-w-a-y i'm a campaign lead
for you
pass with um youth environmental justice
alliance and a 2020 park rose high
school graduate
um i'm speaking this evening on behalf
of the get moving measure more
specifically the 9 million dollar annual
investment for all youth in the metro
region
to receive youth pass as a transit
dependent student
with a history of long commutes i've
seen my share of absences
and detention students without
transportation options can miss as many
as 11 extra days
a year of class youthpass can minimize
these absences and help improve
academic performance having accessible
public transit available has proven to
decrease chronic school absences issues
for students
this measure also expands resources
to the many low-income and bipark
families in the east county as well as
those within portland public districts
whose needs are met by youth past
this measure can and will change young
lives like mine who are dependent on
transit and deserve a safer and more
reliable
way to get around safer meaning cleaner
safer meaning acknowledging the needs of
young black indigenous and youth of
color
and safer meaning transit dependent
youths communities are being more funded
transit-wise
companies and corporations like nike we
know in the past
have come out against the measure due to
an employee tax
there may be some people on this board
with conflicting perceptions on this
measure due to aspects like these
and i urge you as members of the board
of education to only think in the
interests of portland students and not
personal business interests
programs like youthpass help leaders and
representatives like yourself tell the
youth of portland that they care about
them
and their futures it also in turn
creates a future
of loyal writers choosing public transit
over cars which will alleviate
congestion and mitigate climate change
and a free regional youth pass creates a
universal region-wide benefit available
to over 200 000 youth
as they become the next wave of public
transportation writers many of them
being students
youth advocates are here in hopes of
your full support on the youth pass
portion of the measure
and the numerous other equity wins like
safer routes to school and other safe
transit benefits expanded to
predominantly communities of color
which is a huge need for portland thank
you for your time
thank you is ms daniel are you available
to speak at this time
is bradshaw um have you been in touch
with ms daniels so we can see what the
tech issue might be here
i have not received anything
from her
i'm not sure which column user
should be looks like we have column user
four
it's the only column user we have right
now that i can see
i just unmuted them hi
daniel yes you can hear me now
yes thank you for your patience with us
tonight
fantastic okay um
hello everyone my name is adam daniel my
partner is she and her and i'm a
campaign lead from asia
and i went to dave douglas high school i
wanted to address the
youth pass as a part of the 9 million
dollar annual investment a part of the
get moving measure
i want to acknowledge that youthpass is
an extremely important program because
we can easily see how youth access to
transit contributes to climate justice
as well as social justice
youth will have the right to mobility
and we know that marginalized
communities
youth and students suffer the most from
these transportation disparities
so this program will provide equity and
allow for all youth to get free transit
although pps has bus passes this will
benefit the district
far more because your students will not
only get it during the school year but
also in the summers
and provide more for your regional
community this program is extremely
important for your students suffering
economic disparities due to clover19
this would show your support and
help out these families more i want to
remind you all that youth have worked
really hard to make this transit program
accessible to our entire region i want
to remind you to act in the interest of
serving your students
the youth in your community and
marginalized communities beyond
we have dealt with corporations feeling
against this measure
and how the tax will work but this
measure truly acts in the benefit of the
broader community
for working class people and for the
entire community beyond
we ask that you do not your penal
interests
with the interests of the community you
serve this matters to your student body
00h 25m 00s
the people of your city the youth they
want your support as tps
for the youth pass program on the get
moving measure as well as a part of to
create
safer communities better routes to
schools and
other advances towards achieving equity
as we are in these current times
it is very crucial that you all
as as the portland public school
district
take action to achieve this equity thank
you very much
you miss bradshaw do we have any further
public comment
one last person signed up for this banda
hunter
hello everyone my name is vonda hunter
that is h-u-n-t-e-r
my pronouns are she her i work for
oregon afscme
council 75 and as a coalition partner of
asia i am speaking on behalf of
alejandra gallegos
who cannot be here today but wishes they
could i will now read the testimony that
they prepared
my name is alejandra gallegos that last
name is
g a l l e g
o s my pronouns are they them
i am the youth environmental justice
alliance organizer at opal
i am here today to give you all an
update on some very exciting news
outside of all the quarantine and
federal messes popping up
on july 16th we were able to get the
entire metro council to unanimously pass
the get moving transportation measure
measure that would include
a nine million dollar annual investment
in youth pass
this investment in youth pass will
provide all youth
18 and under in the entire metro region
year round regardless of income and
school enrollment status
to have access to this amazing program
that pps
already partially enjoys this
is over 20 years of work led by black
and brown youth
predominantly women insisting there
should be no barriers in being able to
get to and from school
this is a huge deal for portland
removing a barrier as simple as
transportation
has been proven to mitigate dropout
rates and improve graduation rates in
cities where transit is free for
students
and we all know oregon needs it you all
have the opportunity right now to
correct
portland's intentionally racist history
by supporting working class and by poc
youth today and fully supporting the
youth path
portion of this measure going forward
this measure also includes
multiple other equity solutions such as
safe routes to school
better and safer buses and corridor
improvements in historically
underinvested in communities of color we
urge you today to place the needs of
students over that of personal business
interests
thank you
thank you and thanks to all of
those who gave comment and if you have
something specific that you want to
follow up with
the board or board office please connect
with our board manager roseanne
nathaniel would you like to provide us
with your report this evening
uh yes i would thank you um all right
so this is my first report as student
representative
uh which is both very exciting and
daunting
um i hope you all will be able to
forgive me for any slip ups herein
um so let's let's begin
um as it's summer it's difficult to
report on
student affairs overall so i will mostly
be focusing
on the district student council the dsc
for this report i would also like to
thank the dsc
for their instrumental role in planning
this report i am most grateful for your
help
and um i would like to note that while
the dsc was very much involved
they do not necessarily endorse
everything that's about to come out of
my mouth
so moving right along um we have
committees we are working to appoint at
least
one dsc representative from each com
sorry one dsc representative to each
board committee
and advisory group at the moment we as a
council have a representative from
approximately half of district high
schools
hopefully as we add more reps this fall
we can ensure that each rep gets a
committee and each committee gets a rep
and uh quick plug if there are any high
school students watching who are
interested in joining the dsc
particularly from alternative schools
and from larger schools
such as franklin and lincoln please feel
free to get in touch with me
it's on nshue pbs.net
now um dsc and student
representative policy as many of you
know we are currently at the beginning
of the process
to amend 1.20.012
00h 30m 00s
p which is the student representative
and dsc governing
policy we are planning
to map out and subsequently implement a
community engagement strategy in the
near future
and we tentatively plan to send the
policy to the policy committee at some
point
in fall of course all that is subject to
change based on the
highly volatile by environment in which
we currently
find ourselves um
now um originally i had
planned to include a section on
reopening i was going to
um discuss the need for greater clarity
surrounding
the district's reopening plan um no no
i no longer feel that is necessary given
the recent guidance from the governor
and our
discussion um it is it now seems pretty
clear
what we're going to be doing in fall um
which
leaves me with one final topic
um well this wouldn't ordinarily
be within the purview of this report we
as a council have decided that we cannot
fail to mention an issue
of this magnitude we would like to
signal our support
to the protesters to all and
particularly
the students who have been involved in
the protest sorry who have been involved
in the black
lives matter protests and for that
matter movement more generally
we thank you for your activism and your
bravery we would also like to condemn
the federal response to the protests in
our city
the likes of which are uncalled for and
have no place
in a democratic republic and
that concludes my first student
representative report
thank you uh
that deserves a round of applause from
your board of colleagues for getting
through your first one with such
uh weight and clarity of uh the values
of our district so thank you
representatives
but also um for bringing up a topic that
um
adults are just uh uncomfortable with so
i really appreciate your um
showing up that way thank you
i know we all look forward to continuing
working with you through this
next school year um superintendent
guerrero you get to follow that
so good luck i was just gonna say that
for our student representative's first
report he's making it a hard act to
follow but uh
i'll do my best i'll just repeat what he
said if i slip up please forgive me
so good evening directors chair uh to
those watching the live stream
or joining us here live thank you for
for being here this evening i'm just
gonna
touch on a few topics uh one because we
talked about it earlier and for
for the larger public's benefit uh
if we go to the to the next slide i want
to start the evening by looking back to
some of the themes we covered earlier in
the work session uh that we just wrapped
up prior to beginning this meeting
folks probably mentioned uh or noticed
that earlier today we
we made an announcement to families and
staff that we will begin the upcoming
school year
online we made this determination
after reviewing the best available
guidance from health officials
and following today's announcement by
governor brown regarding
new health metrics and standards that we
should consider when
opening schools i also want to recognize
and realize that for families this news
might
provide some some assurance they were
looking for but it also
uh likely presents challenges to to many
others so
as we're nearing the end of the summer i
i said this earlier i think we all hope
to be in a different reality with this
pandemic and for those of us in public
ed we always prefer to have our students
face to face
engaged in classroom-based learning but
under the current conditions
uh it just would be unsafe to have
significant numbers of students and
adults
back on campus at this time so our
comprehensive distance learning model
which
directors and public heard a little bit
about uh earlier
is intended to be different from the
student learning experience of this past
spring our goal is to be prepared to
engage
students and provide them with a more
robust learning experience
students will be observing a regular
weekly schedule
there will be regular interaction with
teachers
grades will be taken as well as
attendance
uh so although this will be a a more
uh atypical or unusual start to the
school year
um we are working uh and collaborating
with our school leaders and educators to
really sort of create a new kind of
opportunity
and also establish support structures
that better
ensure black native and students of
color have access to
culturally specific supports this
includes continued
and strengthened partnership with
culturally specific community-based
partners
continuing to braid our racial equity
and social justice strategies
00h 35m 00s
into our instructional core and
developing supports that
begin to address mental health impacts
uh of these times i i want to thank
parents who
lent their voice to a couple of recent
focus groups about
what would be helpful uh in supporting
them as we contemplate the new school
year i want to invite families in the
broader public
to stay on top of our posting
information
we'll be doing that on a regular basis
at pps.net
fall 2020 so please stay in tune
on our homepage we're also going to be
reaching out to families
through other means so these are tough
times
we're going to do our best to rise to
them i will continue to count on our
educators and staff to
be creative and compassionate as we as
we serve
our critically important mission so i
know that the next update will
dive into much more detail about uh
the specific experience that our
students and teachers will have
next slide uh we committed to our
directors
uh we we want to recognize this also was
an unusual budget development
uh season this past spring there's a
little bit of movement
uh in this area and we just want to call
it out here
we know that our resource planning would
be different for most years
and information from the state is is
also going to be iterating so
we're waiting for the next state budget
forecast we're beginning to hear
a few things from the ways and means
co-chairs revenue proposal
first of all there's a possibility that
the student investment account funding
will actually be cut by two-thirds uh
earlier forecast showed that funding
would be cut by one-third
uh pre-covered so we're paying close
attention to that
on the good news side we understand that
measure 98 funding
just might be fully funded uh for
for the coming year uh and we're also
hearing uh
uh that there may be fuller full funding
for state school funds so
the current level of funding uh under
discussion at the state level will
i we believe cover all of our staff and
resource needs
to open the coming school year but as
soon as we have
more concrete information from the state
we'll be sure to come back to the board
and the cbrc with
that that pledged budget amendment after
the special legislative session
is completed uh that session is
anticipated to begin
on august 10th so stay tuned for for
more updates there
and then i just wanted to touch on what
what is going to be a
a main topic of conversation in
tonight's regular meeting
uh because it's an important milestone
uh something that we're asking to
or planning to go to the voters with
this this fall
and continuing to ask for their support
uh
in passing a bomb that will result in uh
not just
the modernization of benson and
jefferson high school
but also builds in a transformation and
ability to really
dedicate an investment in curriculum uh
in learning technology
and continued health and safety and
other facility upgrades
and then importantly and i appreciate
the director's
conversation at our last meeting uh
attention to
facility accessibility uh which is
particularly appropriate on this week
which marks the 30th anniversary of the
americans with disabilities
act so uh glad that the board will be
considering that this evening
uh for a final vote as well and then
there's another exciting concept in
there
uh which i want to go to the next slide
about and say a little bit more about
we're excited about this concept of a
center for black student excellence
i'm excited about this vision i think
it's a groundbreaking concept for a
number of reasons
