2013-01-14 PPS School Board Study Session
District | Portland Public Schools |
---|---|
Date | 2013-01-14 |
Time | missing |
Venue | missing |
Meeting Type | study |
Directors Present | missing |
Documents / Media
Notices/Agendas
Materials
01-14-13 Final Packet (8b2e2593ea24e8e4).pdf Meeting Materials
Minutes
Transcripts
Event 1: PPS Board of Education, 01/14/13 Study Session Part 1 of 2
00h 00m 00s
study session of the form education for
January 14 2013 to salt water welcome
everyone present for television viewers
this meeting is been televised live
thank you and we will play throughout
the next two weeks please check the
board website for replay times
interpreters are available in the five
major languages I'd like to ask
interpreters to come to the speaker's
table at this time and introduce
themselves with and stay for they're
going to be located which will be the
lobby potassium voice up in high school
now Rachel eating baked ricotta you come
here olympus I kapamilya Tatiana is full
of motion physical checks Rose covering
second our music folk are appreciative
thank you we're gonna start with public
comment and at this time we're going to
allow 20 minutes for public comment miss
Susan do we have anyone and signed up
for a public comment yes we have six our
first to Greg Garcia and Sienna Shepherd
as you take a seat I'm going to read the
public comment instructions and i know
you have watched this party meetings
before but wanted to state that our
responsibilities support lines in active
listening and protecting thousand
opinions of others guidance of all the
game put emphasize respecting
consideration for referring to port
members staff and other presenters you
have a total three minutes to share your
comments please begin by stating your
name is spelling your last name for the
record during the first two minutes of
your testimony a green light will appear
when you have one minute remaining a
yellow light will go on and when you
time except the red light will go on and
it possible sound we respectfully ask
you that you conclude your comments at
that time we sincerely appreciate your
input and thank you in advance for
cooperation welcome anything I'm Greg
Garcia GA rcia super Dan Smith and Steve
members of the PPS board I begin first
by thanking you for your time we offer
gratitude to Steve Gonzalez artistic
director of Jefferson dance and Margaret
Calvert principal at Jefferson High
School for you all we have dance company
calendars please enjoy them I'm here
tonight speaking on behalf of the
parents whose PPS students might
possibly be affected by the recent
announcement of forced enrollment at
Jefferson High School they wish to
continue as Jefferson dance company
members our issues and concerns as
parents are as follows as much activity
in backpedaling PPS seems to be doing
regarding these few
students not until the recent are the
receipt of a letter dated December 3rd
2012 to Jefferson dance company families
were we ever informed by anyone within
PPS that enrollment requirements were
changing for JD company members you
might have thought administration
communicated to school staff to school
counselors and to high school principals
throughout PPS but nothing nothing until
our letter our receipt of this letter
was ever conveyed to us either verbally
or in writing at the audition phase in
May acceptance phase in june and the
contractual signing and obligating and
committing the students jefferson's
dance company was there ever ever any
written correspondence or verbal
communication tellin esta there would be
enrollment requirements at Jefferson
High School for all the meetings and
internal communications I'm guessing a
heavily administrative and political
organization like PPS mus have not once
did a single delivery of information
reach the actual students whose lives
you are intending to affect with this
newly announced information since 1997
500 or more students have been accepted
a grandfathered into the Jefferson co-op
dance company you can be assured that if
there was clear guidance of enrollment
changes given the students along the way
with their own peer group communication
00h 05m 00s
skills this information would have
quickly and efficiently trickled down to
them but to suddenly announced to a very
few in a December dated 10 line letter
without any prior notice is wildly
inconsistent and clearly unfair to these
already academically committed students
there are only five potentially affected
dance company members the remaining 35
are already grandfather all have already
set their academic course at their
current high schools and they are all
excelling in the spring of 2013 those
not already grandfather Jefferson
company
interested dance students can receive
the Jefferson High School in Holborn
requirement written communication before
deciding to audition accept and
contractually obligated to the Jefferson
dance program but these five some of
whom you are about to meet deserve your
equal grandfathering they deserve your
consistency and they deserve your
commitment but their current academic
course and their dance company
membership will not be disrupted thank
you my name is Sienna Shepherd Sh ep ard
and I'm a sophomore I want to start by
presenting my analogy for this whole
situation it goes something like this
have you ever discovered a type of food
and it was just so good one of those
foods that is guaranteed to always put
you in a good mood your comfort food
maybe it's ice cream maybe it's bacon
now what if i told you that one day the
stores made it so expensive to buy that
food the only way to eat it was to stop
eating anything else what would you do
you would have to choose between your
comfort food and all the other
nutritious things you eat and the worst
part is that price inflation had come
right out of the blue without any
warning the stores had not put up any
sign saying this good is temporarily on
sale and will resume being sold for much
more starting next week so there you are
left to choose between your food
cravings well my name is sienna and my
comfort food is the jefferson dancers I
look forward to going to dance every day
and it is guaranteed to lift my spirits
I'm part of a community there a friends
and teachers and i have already embarked
on a journey in which i grow as a dancer
every day I've seen the Jefferson
dancers perform every year since I can
remember and I finally become a part of
that legacy I was not warned that upon
joining Jefferson's second company I
would be involved into an environment
just to have it taken away from me again
no I just got a short letter in the mail
one day in December what I'm trying to
say is i received no prior warning
before i fell in love with my comfort
food i'm stuck making a choice between
the jefferson dancers and everything
else i eat it's not simple
in any way shape or form I love dancing
at Jefferson but i also have so many
other things that make me a successful
happy person not only if i spent the
last two years making friends at my
current high school i want to set
academic course i'm going to take AP
tests and four classes next year i also
am a full part of my school community
over the last two years I've helped
organize my school's food penny and
blanket drive i participated in
assemblies as well as been involved with
student government different clubs like
math club peer mediators and ski bus
both my school and the Jeffers and
dancers have shaped Who I am they're
part of who I am yet I have to choose to
give up a part of myself quite honestly
I don't think it's fair we just happen
to be part of a number a deadline the
class of 2015 and there are only six
freshmen and sophomore company members
who are stopped choosing between our two
halves Jefferson and our other school
community we have equally invaluable
experiences from both and we cannot
ignore or forget them this is why just
like the juniors who are on Jeffersons
dancers first and second companies we
feel we're equally integrated into both
school and dance programs at a level
that is too deep it would be an immense
hardship to ask us to pull out of one of
them now we kindly request for the six
freshmen and sophomore Jefferson first
and second company members to be
grandfathered in just like the juniors
thank you thank you and I'm going to
remind people that we have three minutes
so if you can stick to that would be
greatly appreciated thank you for coming
our next two speakers are Mikey Garcia
and Natalie ward
my name is Mikey Garcia GA are CIA dear
PBS school board members this evening I
come to you as a student of lincoln high
00h 10m 00s
school as well as a member of the
jefferson dancers in hearing news that
co-op students will have to transfer to
jefferson high school this fall to
continue their dance training I have
been forced to stand at a crossroad
between my education and my upcoming
three years working with the Jefferson
dancers upon hearing this news I
couldn't believe it I was absolutely
devastated i have already planted my
roots in more ways than one at lincoln
high school yet i am being asked to rip
myself away without any prior warning
not only will i be leaving my friends
behind but i'll see a steamed IV track
that i am already on as well as looping
tracks with two of my four teachers
these ties are unmatched at Jefferson
and it would be a