one it's long overdue and much needed in
our city and in a school system that
too many times has marginalized black
youth and their families
this initiative allows pps to play an
important role
in partnership with the broader
community and lifting up
our black students uh the partnership
aspect
is central to the ultimate success of
this initiative
if we're going to truly succeed in
serving black students and youth and
we'll have to do it together there is
great power and
partnership and we could bring some
things to the table but we're a better
school system
when we work with our community partners
uh to serve students and thank you
some of you for for being on the line
now uh our conversations and planning
with albino vision are going to continue
the potential of the center for black
student excellence
is limitless again this concept
represents a constellation
of school communities this uh might very
well be
our landmark effort that will benefit
generations of black
students their families their
00h 40m 00s
communities portland public schools and
the city of portland in general
so i think this bond package has the
potential to drive a foundational change
for us
but i want to thank everyone our
directors staff volunteers
and members of our broader community for
a really great deal of hard work and
input that has led us to this moment and
i know we're going to have
a deeper conversation and i'll have a
few more thoughts to share
later in our agenda uh so as a last
slide uh to my report this evening
um just want to sort of preview here uh
you may have noticed that around this
time uh
at the end of each summer as we launch
into the new school year we we come up
with a theme or
a motto um and for this year uh
and i think it's appropriate uh the
theme is
together we will uh and partly because
we're taking on some enormous challenges
uh and changes due to this pandemic uh
and so a lot of dedicated work important
work is going to need to continue
uh we're gonna need to be more focused
than ever uh to meet some pretty
aggressive goals and
standards we've set for our ourselves
and stay on this path of reimagining
public education in portland so our
school leaders as they do
every summer are going to still come
together
it's not quite going to be the week-long
extravaganza and culture builder that
uh we're going to miss not being able to
do but they are going to come together
for a couple of days
to really prepare and plan for welcoming
and engaging our students
for a positive school opening even if
it's virtual so
as we work to provide and to ensure the
best possible beginning to the school
year
we're eagerly anticipating the day
hopefully soon
with the community's cooperation when we
can welcome students back to school so
that concludes my remarks uh for now
thank you chair
thank you superintendent guerrero um it
is now my
uh honor and pleasure to invite uh
director andrew scott the chair of the
school improvement
bond committee to provide an overview of
how the 2020 bond package was
constructed
great thank you chair lowry
i'm really excited to introduce this
item and i'm going to provide just a
quick
overview um and then also give a chance
to some of our other board members who
are heavily involved throughout the
process to talk about some of the
specifics um i think it's just it's an
exciting day
um and the culmination of many years of
work to get to this point
obviously things have predated my term
on the board um tonight what the board
is deciding is is whether we're going to
ask voters to consider
a 2020 school bond renewal that would
maintain the current tax rate
uh and continue our critical capital
investments um
in our portland public schools um
portland public schools has a long-range
facilities plan that identifies the
district's intent to request voter
approval on capital construction bonds
on a four-year cycle and this is
again continuing that that um continuing
on that four year cycle
that cycle is intended to support um
what really is a multi-decade
multi-billion dollar capital improvement
program to modernize the school
districts aging schools and
as some of you have heard me um sort of
riff before
i spent a lot of time uh in my career
working on
government infrastructure projects and
and trying to find funding
and i i think we're at a really exciting
moment within portland public schools
because
um again we do voters were very generous
in 2012 and generous in 2017
and we're at the point now where if we
can just maintain this tax rate and
continue to come forward with these
um with these bond renewal cycles um you
know it
we we really can over the next couple of
decades um make a huge difference
in in the infrastructure uh in the
schools that our kids attend um so for
this particular measure
back in early 2019 staff began exploring
options
for what a november 2020 bond might look
like
um meetings with the school improvement
bond committee began in october of 2019
um shortly after some new board members
joined and you know over the last nine
months
staff and the board of education have
met to discuss district capital planning
documents and guidance
we've talked about educational and
facility needs assessment and priorities
we've discussed cost estimates and
different financing options
what potential bond projects might look
like what those scenarios might look
like
and we've done our best to get community
and stakeholder input during this time
we propose three different options for
community feedback um and even during
covid
uh we were able to get that feedback
through surveys through focus groups
through polling
and virtual town hall so what we have
before us tonight
um is the culmination of that work it's
an option that will include
increased investments in curriculum and
accessibility
it includes funding to modernize
jefferson high school which i think most
of us would agree all of us would agree
is long overdue
it includes funding for planning design
and pre-construction for the other two
comprehensive high schools cleveland
wilson which will be the two remaining
high schools um
spawn package goes forward and passes
and really makes some significant
progress so that we can come back in
2024 and finish those high schools off
00h 45m 00s
as i think we promised the voters we
would do
and it also includes a focused
investment in realizing a community
vision for
a center for black student excellence
which is the superintendent and others
have talked about we'll talk about
tonight
um is an incredibly exciting vision um
and something i think is really
important at this time
so in you know my view this is a package
it's really well balanced
um it's aligned with the district's
racial equity and social justice policy
um and i think most importantly every
student in the district is going to
benefit from the investments that we're
making in technology
in updated textbooks in the culturally
relevant curriculum
and increased building accessibility for
students staff and families
so that's a high level overview i do
want to turn it over to some of our
other
directors to talk a little bit more
about some of the specifics director
constance she also
served on the school improvement bond
committee and and of course chaired uh
the the school board over this last year
and i was going to um ask if you could
please speak to the
education health safety and
accessibility investments in the bond
package
sure i'm happy to um one other comment i
want to make which you
you touched on a little bit is that um i
want to commend our staff for the public
engagement process
in the development of this bond um
package
you know i think we never could have
imagined five months ago
doing this without the ability to get
together in our school gyms and
cafeterias and really hear from the
community
about what they want to see and we did
things differently we had some sort of
curated focus groups
that um i thought yielded really
authentic
meaningful engagement that um helped us
improve
our thinking on things so um
kudos to uh jonathan garcia and shanice
clark and their whole team
for enabling us to really hear from the
community about what they wanted to see
um andrew i think you went through
things fairly fairly clearly but i'll
speak to
the first couple of elements that we see
in this package and these really came
forward from
the superintendent as he looked at his
vision for transformation for this
district and specifically
how are we going to move student
achievement and as a board we've settled
on
four um achievement-oriented uh goals
and so the superintendent's marching
orders were okay if this is what my
board is going to hold
my team accountable for then i need the
tools to get there
and so the first part of this package is
um to invest in curriculum materials and
that means
you know some traditional materials like
like
books but it also means um access to
online materials and
all kinds of things so i think this is
very um this is a very thoughtful
contribution it's not something that we
have included in our
capital bonds before but given that this
district is
20 plus years behind in curriculum
adoption for virtually every subject in
every
grade level it's sorely needed
and with the voters blessing once we
we and not adopt these new curriculums
then we can be
on a more traditional curriculum
adoption cycle that other
school districts are on to refresh
materials but we we've got to make up
for
lost time and another piece of that too
is
to really have the 21st century
curriculum
that our students are clamoring for and
that they deserve so this means
ethnic studies curriculum that is
integrated into
you know all content areas and all
grades not just as a
standalone elective class or something
that maybe a
a project as a particular teacher we
know that's not what we want for our
students
we want a fully integrated ethnic
studies curriculum so
we have 53.4 million dollars um
that uh makes up that request for
curriculum um we also have 128.2 million
dollar
piece in this bond for technology
and again this is an area where our
district has been sorely behind
in making necessary infrastructure
investments so not only are some of our
internal
um you know some of our internal
hardware
antiquated to the point of like near
failure
but this also includes being able to um
purchase new devices and new
um uh teaching tools uh for
for all of our teachers so that is um
again a
long overdue proposed investment
and um we'll really um bring this
district into
the 21st century um next area that we
have
is in terms of flexible special special
education supports 13.4 million dollars
and
you know i want to call out that i think
in each of each of the categories here
00h 50m 00s
there's been a great deal of
consideration given to
our whole our commitment to
differentiated instruction
so um all means all and so with our
curriculum materials with our technology
those are
those are and intended to and will serve
all of our students
even in the technology ask some of that
um
includes resources for assistive
technology for some of our special
education
students but we also know that we need
to do more and i appreciate
superintendent you bringing up the
anniversary of the americans with
disabilities act because
um it's so important for us and with our
old facilities we have a lot of work to
do
in terms of physical access but we also
have work to do
in terms of the the innovation
and the ways that we serve those
students so
those will support some of our focused
classrooms but
but also more thoughtfully we'll be in
service to
the inclusive education that we want to
see for all of our special education
students in all of our schools
um we also have 33.8 million dollars
recommended
specifically for physical improvements
for accessibility and we know right now
that every
student with a physical disability
cannot attend his or her neighborhood
school or any parent or grandparent or
staff member
um cannot access each of our buildings
which is really
um shameful that's not that that doesn't
represent our our values it doesn't
represent our social justice framework
so
um this um this
amount of money represents first floor
accessibility
in each of our schools um so that's a
huge huge difference it doesn't get us
the whole way there we want all of every
building to be accessible and that's
what our our full modernizations do
like our our beautiful fully modernized
high schools
um but it gets us a long way there
um andrew did you want me to continue
with the health and safety
um yes i believe so
okay sure sure so um
again this is just long overdue
investments
on our ancient infrastructure more than
half of our buildings are over 75
years old some of them are at point of
almost critical failure in some ways
so that includes just over 65 million
dollars for
roof work and of course with that roof
work
comes improvements to seismic um
stabilization
75 million dollars on our mechanical
systems
including our heating and cooling
systems which
are really challenging in all of our
buildings i'm glad no one's having to
teach in one of our
school buildings today because it ends
up being really tough sometimes
um almost 25.9 million dollars in
security investments so this would
would redo all the door locks and all of
our buildings
and camera systems for each of our
buildings again
most of our buildings many built at the
at the turn of the last century
certainly didn't anticipate the kind of
security
um concerns that we're faced with now
and they've got multiple points of entry
and exit so
um this is um really needed work for
that
and then also um an additional 17
million
for um some more seismic improvements
um and and roof stabilization work so
um this is this is all um hugely helpful
for the for the safety
and well-being of our students and our
staff working in our schools every day
so i want to thank the staff for
um really coming up with the thoughtful
prioritized list
for the board to consider because i
think the figure that deputy
superintendent
heard uses is that where we have over
two billion dollars worth of deferred
maintenance
on our facilities in this district so
there are many many more projects that
we could do
but i think what we have before us is a
urgent and thoughtful um list of
the most the most pressing things that
we can address
in the next four years um and i think
that's it from me
great great thank you very much
um uh for that overview um director uh
de paz
uh you played a really critical role in
leading the initiatives related to the
modern nation of jefferson and the
groundbreaking work was
center for black student excellence in
fact um i'll actually just
say and i think i mentioned this to you
before but it was actually your comments
in our board meeting a few weeks ago
that convinced me
that now is the time to move forward on
jefferson so i thank you personally
um for that perspective um i'd love to
hear from you a little bit about
um uh uh the modernization of jefferson
00h 55m 00s
what's included in this bond
i'm sure thank you director scott and
i'm all when you talk i'm also
always listening to you to hear like
michelle's been at this for such a long
time
so thank you for not going on and on
about how many years i've been involved
um so i'm really excited to support the
modernization of jefferson high school
and we've been hearing tonight about
things that are long overdue
for about 170 years portland public
schools has had
issues um failing communities of color
particularly black and
indigenous students since i think it was
william boyd
tried to enroll his children in one of
the two white schools
in 1860 so addressing
the black community's needs are long
overdue but i'm really excited to
support the modernization of jefferson
high
school in this bond in this moment for
so many reasons
one because um it's the first time in my
memory which goes back a long ways i'll
admit
um that pps has seriously taken the
voices of the black community
um but particularly because of the
benefits it'll deliver to black and
brown students
particularly black students who finally
will know
if not directly that their education
matters
black to black students out there who
probably aren't listening on this call
right now your education matters
jefferson's located in a neighborhood
that was once a historically black
neighborhood
but prior to that was a neighborhood of
all immigrants including my father's
family
my father's family some of you have
heard this story
emigrated from panama um to portland in
1947.
my mother's family had been here for
several years by that time having come
from louisiana
um my dad met my mother at dawson park
on the first day he's here and
he joined other immigrants including
chinese americans germans and russians
and those from other europeans in this
neighborhood
we have two onion domes still as
remnants of um
that that early immigrant presence in
albina
the albino neighborhoods um encompassing
king
saban mississippi humboldt
boise elliot are significant today
because the areas
were restricted because it was an area
that was restricted to
housing black people um there that could
live there and only there
having been forced to the neighborhood
after the vanport fled
um but those people that lived there
could not purchase homes
if they did purchase homes like my
grandparents did they had to buy it
through
someone else that was not black there
was
a very thriving business district as
black people realized
that they could earn middle class wages
by becoming business owners
and neighbors looked after each other it
was a different time um dr unthink's
office was located there
um saint martin preschool named after
the only black saint
he's not a black saint anymore they took
his sainthood away but um
there was a preschool where the knot
street um community center is and there
were groceries and meat markets and
and dry cleaners um beauty shops
churches and there were even two black
owned banks
they were they were called negro own
banks one was affiliated through the
naacp and the other one was privately
owned
american state bank but the city and the
mortgage and real estate industries
individuals and banks did not invest in
albina
and you couldn't get a bank loan here as
a result i have two distinct memories
memories of this neighborhood
um about albina was like when i was a
child which was a long time ago
um one is bustling and thriving and
doing all of our business on foot and
the other was a burned out shell of its
former self with
addiction and just incredible
disinvestment
so you can understand why i'm excited
tonight about making
these significant investment in a school
that has historically served black and
brown kids for about 60 years
in addition to the modernization of
jefferson high school
um i'm sorry i've lost my place for just
a moment but
in addition to the modernization of
jefferson high school that's been
serving the bulk of the city's black
students
that has experienced significant
investment from the district
board and administration we today also
have managed the opportunity to invest
in a center for black student excellence
that will be
imagined and brought to life by the
community in partnership with the
district and i just i can't express that
enough so
if this if the plan sounds vague it's
because we want to
keep this opening for the community to
reimagine what this um center looks like
um i imagine that there will be a robust
process that intentionally seeks input
from impacted stakeholders
and i personally hope that the community
will revisit the naming conversation at
jefferson
um i understand that we uh the community
went through a naming conversation
several years ago and from what i hear
from alumni
is they would like to have that
conversation again because times have
changed
so shiny new building aside i'm excited
to realize
acknowledge love cherish and value the
excellence that's the black community
01h 00m 00s
today
to demonstrate our shared vision and
values through this investment
to show kids we care we are listening
and we have big hopes
for them for our communities children
we are a resilient bunch having survived
many many generations of disinvestment
and navigating systems that were not
designed for us to achieve
excellence and yet many of us um have
we've we've survived
so i can't wait to witness um the kids
that we're investing in today as they
cross that stage with their deployments
in hand
headed to the future that we help them
to achieve
i um don't i think i failed to mention
the dollar figure and please correct me
um
dan jung if i'm wrong it's a 300
represents a 365
million dollar investment that's that's
uh 305
million for the modernization of
jefferson and about 60 million for the
center for
black student success
thank you director to pass that was um
um
really important history and and and and
powerful words in this moment so thank
you for sharing
um i think it's a really really exciting
from in from my perspective the most
exciting part of this bond
um vice chair bailey who was also
uh served on the school improvement bond
committee over this last year
um you also participated in the benson
design advisory group from benson and
engage with the multiple pathways to
graduation work can you provide a quick
overview of what's
in this package for that project well
director to pass that's a chef act to
follow
but i am you know we considered uh
a number of options over the last couple
of months in terms of
how to structure this bond uh but one
uh piece of the bond that was in every
one of those
options was rebuilding benson and
building a new
uh building for our multiple pathways to
graduation programs
um so i have been sitting in on those
meetings for benson
director brim edwards has been
representing us in the discussions for
the
uh and excuse me mpg not miles per
gallon multiple pathways to graduation
uh building uh and they're they're a
real contrast
benson is rebuilding
a historic building which
is a real challenge
while the mbg building is brand new
but it was also challenging because of
the variety of programs there
and trying to build something that um
worked for everybody and had some
synergy as well
uh so it's been a a privilege for both
of us to
to sit on on those um
and again one of the um
one of the real areas that this district
has made strides in over the last couple
years
is moving towards a true system of
career and technical education
programs in all of our
high schools but of course benson is the
flagship for that and having a
modern benson will
will help us uh even more
uh deliver state-of-the-art career and
technical education programs for our
students
in partnership with uh businesses and
uh unions across the city so i'm really
excited about that um
when it comes to multiple pathways to
graduation
program one i have to
again thank students from programs like
alliance and pisa
for giving us a swift kick
a couple of these years ago and saying
um
you know what about us
and that really gave us the impetus to
move ahead
and to prioritize uh building that
building
so uh programs that will some of the
uh mpg programs will be in benson some
will be
in the new building
but they'll all have modern facilities
just very excited about that so again
that includes alliance
which is currently split between
alliance at meek
and alliance at benson i'm wearing my
reconnect t-shirt here because the
reconnect program
that goes after students that our high
schools have lost track of
to call them back in and help them get
that diploma
uh will be housed there uh there will be
a teen parent center there
um our dart program that works with the
students in long-term treatment
01h 05m 00s
will be there as well the pisa program
which works with new immigrant students
and i hope i'm not leaving anybody out i
apologize if i am but
some really important programs again
will give some great facilities going
forward
great thank you very much uh vice chair
bailey
um director moore there are three high
schools i mentioned briefly
in in this bond that are going to
benefit from a significant uh
advancement in terms of their
construction or design um could you
share a little bit the cleveland wilson
and roosevelt design and implementation
plans
thank you um i want to give a little bit
of
history not nearly as much as director
to pass but i think it's worth
uh remembering how all of this started
um in 2012 um
the portland community
agreed to voted for a bond uh
which was the first bond for
construction new construction
in portland public schools since 1995
and this is my cat who
says hello um and
in 2012 um it was coming on the heels of
the long range facilities planning
committee
that outlined a 30-year plan to
modernize all of the schools
in portland's um 82 school portfolio
for the 2012 bond uh the the focus
of that bond and and the the initial
focus
for the monetization work was determined
to be
high schools um a lot of the reasons
went into it
uh was partially a product of the time
but
um starting with the 2012 bond portland
public schools
has been modernizing
its entire high school portfolio piece
by piece
and um with this bond
we're going to be tackling jefferson
high school
and then we're also going to be
providing uh
plan funding for
the design and pre-construction planning
for the remaining high schools cleveland
and wilson
that will be completely re-modernized
in addition to that we're providing
funds
for the design and pre-construction work
for roosevelt high school
to be expanded to um
to a 1700 capacity to match
all of the other the capacity of all of
the other high schools
um and the uh
the hope the expectation here is that
um because we're using this bond
the the next four years to do all of
this pre-construction planning
the hope is that these three high
schools will then be
included in a follow-on bond presumably
in 2024
um to continue on this path toward
um and uh if the
2024 bond passes um
with the approval of the voters then
construction
could start as early as 2025. um
so this is another step
in in the in our journey
toward creating 21st century high
schools
um and responding to uh
enrollment growth in north portland and
um it's it's very exciting and this will
allow the the original 2012
conception of this kind of first tranche
of completing um a
level of um schools in the district
um it will maintain the momentum
and will be able to start construction
hopefully as soon as the next bond
passes
so thank you great
thank you um director moore last um but
definitely not least in fact maybe uh
most importantly uh director brett
edwards is chair of the audit committee
can you speak to some of the review and
accountability measures that are going
to be included
in this bond moving forward
i think you're muted uh director madrid
you missed the thank you to you um thank
you director scott
um as director scott mentioned it's
important to note um
that this that the bond tax rate um
in this package is um going to be a
continuation
of the current rate um so it's a renewal
it's a flat rate
um it'll likely be the only bond or levy
01h 10m 00s
on the portland ballots
uh this fall that will not be an
increase or a new tax so really
important for voters to know this is
this is a renewal um it's also important
that we demonstrate to
taxpayers that were good stewards of the
dollars the capital dollars they give us
just
um as we are with the operating dollars
that we receive
um so what will that stewardship looks
like look like first
uh we'll continue to have an independent
external bond performance auditor
sec reviewing the bond expenditures as
they currently do
for the 2017 bond um those audits
are presented and will be presented to
the external bond
accountability committee and to the pps
audit committee
and the audits and the district
responses are all posted online
at pbs.net and second um we'll have an
ongoing review and audit
auditing by our external financial
auditors who will look at internal
controls and compliance with state and
public regulations and laws
and third in addition we have and i feel
bad because like compared to
director de pass's um speech this is all
about the
financial controls and our review and
the
expenditures but i think certainly
important for our taxpayers
so the third sort of layer of auditing
we'll have
we'll have contract auditing which is
looking at the guaranteed maximum price
and they'll review and audit invoices
and change orders
as they currently do and have done with
the franklin high school the grant high
school
and the roosevelt high school
bond projects
so you know as a taxpayer in the chair
the audit committee have confidence that
the expenditures
currently that our bond expenditures
currently receive and
if the voters approve the 2020 bond that
the
expenditures will receive a very
thorough
review and where there have been
issues that the auditors have
raised the district staff has been very
responsive
integrating recommendations and into the
ongoing
operations and work of the
um office of school modernization
in addition um this this time uh the
board
decided to add another pre-referral
check on our bond and expenditure
planning
so the bond accountability committee
which is made up of
community members with professional
expertise um
they currently advise the staff and the
board on the bond
and this in addition to
staff review and board review this
external
um group of beauty experts who volunteer
their times
um also we asked if we could add
another um responsibility
to their current charter so last october
we amended the charter to add
um we asked first but to add
um on to their list of responsibilities
to review uh future district bond
planning
including cost estimate cost estimating
processes
and risk management strategies and
um i will say that the
while the bond accountability committee
has a full plate
they agreed to undertake this so there
were a number of informal meetings
between
staff the bond accountability committee
i know some board members attend those
meetings
but once we had a proposed bond package
the bac met to review the package
that we're gonna that we're considering
tonight and i'm gonna
close my section here by asking
kevin spellman who is the
chair of the bond accountability
committee to give a recap
of their review of the 2020 bond measure
and i
also want to as kevin uh
gets prepared to speak i just want to
thank all the members of the bac because
this was over and above
what we already asked them to do which
is a considerable amount of work in
reviewing the expenditures on behalf of
the district
and the community and protecting
taxpayers investment
so with that hopefully i can turn it
over to kevin
chair lowry is he on i can see mr
spellman
and i see that he is still muted
oh there we go there you are mr spellman
all right thank you director
brim edwards um indeed when when you uh
changed our charter
last october uh another way of
putting it i think was to have us kind
of
take a look at staff's work and ensure
that the amount of
money being asked from the voters on any
future bond
01h 15m 00s
was consistent with the scope that was
being promised so that's the charge we
we took on we met with staff um i think
a total of six or seven
times uh but most of the work was done
as the scope of the proposed program uh
became clearer in the last four or five
weeks
and and i know several of uh you board
members sat
in on some or all of those uh what we
the process we used was we looked at
every piece of the proposed
program and explored how staff had
calculated the associated costs
um and it's i think it's important to
note that this
is not necessarily always a science
sometimes it's an
art and some aspects of the work
are clearly more well defined than
others and really that's where we tried
to bring
our technical expertise and uh ensure
that
staff has brought had brought data in
support of their um
their costing techniques and those where
the scope was still rather undefined
we it's we we tended to explore their
use of professional judgment we asked
questions we made suggestions
uh we asked in some areas for a rethink
and then we reviewed the district's
responses to all of those and i have to
really complement the staff on how they
handled this process
because i'm sure some of our comments
were not necessarily always made
totally artfully but they were
nimble and professional
even though they're working under
extraordinary time pressures with
furloughs etc not to mention
covet etc as far as our conclusion is
concerned we've issued a memo to the
board
and we're pleased to present our
conclusion here that
in our judgment the pricing of the bond
package before you is appropriately
supported by robust
professional cost estimating processes
and risk management strategies
great um thank you and again as
as uh uh director brent edward said
thank you um kevin for your work and the
work of all of these
ac numbers um it's it's really important
we appreciate that we're saying
uh chair lowry i'm going to turn it back
over to you uh for the rest of this um
item excellent thank you uh
director scott we have some public
comments and testimony
on the bond and um each person will have
three minutes to share your thoughts and
we'll begin
with uh kathy reynolds who's gonna speak
with us about mpg good evening can you
hear me
good evening school board members
good my name is kathy reynolds
r-e-y-n-o-l-d-s
pronounced she her and i appreciate
being able to provide testimony
regarding the multiple pathways building
as a central element of the upcoming
bond measure
as a parent of a multiple pathway
student and as a member of their dag
it's been my pleasure to be part of the
process and to bring to you
what mpg does and some of the many
benefits that the new facility will
create for the students who have long
been served
frankly underserved in substandard
facilities
multiple pathways serves majority
students of color black native american
latinx from six weeks of age to age 21
enrolled in schools as well as
district-wide programs
everyone in mpg works tirelessly to
create an education system that works
for all students to make every student
feel welcome
wanted and worthy this is what this new
building will convey to our students
and our families that they are worthy
and that we as a district
value and are making space to center
their experience and their membership
in pps over a thousand families will be
served each year in reconnection
outreach services
alliance high school students will come
together from both the meek and benton
campuses
dark clinton school whose students and
teachers work with three community and
mental health partners
will bring those students together in
their day treatment programs
team parent services will have a child
care facility to serve
mpg and benson high school infants and
partners
in the dag we have been really
intentional in our thinking about how
the facility can reinforce multiple
pathways values
social emotional wellness and have a
deep menu of academic programming for
the students
we have brought trauma-informed design
to the center of our discussion
what the mpg building will provide
includes a welcoming space that is warm
and inviting for all families
specifically for racially diverse
communities we want the entrance to be
that of a living room experience we want
them to be welcome and belong
01h 20m 00s
it's a facility designed for people with
various needs we've heard about ada
wheelchairs strollers varying levels of
anxiety and that provides
private confidential offices for mental
health counseling support
iep testing i mentioned bringing
together the alliance high school
campuses so we can share those valuable
resources
space equipment staff we're going to
have automotive manufacturing digital
media natural resources culinary cte
strands
and dark clinton students will have
access to cte in their building for the
first time ever
teen parents will have access to child
care and social workers at the same
facility of their school
we will have showers mpg serves many
homeless students and yet the current
facilities don't have showers
and laundry we all have food pantry
services for our students and families
who need them we'll have a gym
not just to meet our basic pe
requirements our students need
movement yes but it will also allow for
school assemblies guest speakers
cultural celebrations
our staff and leadership and families
speak about how this building represents
a larger cultural community bringing
families together
were so often displaced so the work that
we are doing is inspiring we know
creating a welcoming space
helps increase enrollment attendance and
graduation as reflected in alliance's
class of 2020
who right now has 132 graduates having
the mpg building in the bond is the
right thing to do
and we know it will raise student
achievement funding the completion of
the building in this bond package
is in complete alignment with the pps
strategic plan
thank you
thank you our uh next speaker is jason
trombley
speaking about the three high schools
good evening can everyone here and see
me yes
perfect good evening chair lowry student
representative
shu members of the board and
superintendent guerrero good evening
for the record my name is jason trombley
spelled t-r-o-m-b-l-e-y
i am both a pps alum and an active
volunteer in pps
recently the co-chair of district
committees addressing enrollment and
school
boundaries a public advocate for the
2017 bond
and recent co-chair of the lincoln high
school dag i'm pleased to be here before
you to speak in favor of the 2020 bond
proposal that is up for consideration
this evening
and the opportunities that lay ahead at
a systemic level
it takes us a large step closer towards
completing the modernization of our
entire high school system portfolio
by investing resources now this
investment provides the wilson high
school community
plenty of time for generations of the
community to come together
and design what this campus will reflect
and stand for when construction is
complete
this bond gives the community time to
work through a series of significant set
of questions that are connected
the name of the new school how the new
design will reflect and incorporate the
next chapter of the school community
and where do and how all students will
engage in learning during construction
for the cleveland high school community
this investment and planning resources
now
helps provide stability for this
community it gives their new principal
time
who recently worked through the early
design and planning process at lincoln
to engage with the community early and
learn from the observations at the
lincoln campus
and work through the cleveland campuses
complexity
for the roosevelt community this
investment is another step forward to
bring their facility to parity with
other modernized
campuses but at a long term level
this work provides an important
investment for future work
as seen in the proposed educational and
accessibility investment section of this
bond package
among the investments here i'd like to
note my support for the middle school
redesign section
this investment package is an important
move because it allows the district to
both codify and fund
what the programs will be for students
in lower grades
and the supports needed to ensure that
all students can access these programs
this investment is essential in some
this bond accomplishes two significant
goals
one it moves us forward towards
completing efforts to modernize our high
school portfolio
and two it provides the district time
and resources to continue its work to
design and invest in curriculum and
services for students in grades k
through eight this allows future bonds
to be crafted to ensure that the
modernization projects
included are designed to help implement
the programs we envision
with our students this bond is the right
step to take
especially in this moment in time and
with that thank you for the opportunity
to testify about the 2020 bond proposal
before you
all this evening
thank you jason our uh next public test
money is from
uh sorry laquita elliott please correct
this bonus pronunciation of your first
name
speaking about the um jefferson and the
center for black accents yes so yes look
at the elliot you have it correct
uh so good evening board members uh my
name is lakita elliott
last name e-l-l-iot and before i talk
01h 25m 00s
about the proposal i just want to tell
you a little bit about who i
am um i'm a proud third generation
alumni of jefferson high school the best
high school in pbs
uh my grandfather attended jefferson in
the 50s
my parents my grandfather led the school
to its first state championship in
basketball
my parents met at jefferson high school
in the 70s and
i actually attended jefferson for
preschool and came back for high school
um i'm the proud parent of a fourth
generation alumni my
uh son graduated from jeff in 2015 and i
currently have a niece attending uh
who's
carrying on the family tradition um
additionally at various times i've
served as a secretary vice president
and president of the jefferson ptsa and
have been here in front of the school
board on many occasions to advocate for
jefferson high school
i tell you those things to give you a
sense of how deep my love is
um for the school of champions
i also want you to know that i've served
on various pps committees uh jason
tromley who just heard from
we have a running joke about who served
on the most committees
and we kind of had a joke about this is
our first one via video
but i served on high school design
committee and also on the long-range
facilities committee with
director bailey and at the time it was
initially suggested that jefferson be
the first school
on the list for upgrade or modernization
and that option was taken off the table
because at the time the school was
starting the middle college
and there were concerns about if it made
sense to uh you know to do a redesign
and disrupt students during um you know
during that start of that new program
but i agreed to that decision with the
understanding that jeff will be on the
next bond and was disappointed that it
was not
it's time now to ensure that the school
is modernized much of the school still
looks the same as it did when my
grandfather attended in the 50s
um i also want you to know a little bit
about my story so i grew up within
blocks of jefferson high school and
attended humboldt and tubman schools
in the eight in the 80s my parents
became addicted to drugs and myself and
my four siblings end up being raised by
my grandmother
my siblings were some of the first sei
students i participated in urban league
of portland programs
my sister attended the alternative
school at the urban league of portland
we sometimes accessed the saturday
school program that was organized by our
community
when i was a student at humboldt there
were teachers and other adults
who had grown up in the neighborhood of
my parents and who knew
um who knew and understood my situation
and were able to provide a level of love
and care that helped me thrive
despite my situation i often tell people
that even though my parents were away in
their addictions i grew up in a
community that cared for me i never felt
like i was lacking the support i needed
to succeed
in a way i grew up in a center for black
excellence
there are people like myself and rakai
adams leader without buying a vision
and they can't get harman johnson the
director of the urban league who grew up
in that
same community um what you see in our
command
continued engagement and service to our
community is a direct result
of the kind of community we grew up in
and what it looks like when a community
invest in their children the reason that
albino vision
and sei and kairos and others in our
community can vision something as big
and bold as the center
for black student excellence is
partially because we've seen an
experience with a thriving connected
black community
where adults are committed to the
education and success of its young
people looks like
in a recent article about rakai adam
she's quoted as saying that the albino
community
that if you looked at it from a wealth
perspective it would have seemed to be
under-resourced and small but to be
inside of it as a black girl
i was surrounded by people who knew my
name and knew my family
and the adults created the environment
for me to be strong
um you may or may not be able to see i'm
wearing my black kids matter shirt from
kairos
um i've also been here in front of the
school board to advocate for kairos on a
lot of occasions
initially when they first applied for
their charter because i believed in the
type of education that they
they provide my nephew was one of the
first graduates
of cairo's and i brought him to a school
board meeting when we were advocating to
keep kairos at um
at humble and at one point during the
meeting he looked over and he was like
wow i didn't know this many people cared
about me in my school
um you have the opportunity in this
investment to create the next generation
of
black young people who know that people
care about them
who can experience growing up in an
educational environment that they can
experience success
and be strong and become the leaders we
need so i urge you to
um to make this investment and to honor
the commitment to the students
at jefferson and the families who will
hopefully
attend jefferson in the future thank you
thank you very much um our next speaker
is oops i scrolled down so i'm missing
my list
our next speaker is roberta phillips
robbins uh also talking about the center
for black excellence
hi can you hear me okay yes
01h 30m 00s
parent of a rising second grader at
cairo's pdx
thank you for the opportunity to share
some thoughts with you this evening
i would like to acknowledge pps's
proactive role in partnering with
cairo's and albania vision trust to
rise to the demands of the current
environment that we are in
only brave and bold leadership will
close the achievement gap in our
district
i acknowledge the pps board and staff
for committing resources specifically
designed to support black children and
their families
it is about high time this legislative
victory would not have been
possible without the important
contributions of civic leaders
including ronnie herndon joyce harris
and many others
champions for black children who refuse
to give up
and accept the same old feeling outcomes
for our community
let me be clear in this moment and
through
this bond referral you have an
opportunity to bring us all closer to
the vision established in brown v border
bed
the truth is that america has failed
black children
and portland public schools has failed
black children
within this district black children have
succumbed to disproportionate discipline
abysmal graduation rates and referral to
the criminal justice system
and those are just the highly publicized
failures
let's talk about the failures we can't
easily quantify
black children shuffled into lower
performing schools and programs
black children who leave a system
believing that they are not meant to
reach their potential
how many physicians scholars award win
winning artists and entrepreneurs
would we have within the black community
if our children were
to reach their potential again that
number is difficult to quantify
but i offer that even one is
unacceptable
in failing black children this body has
failed black families and it's failed
the black community
an important step in the right direction
is to support the center for black
student excellence
and i urge you to take that important
step thank you so much for your time
thank you our next speaker is angela
jarvis holland
at stream at the ada
hello can you hear me
okay well i just want to say how moved i
felt by the testimony that i've heard
and
it's like we each have a slot where
we're speaking to one piece of this bond
but i think it's really important
that i just acknowledge black lives
matter and that all of these pieces need
to connect the rasj
framework um and ada is a piece of that
framework in my mind and um
it is the 30th anniversary and my
community were very
pleased that there was a reconsideration
and
um support for some important changes
made by the board last week and um
i've been talking a lot i represent 5
000 families and disability crosses
every boundary there are people of all
races
or incomes or sexualities who experience
disabilities so it's kind of a
interesting intersection
but i think that what we have is this
moment and this reminder from
our wider community to really pay
attention
and this possibility and i commend the
leadership of guadalupe
and i commend the black volunteers
leaders teachers who are willing to come
back to the table
the same as somebody that was with me 12
years ago working on ada
came back and gave me testimony and
talked to me and
encouraged me to keep me me motivated
and come back and work
with the school board it's a moment for
us to
realize our interconnections so ada
is about belonging and i think that's
really what this bond is about
it's about belonging because if we have
a hierarchy of need
nobody can learn if they don't believe
they belong
if we don't believe we belong our minds
are troubled our ability to learn is not
with us
and then the curriculum and the
intersections
and the respect is the next layer that
we need help with
so ada is long overdue
i'm hoping in the next bond we we
complete pay in the debt that is is owed
but i'm also excited
to see these pieces fit together and i
make a commitment as a
woman a white woman a privilege that i'm
looking for how
i will bring my best self to the table
as i represent many other folks voices
and how i'll elevate their voices in the
in the work ahead um and i think if we
01h 35m 00s
can
all speak to these intersections and
speak
with pride about what's being attempted
here
as we try and market and encourage
people
to support this bond then portland's
going to be a better place and portland
public schools will be a place that we
can really truly be proud of
so i just like the thought that i'm
standing alongside so many other
warriors i consider myself a social
justice warrior
my two children went through portland
public schools one had mental health
issues
and is an incredible artist daniel my
son has down syndrome there were
difficult days he considers himself a
media guy and went to benson
i can see that we were able to carve a
space
with privilege i don't want people to
have to hack their way through
to find justice i want us to put a path
in front of them
that says welcome and i'm grateful to be
part of this community of pps and this
community of people on this call this
evening
thank you
um our final speaker tonight will be
michael alexander
i am trying to get uh can you hear me
yes okay and can you see me
no good let's start here and
see if that okay um
my name is michael alexander last name
is a-l-e-x-a-n-d-e-r
and um i am actually secretary of albino
vision trust
and also past president of the urban
league of portland
i want to extend greetings to all on the
call tonight and particularly
to the board albania vision trust
is pleased to offer endorsement and
support
for the proposed bond renewal and we are
particularly excited about
the commitment to the revitalization and
renovation of
jefferson and looking into the creation
and the planning and design of the
center for black student excellence
you know i really could have given my
time
to direct to the past as she offered her
comments
because they reflected many of my own
thoughts it's not lost on any of us that
the portland
school board in its 170 year history
was created at a time when the
accountability and the service to
black oregonians was not a part of its
portfolio
and clearly base assumptions that were
built into that system and others
embrace concepts of racism and cultural
deprivation that we have had to address
over
time i commend the school board for its
commitment
10 years ago to its policy of racial
equity
and over the course of that time there's
been ongoing efforts
to begin to unpack some of the
impacts of that work and that
mitigation against the efforts of the
needs of black communities
here in oregon and particularly in
portland but i think the
events of the last several weeks have
told us that whatever we've done
it's not been enough and clearly
one of the takeaways is that you cannot
fix
what you won't face and i am heartened
by the resolution that was passed by the
board in its june meeting
and the language contained within this
resolution which
owns up to the history
that has been a part of the
non-performance
of the school board over the course of
many
many decades we have an opportunity now
to create new history we have an
opportunity now
to begin to invest in the students in
this community who
are most deserving of the best that we
can do
and the center for blacks to student
excellence
is a wonderful opportunity for us to
step back
and create a new pathway it's clear
that many of the things that have been a
part of our history need to be revisited
i support
director the past and looking at
particularly naming convention changes
some of you were here several months ago
when
mayor landrieu michelangelo from new
orleans came and spoke
and talked about the challenges he faced
in removing
um confederate statues monuments to the
confederacy
but you know that's only a part of it
it's wonderful that our children do not
have to walk
past institutions that are named after
individuals
many of whom whose primary distinction
was largely associated with their
01h 40m 00s
support and endorsement
of slavery but it's equally important to
identify what we replace it with
and we have the opportunity with this
center and the innovations
of concept pedagogy and partnership
with organizations here locally that
have absolutely committed themselves
to advancing the educational dreams and
interests
of black children as their core mission
sei
cairo's the work that's being done at
rosemary anderson high school and many
others
we can create new history and so i
commend
superintendent aguero i commend the
leadership team i commend the board
for the courage to not only look at
change but look at the change
that will define the world that our
children and our grandchildren will live
in
that many of us will never see and so
thank you very much for the opportunity
to offer
some comments and know that the albino
vision trust
is fully committed to partnering with
you and to navigating this path
wherever it takes us because we believe
that it will be a noble one
that will put us on the right side of
history
thank you mr alexander i think you're
going to really like what's coming next
uh which is that we are now considering
a resolution
in support of centering black student
excellence in berlin public schools
russia depos would you please read the
resolution aloud
are you there michelle
she had texted me that she was having
some uh internet issues
i am we can hear you
so that's good yeah so
okay
okay yeah i'm sorry i'm having um some
some issues mr alexander i heard about
maybe a third of your testimony but
thank you anyhow for being here
um so bear with me this is long but it's
important
it's a resolution in support of the
center for black student excellence
in portland public schools in 2019 the
board of education adopted pps
reimagined
a community driven vision for what we
want for the graduates
systems system and educators of the
portland public schools
this ambitious vision represents the
values and aspirations of thousands of
portland students
families staff partners and members of
the community
and our articulates our foundational and
enduring belief in racial equity and
social justice
and that all students can succeed
academically
we believe in the fundamental right to
human dignity and believe that
generating an equitable world requires
an educational system
that intentionally disrupts and builds
leaders to disrupt
systems of oppression a decade after the
pps board adopted a historic racial
educational equity policy
that held racial equity and social
justice as central tenets to our
decisions and actions
pps is determined to bring about racial
justice and equity in our district
espousing a counter-narrative for our
black native and students of color
through an updated race racial equity
and social justice framework and plan
pps continues its steadfast commitment
to creating
access to an array of opportunities for
students especially students of color
aligning our cultural norms practices
and structures so that they center the
lived experiences and hopes of our black
native and students of color
developing culturally responsive
practices including equitable budgeting
and strengthening our partnerships with
culturally specific community-based
providers
to tailor individual supports to the
needs of our students
an important aspect of this work is
acknowledging the cultural and
institutional racism that has existed in
our system
since its inception over our history pps
has promoted racist policies
protocols and procedures helping to
reinforce racist cultural narratives
beliefs and norms six years before
oregon proposed a state constitution
banning black people from entering
residing or acquiring property portland
public schools
oregon's now largest school system was
established
for close to 170 years pps
has failed communities of color
especially black and native american
students from the time of its
founding when william brown a resident
of portland in the 1860s
was denied the right to enroll his
children in one of portland's only two
public
elementary schools launching what would
be the first recorded case of racism
against black children in portland
public schools
while our commitment to calling out and
eradicating systems of oppression is
clear in our vision
we also know that cultural and
institutional racism
continues to produce disparities and
negatively impacts lives of our students
of color
specifically black students reflecting
on our community's vision for pps
our core values and educational system
01h 45m 00s
shifts along with the acknowledgment of
persistent racialized predictors for
student outcomes
pps must strategically utilize and
invest resources
in a targeted and culturally responsive
manner to achieve racial equity and
social justice
cultural specific culturally specific
organizations are uniquely positioned to
partner with pps to support our racial
equity and social
justice goals and we rely on our
continued partnerships with them to
implement culturally responsive
family engagement mentoring mentoring
wraparound services and support
on june 11th of this year the board
unanimously approved resolution 6130
declaring that the lives of black
students and our black community matter
and committing to working with the
portland community to create the
conditions for every student
especially our black and native students
who experience the greatest challenges
to realize the vision of the graduate
portrait
the albino vision trust is a non-profit
organization facilitating the thoughtful
reinvention
and transformation of the 94 acres of
lower albina
from which thousands of primarily black
residents were forcibly
displaced over decades of urban renewal
recognizing the power and importance of
education albino vision trust
seeks to develop a youth-centered
community in lower albina
that creates opportunities for
portland's next generation of black
people
to learn build wealth and reclaim home
this albino vision neighborhood this
albino
neighborhood would allow for intentional
design for the safety of black and brown
children
in the urban environment while at the
same time providing the housing and
community stability
that supports education equitable access
to public education has long been a key
component of the civil rights movement
and fight for racial justice
building on the legacy of advocacy for
black children in portland and catalyzed
by the social movement for black lives
black portland community leaders have
put forth the concept of the center for
black student excellence
this concept endeavors to center the
experience
promote opportunities accelerate
outcomes and celebrate the achievements
of portland's black children this new
collective impact
effort channels the decades of visionary
leadership and culturally responsive and
pedagogic kind of glide
i'm sorry stumbling kind of
pedagogically
sustaining approaches of community-based
non-profits like self-enhancement inc
and cairo's pdx among other black led
culturally specific organizations
here in portland this emerging
community-led concept
seeks seeks to unify and elevate the
educational experience of portland's
black children
and their families connecting a
constellation of community schools
such as boise elliot humboldt elementary
dr martin luther king jr elementary
tubman middle school and jefferson high
school and black-led community-based
organizations in the albino neighborhood
which there are many the center for
black student excellence will work with
the students families and community
stakeholders to develop a coherent set
of strategies that will positively
impact student achievement and outcomes
while affirming student identity
and will include promoting and
supporting culturally responsive
sustaining teaching and learning from
cradle to career
the center for black student excellence
will serve as a living expression
of portland public schools expressed
commitment to black lives
and will help advance pps's mission to
prepare students for
competition to be compassionate critical
careers
on july 28 2020 tonight the pps board
will consider adopting a resolution
to place a general obligation bond on
the november 3rd 2020 ballot
if approved the proposed bond will
allocate up to 371 million
off by 6 million to modernize jefferson
high school and will launch the design
and implementation of the center for
black student excellence in neighborhood
schools and facilities
in north and northeast portland
especially in the heart of historic
albino neighborhood
i now therefore the board of education
affirms that it will stand shoulder to
shoulder with the black community who
continue
to be central to building this nation
who have fought and continue to fight
for more just and equitable
opportunities
here in portland and across the united
states
stands strongly in its commitment to
authentically listen
learn and partner with our community's
black elders and listen to our black
youth
to address the cultural and
institutional system that have
it has existed in our system since its
inception
commits to affirming its long-held
belief to lead a robust racial equity
and social justice agenda
and centering the lived experiences of
our black students
these educators and staff in our actions
decisions and words
firmly stand behind the communication
inspired idea of the center for black
student excellence
01h 50m 00s
both as a physically built environment
and as a designated set of culturally
responsive studies
immediate and long-term plans and
culturally specific partnerships
to advance black student achievement in
pps
affirms the phased approach to
implementation
based on the center for black student
excellence conceptualizing
an overall plan starting with phase one
focused investments in north and
portland facili facilitates funded
facilitated funded through
the general obligation bond referred to
the november 3rd 2020 ballot
if approved by voters directs the
superintendent to resource and develop a
clear roadmap for the design of the
center for black student excellence
an initiative that focuses on group of
community schools
by supporting optimal teaching and
learning environments and promoting
culturally responsive strategies
and to continue to partner with
culturally specific black led
and black serving community-based
organizations to develop these plans
and finally requests that the
superintendent divide their public
updates to the board of education
on the progress made toward the
conceptual design and implementation
of the center for black student
excellence
thank you director depos before i turn
this over to superintendent guerrero i
did want to apologize for any confusion
i caused by saying that was the last
public comment that was the last public
comment
of that section don't worry we have like
four more sections of public comment
tonight
so if you're anxiously waiting to share
there is ample opportunity um
the superintendent ferrero i'm going to
turn it over to you to introduce this
item
thank you chair lowry and and thank you
director
de paz for for reading what i think is a
very
strongly worded ambitious uh
and inspiring resolution
i hope you're feeling directors a little
bit of what i'm feeling as i listen
to each of you describe key elements
of this bond campaign
because in my short tenure here in
portland
what's going through my mind is late
evenings hearing
alliance students talk about um
facilities they don't have access to i'm
thinking of
saturday mornings with spanish-speaking
mothers of special needs students thank
you angela
i'm thinking of all those critical
voices
many of whom we've heard here tonight
uh in particular community leaders that
i want to well recognize have been
engaged in this advocacy for a long time
and i'm just proud that we're at this
moment
this evening in this milestone to
address so many wonderful aspects
that are going to mean so much to our
students
not just in their learning environment
to their health and safety
to hopefully not walk around with 20
year old textbooks held together by duct
tape
of course i'm excited about
instructional materials
but i've got to say the the element that
for me
stands out the most is is the one that
we have just heard a lot of testimony
about
and that's actually following through on
investing in our black students
specifically
this concept of
[Music]
a center for black excellence which by
the way represents the geographical
constellation of school communities but
more importantly an approach
of culturally sustaining pedagogy and
practices that lifts up
the gifts and talents of our black
students
i'm thinking of endless conversations
with leaders like mr tony hopson thank
you for being with us here this evening
who says often to me
we know how to do this right and i think
this
this is an opportunity to really engage
in that
collective impact that uh director to
pass you were just referring to
uh that together we we can actually
create that counter narrative
here in portland we can be that
demonstration we can
do what we know is possible uh
particularly when there's
such a rich history here in the city
uh thank you laquita for for sharing
that uh
your your story uh in the same way that
that director depass did
as well so um i'd be very excited to
receive
this kind of a directive from our
directors
as it considers this resolution i can't
01h 55m 00s
think of
a more powerful mandate to have
and and to jump into this work uh in the
same way that i know that the staff
would look forward to to addressing all
those other elements so
i just want to commend the directors for
uh what i'm hearing
uh is a really grand consensus on an
ambitious and ambitious agenda for
for every one of our students but
especially those uh
who we haven't provided that same
opportunity so so thank you for this
for reaching this milestone this evening
thank you superintendent guerrero the
board will now bring forward
resolution number 6150 resolution in
support of
centering black student excellence in
portland public schools
do i have a motion go moved
second second
go ahead director constand moves and
director to past seconds the motion to
adopt resolution 6150
and i believe there are two public
public comment
comments on resolution 50. is that
correct ms bradshaw
yes we have first joe mcferrin
all right mr mcferrin
can you hear me oh good
good evening chair lowry pps board
members superintendent
guerrero and attendees president this
evening my name is joe mcferrin
spelled m c capital f
e r r i n
second i serve as president and ceo of
portland oic in the rosemary anderson
schools
in my work i have spent the last 25
years
providing a safety net of education
youth development and wrap-around
services
for african-american students suspended
expelled and pushed out of the portland
public school system
and other district systems throughout
multnomah county
and many of these students have been
disproportionately
involved with the juvenile justice
center
i enthusiastically support
the portland public schools 2020 bond
renewal to include the center for black
excellence
i would like to commend the district
for all your work your courage
for partnering with cairo's the albina
trust
to ensure that black children have
access to the highest quality
education they deserve
and that so many of our ancestors fought
and died for yes vote for the center for
black student excellence from pps will
signal to the black community locally
and throughout this country that you are
serious about
equity unlike so many
other private and public sector
organizations
that have used the concept of equity in
a hollow
and superficial way to appease
stakeholders
i sit before you as a result
of the center for black student
excellence
in its concepts from the first grade to
the third grade
i attended the black educational center
bec was led by ronnie herndon
and you all know
how much of a advocate and effective
leader
he has been for our community
and my homeroom teacher was joyce harris
who taught me how to read
my experience at the black educational
center gave me the confidence and the
skills
to succeed academically despite the
challenges i
ultimately faced in pps
grounded in low expectations
while in high school i participated in
sci
where i was counseled by
african-american men who instilled in me
that failure was not an option
and pushed me to reach my full potential
as a student athlete
to conduct myself with the highest
level of integrity
the center for black student excellence
will give so many african
american students the true history
of the contributions of black people to
02h 00m 00s
building to the building of this
country and the confidence
belief and trust and tools
a need to prosper
i will do whatever i can to ensure
the success for the center of black
student excellence
and i'll say this as i close a couple of
things
i remember having dinner with guadalupe
um when he arrived early
uh on the scene and i have to admit
that i wasn't quite sure
where he was going or his real
commitment
but i gotta say uh and i want to say it
publicly
superintendent guadalupe has
uh continued to step
up for black kids
and other kids of color in a way that
i haven't seen before and i just wanted
to
to call that out i really appreciate
your leadership
i look forward to walking alongside you
and support you in any way that i can
lastly i'll say this i have a grandchild
i have another one on the way
and
knowing that there's going to be a
center for black student excellence
in our community i don't have to
consider a central catholic
necessarily i don't have to consider a
catelyn gable
i can consider
a portland public school
will support them in a way
that i was supported in our community
as a child thank you
joe uh miss bradshaw i understand we
have one more
public comment on this part don't worry
yeah tony hobson
yeah can you hear me yes sir
right uh for the record my name is tony
hopson senior
is at peter s-o-n i'm the president
ceo self-enhancement inc let me just say
uh good evening
to uh to the board to all the staff of
portland public schools and all of the
participants that are on this
very long call i have the distinct
pleasure tonight
to speak to you as a past student of
jefferson high school
a past parent of jefferson high school
grandparent of jefferson high school a
staff member
of jefferson high school and a staff
member of portland public schools for
over 10 years i have 55 years of
experience
within portland public schools we are
looking at a vote tonight
that would move forward a bond measure
to modernize
jefferson high school and provide
resources
to pursue the concept center for black
excellence
first in the resolution you recognize
and acknowledge the cultural and
institutional racism that has existed
within portland public schools
for decades with that we should also
acknowledge
if not for that same institutional
racism
the jefferson modernization would have
been one of the first efforts of
modernization
and not one of the last tonight
we entertain the concept of black
student excellence
as if it's a new concept we have had
black student excellence in the
jefferson cluster in spite of the
district's systemic racism
there are examples of that black
excellence speaking tonight
and other examples that have presented
to you before
we in the black community have always
had the solutions to our educational
challenges
but often we've lacked the resources
and power to do what's right
when we do have the support from the
district you have examples like
cairo's pdx poic
and sei that clearly show what success
for black children
can look like the jefferson high school
example of black student graduation
rates
exceeding the district's graduation
rates for white students
is an obvious clear example
exactly what portland public schools
says it wants to achieve
02h 05m 00s
no achievement gap between white
students and students of color
so we understand that adopting a racial
equity policy 10 years ago
did not move the needle for black
students
so in today's climate we know that
saying
it is simply not enough we absolutely
must do it
portland public schools by itself has no
history to suggest it can get the job
done for black students
but together let me say that again but
together
within this resolution that outlines a
true partnership between portland public
schools
the black community and successful
proven black organizations we can create
an environment
of support and leadership that will
create
a true culture of success
success not only for black students
but for all students that are touched by
love
by respect and high expectations
that must exist for every each and every
student
so tonight i gladly support this bond
with the center for black excellence
recognizing that the community has been
doing its part for years
and is ready to go for this school board
representing decades of disappointment
in the black community
to now have this amazing amazing
opportunity to create support
and directly impact the success of black
children and families
is an unbelievable moment in time
unbelievable moment in time one that we
must must take advantage of
you cannot change the district's past
but as board members you can surely
provide the light
and pathway for a more equitable
future so like joe and others i say
please vote yes on this
it could help provide an opportunity
truly for all of us
to breathe thank you
thank you ms bradshaw is there any other
public comment
on this not on this resolution
right is there any board discussion on
this resolution
yes i have a couple things i'm just
sitting here kind of stunned by the
incredibly inspiring words
of our community partners and to to
honor and
um acknowledge what mr hobson was just
saying about how so many of you have
been doing this work for so long
and have the resources in the community
to
to fulfill the dream that we all want
for our black students
um and now here we are able to invest so
just incredible gratitude to to you to
mr mcferrin to
um laquita elliott for her role as a
parent
activist to uh michael alexander for
just
always showing up at different times
always keeping an eye on this board in
the school district and
looking out for the kids and and
importantly our black students um
it's incredibly inspiring and um
especially because this is a
collaborative effort
and because our vision for a center for
black student excellence
not only is it realized but it's not
even fully imagined yet
it's a glimmer and a dream that we're
going to build together
so um i'm just a little stunned
and deeply grateful for all of you
and for my colleagues um for bringing
this forward as well
and um now to be a total downer actually
i have just one
tiny little um little picky uh
piece on this resolution which is
actually in the recitals and i think we
could handle this through
a friendly amendment but um in the
last recital it says the proposed bond
would allocate up to 371 million to
modernize jeopardize
jefferson high school and will launch
the design and implementation of the
center for black student excellence
etc and um just to be
to be consistent um nowhere else in any
of our bond
language or our options have we
referred to that number in aggregate the
estimate for jefferson high school
and the center for black student
excellence and so
um i think um i wouldn't want to
inadvertently
um somehow take away from
what we are earmarking for the center
for black excellence
should there be any budget issues with
02h 10m 00s
jefferson high school so
i think um in order to just make the
language more consistent if we just
um remove the word will so it reads
would allocate up to 371 million to
modernize jefferson high school
and launch the design and implementation
um because at least to my mind it it
looks like those could be
read as two separate efforts
so if uh if everyone will humor me with
that friendly amendment um it makes me a
little more comfortable that it's more
in alignment with
how we refer to to this proposal
elsewhere
all right sorry
i was going to check in with liz to see
if that was kosher
uh hearing no objection i think we can
uh
deem that approved on a friendly
amendment basis
excellent and i apologize for the
language i just used was inappropriate
so
if it was uh clear that that was okay um
is there any further discussion on this
resolution
so this is uh director from edwards
um this is a
reflection on both the center but also
the jefferson high school component of
the
of the bond and um as a long i haven't
been around quite as long
as mr hobson um but almost
um i've been engaged with pps since 1966
and i
was very moved listening to the director
to pass read the words
of the resolution because we have a lot
to reflect on as
a school district and um we have a lot
of ways in which
we have um
really done damage to the black
community
in portland as an as an institution
and i think tonight
i think there's it's two big steps we
have the many other things we need to do
but i think one of the things that i
want to acknowledge
is um the student voice over the last um
10 years in 2011 when the bond
failed when jefferson was in it and then
the next year when they didn't
weren't in the bond
it would have been easy for community
members to have just given up on pps
but students consistently use their
voice
to speak to
what they felt what was needed for them
to be successful
and having met with
students over the last five years um
i know one of the things they very
clearly said was
the condition of jefferson high school
really was a reflection
they felt a reflection on how the what
the community felt about them because
the condition of the school
building was so poor and
that um if we if we wouldn't want that
for our own children
why should that be okay for for the
students of jefferson
and um so i think i want to thank the
students for really
holding adults accountable and i want to
thank
tony and all the other members of the
community
who consistently have
shown up because they shouldn't have to
to hold the board
accountable for doing the right thing
and i
i do know that we have an opportunity
to really make a difference tonight
and again it's not everything but i
think the students the staff
um jefferson and their community
partners have
done their piece and now it's time for
us to do our so i'm
really excited this is in the bond
package and
i know our community is as well
thank you director broome edwards any
further discussion
all right the board will now vote on
resolution number 6150
resolution supporting centering black
student excellence in portland
all in favor please indicate by saying
yes
yes yes yes
all opposed please indicate by saying no
are there any abstentions
resolution 6150 is approved by a vote of
seven to
zero with student representative shu
voting
yes excellent
the board will now bring forward
resolution number
6151 a resolution of portland public
schools multnomah county school district
number 1j
multnomah county oregon calling a
02h 15m 00s
measure election to submit to the
electors of the district the question of
authorizing
1 billion 208 million dollars of general
obligation bonds
and providing for related matters do i
have a motion
so moved second director from edwards
moves and director conte
sam seconds the motion to adopt
resolution 61-51
ms bradshaw is there any public comment
on resolution 6151
yes we have mine frozen
mr rosen are you there i saw you earlier
great i'm gonna get one of those
t-shirts that says you're on mute
okay you're unmuted now mr rosen
okay great um
so good evening or good laden tonight
board chair lowry board directors and
superintendent guerrero i'm mike rosen
last name r-o-s-e-n
and i'm very excited about the 2020 bond
proposal and very appreciative of the
scope
particularly the health safety and
accessibility
portions we started this work in 2015
through the health safety and
accessibility committee which i
chaired and we recognized this as a
long-term commitment
and seeing the board continue this
investment is critical
as a parent of three cleveland high
school graduates i appreciate the
investment in cleveland high school
and wilson high school and then
finally the investment in
jefferson high school center for black
excellence is critical
in these times and absolutely necessary
right now i represent the board of the
northwest down syndrome
association in all born in we're an
organization
a nonprofit with a very wide reach in
the disability community
our annual and we're up to 16 years our
annual
all born in conference attracts 600
people
our facebook page exceeds 5 000
families and our influence is national
and as such we feel ourselves to be
an important ally and resource for pps
the pps 16 million dollar investment in
making every school's
first floor accessible is historic
and to be celebrated combined with other
accessibility investments
this is a total investment of over 30
million dollars
this i believe represents a nationally
unique commitment
it's important to keep in mind that we
can achieve total ada compliance for
another 60 million dollars
and our hope is that this work will be
completed in the 2024 bond
finally i want to acknowledge the
intersectionality of ada
issues with race and thank pps staff for
recognizing this
i look forward to more racial equity and
social justice discussions
in the area of ada rights and goal
setting
and then in closing i want to thank amy
constand
and julia brim edwards for their strong
and independent leadership
on this issue we wouldn't have achieved
this historic investment without you
and then finally i want to be the first
person in history
to toast you with my ice cold corona
beer
refreshing thank you
thank you mike uh miss bradshaw is there
further public comment
no that concludes public comment
all right is there any board discussion
on this resolution
all right the board will now vote um can
i
can i just say one thing yeah um
i'll keep it brief um this is
um a number of us have been involved in
bond work
since since the world was sludge it
feels like
and and this this bond package really
i think is um extraordinarily responsive
to the world historical moment that
we're
in to pps's
responsibilities that we have
long neglected um
02h 20m 00s
it it's um it's a balanced package
it is going to result in
both long-term and immediate benefits to
students
and um i'm proud to
ask my vote in favor of this um i think
this
is hugely exciting for portland public
school
thank you
[Music]
all right are we ready to vote it's very
exciting i'm super excited
so the board will now vote on resolution
number 6151
a resolution of public schools multnomah
county
school district number one day jump chem
oregon
calling a measure election to submit the
directors of the district the question
of authorizing
billion 208 million dollars of general
obligation bonds
and providing for related matters all in
favor please indicate
saying yes yes
i think everyone's unmuted
doing a lot of moving in the background
all right i will pose please say no
are there any abstentions
all right resolution 6151 is approved by
a vote of seven to zero with student
representative shu voting
yes all right thank you members i would
like to ask director broome edwards
who will be leading the bond campaign to
briefly speak to the path forward for
the bond measure
great uh thank you director lowry
our chair larry um you know it's been a
long process and
we can't uh wrap up this agenda item
without um
the board giving um our appreciation and
thanks to the staff
uh for really uh
all the work you did to help us design
this package um
also this i want to thank the school
bond improvement committee chair scott
um the committee members and the board
members for all the work they did
around this this package that really is
going to i think inspire
and serve our students well um and
thanking the community members who spoke
so eloquently tonight and supported the
referral
um as we know it wasn't a straight pass
we half we started building this bond
package
last year we continued through the onset
of that pandemic and then the recession
followed by a national reckoning with
racial um
justice and we we made adjustments
in the package um throughout that time
again um i appreciate the work that the
staff did because
um we've positioned ourselves um that
the campaign is ready to take the uh
baton handoff
um we're making the right investments at
the right time
so with the reduction of the referral
tonight the next step will be to
launch the bond campaign we have less
than 100 days
but we'll have a strong and diverse
campaign team and campaign effort
it's a challenging economic time for
portlanders we need to acknowledge that
um this isn't going to be easy voters
are going to
be thoughtful about decisions they make
but we've consistently we consistently
heard
and i think we're well positioned as we
head into the campaign um that our
community wanted us to go big
and be bold and i believe we've we've
done that but we've also been
judicious um and how and how we're doing
that and thoughtful um
the campaign will be sharing more
information in the next couple weeks
uh we're already on twit you know have
twitter handles and instagram and
facebook we're at yes
pdx schools again it's yes pdx
schools it's the same name as the
website we've engaged a campaign team
that has won the last two
pbs bond and levies campaign and we're
looking forward to working
with students parents community members
board members
to get this across the finish line so i
guess i'll just
close close out this chapter of the
referral work and move into the campaign
uh
maybe reflecting on mr hubson's words
that we have an amazing opportunity
and and it's an unbelievable
moment in time so let's go do it
all right deserve the dance break i
think uh
let's take a six minute uh break uh
you'll hear some tunes from the 2016
england high school uh playathon while
we take a stretch break and maybe do
some celebratory dancing
for the referral of the pond director
just one
thing i'd like to add to director bryn
medward's um statement chair lowry
um is first of all thank you julia for
volunteering to
lead this effort for the bond campaign
um it's going to be
interesting campaigning um in
the virtual mode but um just like the
02h 25m 00s
public engagement that
we talked about um that helped us build
this package i know that we can do it
and also you know reflecting on the
strong support that we heard from the
community and testimony tonight that
we've
um been hearing through the from the
community as we've been
considering the different elements to
comprise this bond
um this is this is going to be all hands
on deck we need
our parent leaders across the district
we need our community leaders who share
our same values around creating a center
for black student excellence
and all the other aspects of this work
that are so important
um so this is just a call to our whole
city
um step up this is this these are our
schools
this is our effort um we need your help
and
uh we have to realize this mission that
we have for our district right now
definitely thank you director comstam
all right we'll see you back here in
four minutes
at 9 15. enjoy
02h 30m 00s
2022 as part of that process we outlined
a set of
academic milestones that we intended to
progress monitor
ourselves against and hold ourselves
accountable to
achieving those outcomes for for our
students
uh our plan originally was to come back
to you this fall
with those initial metrics uh to inform
our progress today
but as you know this past spring we
found ourselves navigating a new reality
as a result of covet 19. so instead of
administering
end-of-year annual assessments we had to
change course and
implement distance learning for the
remainder of the year
so just to lend a little bit more
context which really what this is this
evening is more informational
uh i've asked dr russell brown our chief
of systems performance to
to provide an initial update so russ
thank you um and i'm waiting for
someone to pull up the powerpoint for me
perfect i'll get started here
and while that's going on i'd like to
take a moment of privilege just to say
um really feel honored to be part of
this organization
and with this board's leadership i
believe i just
listened to what i consider to be a
historic vote
and for me having been here oh we can
back up with you
um having been here about a year now
you know reflecting back over uh where
we've come
and our sort of our continued um
commitment to an investment uh to our
black and indigenous students
uh is something that i i'm really proud
to to be a part of
and honored that that um i have a chance
to speak this evening
with that i i know it's late so i will
go through this quickly it is
really truly meant to be an
informational item and
a reaffirmation of our commitment to
our goals for our students so if we
could next slide please
again today i just want to remind the
board and commute what those goals are
i want to talk a little bit about the
context i'll i'll expand a little upon
what serving guerrero had mentioned and
then i want to talk about the data
availability so
what we expected to have last year and
what we expect to have
this year um it is just the context and
again information for our work around
these goals as we move forward
next slide please
yeah um as you've heard us speak during
the course of the year we've talked
about our theory of action our
commitment
to our black and indigenous students and
the notion here is that we we wanted to
have high expectations for all our
students
and we wanted to set goals that
incentivized
achievement gaps and that differential
growth that's necessary that some kids
are going to have to cover more academic
ground to catch up
what does that look like and and how can
we move forward with that
and then that commitment to a continuous
improvement cycle that as we move
forward we would continuously look at
the data
and revise given our context i think we
have to look at our data and revise so
next slide please
all of which it was centered on on our
uh graduate portrait
and our our goals and the board goals as
as laid out act as a ladder to this
um fulfilling this vision of the
graduate portrait and so if we go to the
next slide please
the first of those goals focused on
third grade reading
and it acknowledged that there's not
only an achievement gap
between our black and native students
and their white counterparts
but there's also a growth gap and if
we're ever going to close the
achievement gap then we have to
accelerate growth for our students
and really third grade reading at the
end of third grade
um it's one of those gatekeepers it is a
transition point
from students learning to read to
reading to learn and it's an incredibly
important
skill as we move forward and remain so
next slide please
likewise in fifth grade there are some
foundational math skills that are
incredibly important too
and again it's important to accelerate
the growth
of black and indigenous students so that
we can close those achievement
02h 35m 00s
gaps that occur have been persistent but
to close them over time and it
requires again acceleration of growth
all of that builds towards eighth grade
which is the next slide
and the objective for eighth grade
really was more of a summative goal
and the objective here is can we ensure
that
our students are better prepared to
enter high school so that they can
pursue
uh pathways towards post-secondary
readiness
and again laid out on a way to to move
kids forward through this and again
now moving forward to the the high
school goes uh the post-secondary
readiness
next slide please
again a racially explicit goal that
talks about
um closing the gaps between opportunity
for our black and indigenous students
versus versus their white counterparts
in terms of post-secondary readiness one
of the things i
again was really pleased about with this
board and his book
its leadership last year was this
acknowledgement that graduation
while it's an incredibly important step
in a student's life while it literally
doubles a student's
income earning potential in their
lifetime it's necessary but not
sufficient you need those
additional post-secondary readiness
attributes and we've heard students
today talking about
how important it is to to be able to
pursue ap pathways
as they move forward so
those were the goals that were laid out
at the start of the year adopted by the
board in october
i shared those with some of my
colleagues around the country
many of my peers would love to have
boards that were bold enough to adopt
racially explicit goals that target
student growth and achievement in the
way that this board has
so moving forward
and then covet happened and as the
supernova pointed out it was
you know it's really an unprecedented
challenge um to the educational system
across the country
certainly pps isn't uh immune to that
and as the superintendent pointed out
all the assessment activities in the
spring were cancelled either by the
state or the federal government or
or even locally and so some of the data
that we had planned on having as you
mentioned
simply wasn't available at this year
add to that research that's been done um
would suggest that that the growth that
would be expected
uh typically expected an academic year
likely didn't happen and i think that's
not going to be a surprise
to anyone early research on that
says that essentially kids
reading growth last year might only be
two-thirds of what would normally be
expected in math it might only be half
so we're in a very different space than
what
where we wanted to be at the end of this
year and i think it really argues
uh for setting a new baseline it isn't
to say that the goals aren't important
the goals i think are incredibly
important and well stated
but we are clearly in a very different
space moving forward
let's look forward let's look at what
data is available or will be available
in the coming year
for grades three and five we expect to
to have a fall testing window we
we have even piloted a remote assessment
and we expect that we're going to be
able to do remote assessment in the fall
here
and i think it's going to be incredibly
important for our families our students
to have
and our teachers to have that baseline
information to understand where our
students are starting
and to begin to plan to to close those
achievement gaps during the course of
the year
we anticipate having a winter window and
then in the spring
depending on what what happens in terms
of availability of state assessment
we could either do nwa or the state
assessment at the end
for grades three and five as we move
forward
going on to grade eight 8. again last
year
the state assessment window didn't
didn't happen in the spring
we anticipate a march through june
window this year with data that would be
available in september
of the coming year and then finally
going on to high school
where i see a typo and i'll apologize
for that
uh seems like we all have a slip here
there uh
there are two graduation windows not
testing windows one in june and one in
august
but the data for for graduation really
isn't finalized until january
and that involves the resolution of the
cohorts
and where students finish their academic
career
so as we look forward this year we we
anticipate to have more data
and a more complete data picture for our
students in grades three
five eight and and also with our our
seniors at graduation and you know we've
we're putting into place
again uh i think you heard much earlier
in the evening
02h 40m 00s
again the plan for assessment to help
drive instruction and
and drive the instructional plan as we
move forward
last slide please
so again with covid with the
interruption that we've seen
uh it's an unprecedented challenge and
so
um while i think the goals as stated
make a lot of sense
i think we really need to look at our
annual targets and our baseline where we
started
because we're starting in a very very
different place and
i don't think anyone and if they tell
you they're confident in this i'm not
sure what they're basing on
anyone's confident of what
growth will look like under a under this
environment so we i think really do need
to get uh gather
new baseline data uh and
so um i think the other piece that
at least a couple of you had raised is
is
you know wanting to know more about the
availability of data and the timeline
so you know clearly not all the goals
fall on the same timeline
some of them we have early data in terms
of the baseline
for grades three and five we'll have
mid-year data for grade three and five
as well as some projections for grade
eight
we'll have some mid-year data around the
graduation post-secondary readiness
but then when you come around to the end
of the year some of that data
particularly with the state assessment
data isn't available until
until the fall and so data will come at
different points during the course of
the year
graduation data again doesn't come till
january so
as we look at this data over time i
think
we have to set a reporting schedule
where we come back and talk about the
different board goals
over time and we can revisit
what we've learned before but we need to
understand that the goals don't all
the data for the goals isn't all
available at the same time
and i think we're now around a question
if you have them
and i appreciate your your patience this
evening that was
a long information item at the end
all right let's do alphabetical question
asking again
to make sure everybody gets a chance uh
to weigh in
and we'll go in alphabetical order this
time
so director bailey do you have any
questions for dr brown
uh i'm gonna pass at this moment uh
i may come back around with one but i'll
let others go first
director do you have a question
julia you're still muted
i'm saying i don't have a question but i
do have a request
um for a future discussion this is
something just building off of
last year um as we i think um
that uh we had just started this um
process right sort of mid-year right
when the
office was being stood up but the
request i would have
is that we've this year
built out the dashboard so that we have
both
growth and proficiency um so we can see
where we're heading
i'm completely support support growth as
a measurement but i also see
think it's like in somewhat without
context
um and the other piece is
um at the end of last year we didn't get
any of this
this aggregate the the data on the high
school measurements
of what um the cte
and the various other indicators and
um that's a piece that i'd like to have
built out i
am very supportive of the a reset and
um no acknowledging that we're in a
um very unique time
um but i also think now is an
opportunity to build out this sort of
baseline dashboard
um so that it actually so for our
community
it they can see both the growth and
proficiency and they'll be on the same
journey as
we are so
thank you director deposit
i don't have any uh questions at this
time
director constance
thank you so um
one of one of my questions that i
shelved
from the earlier presentation on
reopening was for dr valentino
around his comments around assessment
and
really being able to focus at the
beginning of the year on
um learning loss because
of remote learning and and inevitable
summer slide so i think dr brown
um i will be interested to see when we
02h 45m 00s
do
these assessments at the beginning of
the year
i hope that we we put it in the context
of
our mid-year maps assessment from last
year
and i think
you know i know that part of our
curriculum planning is
um building in um refresh of
proficiency standards from the prior
grade
um to try to get a sense and correct me
if i'm wrong dr valentino
to try to get a sense of um
you know where those kids were and um
where they are now so
i i just will aside from our our march
toward proficiency toward proficiency
i'll be interested to
have the conversation in the context of
just the covet
slide as well
yeah i i think we're all very interested
in
where our students are starting and i i
think that baseline information is
incredibly important
for the purposes of planning and i'm
sorry dr valentino i think i just spoke
over you no i was actually just going to
acknowledge the fact that you've been
spending a great deal of time thinking
about that and we've had
a couple of conversations in different
configurations to think about
how was it that we're going to be
comparing so that we're not comparing
apples to oranges
um but that we're actually measuring in
the right way
um as as julia
indicated the growth and the proficiency
right
over over that period of time in an
authentic way
because one of the one of the things you
need to be able to say is that
the assessment is really not just the
system need for data
but the need to actually be able to
track each individual student
in in in the way that actually will
allow us to
adjust our content but also to help
teachers pivot to practice as needed
my question continues to be about our
middle school portfolio
and how we're moving towards that steps
we're taking and i know with
school looking differently than we had
planned um that that
might be delayed but again we want to
just continue to
move forward on that portfolio because i
think again it is a historic way of
measuring student success and really
offers a lot of opportunities for
students to demonstrate
leadership and those attributes of the
portraits so is there any
additional information on the portfolio
at this point
i do not have any additional information
on the portfolio at this point
i have to admit that um
we have been very busy trying to plan
for what what fall
can look like so um
the director go ahead dr valentina so
yes so what i wanted to uh that
we did slow down a bit because we needed
to refocus
as as as russ indicated but uh we have
been maintaining the focus on three
components and we've integrated the
three so that it actually helps
inside of our middle school redesign
effort is project-based learning
and our portfolios one so that it
actually focuses on the middle school
and that we are able to identify not
only a
a service provider for the portfolios
but that we're
able to use it and integrate it into uh
part of part of our re-entry is to begin
to identify
practices that we can build off of as we
think about the
middle school redesign entry for the
following year with kellogg for example
or any other pilot school
and so where while we did slow down a
bit as as dr brown indicated we're still
maintaining the focus on that
and we are still looking at possible
partners
for both of those areas
i did have one follow-up question just
to make sure i fully understood
everything you said dr brown
are we going to be doing maps testing
this year or is it going to be different
assessments
we will be doing map map assessments
this year
okay so we will be doing that in those
testing windows that you indicated
yes yes how does that work
how does that work yes so
uh the map assessments are computer
adaptive as you guys are aware
and that allows us to be able to
to do it remotely if need be um
again we did a pilot of that with one of
our schools this
past spring learned a lot from that was
very appreciative of that
and we've got some guidance for schools
in terms of
how to communicate with parents about
expectations in terms of the testing
environment
um
you know it should um again
02h 50m 00s
it can be performed on uh on a
chromebook so there's no reason that
that can't
happen so there's no additional i.t
requirement
we're going on to a single sign-on
environment should be easier for
students to pass through
um that being said it is a new
environment so i think we do have to
look at the data when we get it
and look for anomalies and and i would
uh
think that you know when we see
exceptions to the data then you know we
have to contextualize it with
with student performance uh in other
areas you know how are kids doing on
their homework how are they doing on
unit assessments
it has to be part of a constellation of
information for
for our students um we won't be the only
folks doing that
uh our partners at nwa have spent some
quite a bit of time thinking about what
it would mean to to be able to do that
as well
so i i believe it can be done
successfully or i wouldn't recommend it
great director moore do you have any
questions
yes um so i'm going to
be uncharacteristically uh
pollyannish and build off your question
uh cheer larry um and this is more in
the
spirit of a comment and a question um
there is much that has happened related
to covid
most of it not good um
but there may be a tiny little silver
lining here because
um one of the things we were moving
wanting to move towards um for the
eighth grade assessment was
um using portfolios and so much of
the distance learning is going to be
um is gonna of necessity
require students to do some
portfolio-like
work that this might be a stepping stone
um and i i think you already mentioned
that so
um so a little glimmer of
of good news in the midst of a lot of
bad um
i did have one question and that is
about the high school metric
um because when we originally developed
that metric
we we didn't really take into
consideration
um the timing um
the timing of the res of the high school
graduation
related um measures
and um and i'm wondering if you
would recommend that we revisit
the a high school metric and
with the possible revision of
what we want to be using as
as an annual metric because otherwise
it's going to be
unless we use the the mid-year
map results for seniors as well it's
going to be a lagging indicator
by a year right so what would be a
recommendation there
if any so i i think that the metric is
fine
um the data the final data for it's not
available
until january um
i think the challenge with that is
you know when it's interwoven with the
superintendent's evaluation
it's and so i guess i would say let's
think about decoupling those two things
and how would we wish to decouple that
and what
because i think the metric as written
really captures the essence of what
we're trying to do
with the portrait of grad and so i
i would be reluctant to move away from
that
but let's talk about what we could base
it on and that i think could be a
mid-year progress measure
um much like we did this year
director scott do you have any questions
um no not a question just to comment um
i appreciate the information and the
reframing
i think with all performance management
um it evolves over time
um both the measures evolve as well as
the targets and
you know we have to do this all the time
um with with normal events
sort of taking a not revisit pandemic is
not a normal event and so
um it's sort of recognizing that and you
know i i think
um i i don't wanna and you're not
suggesting this so i
should appreciate it as well we don't
wanna lose any of this data i think we
need to measure where we are and even if
our students have significant
backsliding as a result of this we need
to
to measure that and be clear about it
but i'm also really comfortable with the
uncertainty
for a little while about targets and
until we have a sense of what that new
baseline is and
02h 55m 00s
what the impact is because this is not
obviously impacting just our students
impacting
students throughout the nation and the
world so um so anyway appreciate the
reframing thank you for the information
thank you dr scott student
representative shu do you have any
questions
uh no i don't think so dr khan
sam it looked like you had something
else to add thank you very much
so uh you know when we originally put
together our board goals we had a lot of
conversation
about um trying to have some kind of
metric
around social emotional learning and
i think we finally decided that maybe we
can build it into
the middle school one or we just don't
know
what the right metric would be and so we
let go of that
but i know that there's a lot of
thoughtful planning going on right now
with our remote curriculum
and our protocols and our professional
development
specifically around social emotional
learning because we know that
in addition to proficiency and learning
targets like
a huge important part of this
giant experiment that we're in is making
sure that the
adults in our system are are
are making sure that our kids are okay
and so i feel like
it's hard but maybe there's an
opportunity for us
here to revisit that because there's a
huge amount of focus
on it um given the new delivery model
and so maybe we can come up with some
kind of uh board metric
um that tells us how we're doing in that
respect
i would like to revisit that
all right um is there any further
comment
uh or question for dr brown yeah
just uh mr bailey um
just want to say i i have thought that
there was at least some discussion about
not doing map
this coming year um in any case i'm
i want to echo director scott's comments
that i'm i'm glad we're doing it
i think it's it'll give us a consistent
measure
and and again as a data geek
help us measure what the backslide was
i think that's important going forward
as
we continue to have conversations both
with
our state legislators and our
congressional representatives
about the needs of education going
forward um and having data points like
that
uh could really help in moving those
discussions forward so
i'm glad for that i'm glad that we'll
continue to have
kind of a consistent baseline
measurement going forward
all right thank you very much dr brown
for your presentation tonight
um we are about an hour behind schedule
right now so i wanted to take a quick
moment
and see if um
you all the board members uh wanted to
continue
tonight with our ten o'clock scheduled
meeting which was an executive session
um
so i'm just going to pull the board we
can move it to another night
if you would like or we can go ahead and
go forward with it
director bailey what would you like to
do
i would like to unmute first uh
and it's it's past my bedtime
all right director brim edwards it's not
past my bedtime
but i think there's a mercy rule for
everybody else because i have a lot of
questions
all right all right director deposit
i would be in favor of stopping early or
not early
but
[Music]
um should start all meetings at 10 p.m
um but i'm willing to
let this go yeah i'm good either way
director scott i was undecided until
julia said she had a lot of questions
i say let's put it off okay and
student representative shu because you
don't come to executive sessions i'm not
going to ask your opinion it sounds like
we are going to defer
uh for another time nathaniel i'm sure
you would want us to all keep meeting
because you don't have to come to the
meeting so uh yeah
um all right well we're gonna move on to
committee reports
um sorry accidentally muted myself
um i think our first report is from uh
03h 00m 00s
director broome edwards
do you have a report for tonight
hold on yes um
so the um audit committee
uh met i think about three to four weeks
ago now uh we were supposed to report
the last meeting
uh we received the um
first audit from our internal
performance auditors
it was on the contracts
for pbs and they had a number of
findings
they were appreciative of the
cooperation and
work with the district staff they have
the audit has been posted there were a
number of recommendation findings and
recommendations
um given everything that's happening
with
ordinarily there'd be a
fairly tight window on the turnaround
from staff
on responding and building out
a plan based on the findings and the
recommendations
given everything else is happening with
the reopening of school and the bond
we set a
date of october 1st of when
that next piece of work will be done we
also received an update
on the second audit that the auditors
are working on
which is the ach audit um as everybody
will recall we had a
fraudulent transaction staff asked
that the we put this back on the
district audit plan
we've done that so that is underway
um in addition um given the um
it's the end of the year um in the cycle
and
the board has um the responsibility of
because the independent uh
internal performance auditors report to
the board um
[Music]
there'll be a the performance review of
the internal auditor
uh through the audit committee and i
want to thank um
director de pass for doing
um taking a lead on that and
that will be coming to be delivered to
the rest of the board
shortly again thank you for directed to
pass i know she put
significant amount of work in that and
then um the last piece
was basically looking at the
audit plan for this up next upcoming
year
and that will be
completed probably in the next three or
four weeks
not the out of plan i'm sorry the audit
committee's plan
all right thank you director do you have
any reports to give
i'm sorry are you talking to me no i'm
talking to rita but she's muted
i do have another report oh i'm sorry do
you if you
do i mean it's it's very short it's on
youtube
and then we'll go to rita okay it's very
short it's on the
rose quarter i5 project um
as most people may have read in news
reports
um based on a number of factors
uh that some community groups and
elected leaders have decided not to
participate in the project
and the executives advisory committee
and there was a discussion with board
leadership
in june about pps's position we're in
somewhat a different position than the
rest
of than some of the other community
members and the elected leaders and that
pps never endorsed the project so um
there's not a need to step away and in
fact um
if we want to stay engaged and
actually have the state and
odot address the issues we've raised
around harriet tubman
and the blanchard site that one of the
ways we can do that is staying at the
table
so there's a two-month uh
break for just the summer break when the
committee is not meeting but it's going
to start meeting again in september
and the early discussions have been
that this needs to have a solution
that's greater than odot they don't have
the resources
nor the mandate to
actually address some of the things that
pps need so
in working with courtney wesling and
others
we'll be looking at other ways in which
we can either bring other partners to
the table or the resources at the table
to address the
issues that pps has for that specific
project
any more reports director brim edwards
i'm done thank you
03h 05m 00s
all right now i can let uh director
moore give any reports she might have
um just really quick um the
policy committee will be meeting on
august 3rd
um we're going to be kind of looking
ahead to
um the upcoming work for this year
um one item that
i know we'll be talking about well two
items
um we're gonna be talking about
developing
a um protocol protocols around
communication um related to
upcoming policies so not waiting
to till the end but
kind of um putting
community uh outreach
up front and um and developing
um kind of protocols and timetables so
that we all know what to expect
um and the second item that i know we'll
be talking about is
um a look back on how the
complaint process has been working over
the last two years
uh we're at the two-year mark
after very substantial revisions to the
complaint policy
in 2018 so um we'll be getting the full
board we'll be getting a report
an annual report on the complaint
process um
and the policy committee will be looking
at that and then
getting any recommendations from staff
or community members about any
any room for improvement in the policy
that's all
director scott do you have any report to
give
uh no only that there is a bond
accountability committee meeting
tomorrow night
for any interested board members and
then we are not having another um
improvement committee meeting until i
believe it's august 13th
all right i have one additional piece of
business to discuss
and it's kind of exciting director moore
has been invited to serve as a member of
a state team
formed to apply for a grant presented by
the cdc
and the association of university
centers on disabilities
that would fund a 12-month project to
promote early identification
of children with developmental delays
screening
referral and implementation of services
if the grant application is successful
director moore would continue to serve
on the advisory team
director moore would you like to provide
any more info about the grant
application or the
um anticipated work if it is accepted
um just a little bit um so as you
mentioned
this grant is part of a larger cdc
effort
to improve the well-being of children
with
developmental delays by improving
systems for
screening referral and
provision of timely services the
specific project um is
intended to engage with parents and
caregivers
to identify barriers to appropriate care
that have been revealed or exacerbated
by the covid19 crisis
um and then developing strategies to
overcome those barriers um so
i'll be part of a an advisory team
that's composed of representatives from
[Music]
across the very broad spectrum of um
systems agencies non-profit
organizations that make up the early
childhood system in oregon and um
it's um i think we have a good
i think we have a good chance of getting
this grant and it it could make for some
um important changes to benefit families
and children thank you
i think this is an important opportunity
for us to be able to drive some
investment into this much needed area
um are there any questions from the rest
of the board for director moore
congratulations yeah sounds like a great
opportunity
i also have a question um how um
this work will differ from the work that
already happens in the head start
programs
where there's some you know targeted uh
identification of kids you know they do
hearing screenings
um site
in our head start programs um
so head start is part of this advisory
committee
this advisory team um and this project
in particular is going to focus on
latinx families parents and caregivers
um because especially
probably in particular migrant families
03h 10m 00s
who have been
extraordinarily hard hit by the covet
crisis
um so it's um
head starts um there's a list of about
20
agencies that are part of this advisory
team
so is this happening
is this happening then at the head start
level or is it kindergarten
no this is for young children so this is
pre-school pre-kindergarten
pre-kindergarten so it's you know three
four
basically three and four-year-olds that
started yeah
but potentially um it
ideally we're looking ideally we would
want an early childhood system that
would identify
um any kinds of developmental delays
as early as possible so so the
actual age range that is going to
be looking at is zero to five um because
the earlier you can identify
developmental delays um and um
and the quicker that you can provide
approp
supports and services the more likely
that
the child will not suffer um
you know ill effects that you'll be able
to provide
supports um to
for appropriate operations for the
development development
ways um so that's it i mean the focus
the focus is going to be on trying to
improve
the system uh preventative systems
um and intervention systems
um and in particular focus on latinx
families
thank you
well hearing all of your congratulations
to director moore
i um consider the board to have agreed
that director moore will fulfill this
role on the grant application
and if funded the advisory team
congratulations rita
all right is there any other business
tonight before we adjourn
director bailey yeah yeah yeah very
quickly
um i said in on a
uh benson work
group meeting um as you know where uh
benson will in anticipation of the bond
passing thinking optimistically here
uh benson will move to the marshall
campus well
that school is rebuilt uh work has
already started on the main marshall
building to accommodate them
there's another uh small building that
will be built for cte
space for the program that building
was coming in a bit over budget so our
staff went to work
and trimmed out basically non-essential
non-classroom space
to slightly shrink the footprint of the
building so now it's back on budget
great work staff um
secondly i just got to tour the madison
site construction site again wearing
properly masked and social distance
with a couple of our architects and one
of our staff people
from osm jesse um
that's again that construction is on a
tight timeline but still
uh on on pace to open up in a year
uh it's gonna be great
um and again the timeline uh
wouldn't be so tight except for um
delays from the city of portland in the
permitting process
that were head scratchers frankly
um the other slight issue that's
impacted uh the timeline is covid
and the day after i was there and thank
you dan again for the courtesy call
uh and ironworker tested positive
nowhere near where we were and and
actually isolated from a lot of the
other workers in terms of where their
workspace was
but um again there's there's still some
some cushion there for some uh potential
delays like that that
it's it's going to be a great building
uh and finally talking to the architects
you know kind of like what are the
lessons learned from this
and the architects were unanimous uh if
we can build a new building as opposed
to remodeling that things go
a lot smoother um that's been a real
challenge on that site
um that's all thanks thank you director
bailey
all right i think that brings us uh to a
close
the next meeting of the board will be
03h 15m 00s
held august 11th
at uh 6 pm and this meeting
is now officially adjourned only 40
minutes
Sources
- PPS Board of Education, BoardBook Public View, https://meetings.boardbook.org/Public/Organization/915 (accessed: 2023-01-25T21:27:49.720701Z)
- PPS Communications, "Board of Education" (YouTube playlist), https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL8CC942A46270A16E (accessed: 2023-10-10T04:10:04.879786Z)
- PPS Communications, "PPS Board of Education Meetings" (YouTube playlist), https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLbZtlBHJZmkdC_tt72iEiQXsgBxAQRwtM (accessed: 2023-10-14T01:02:33.351363Z)
- PPS Board of Education, PPS Board of Education - Full Board Meetings (YouTube playlist), https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLk0IYRijyKDW0GVGkV4xIiOAc-j4KVdFh (accessed: 2023-10-11T05:43:28.081119Z)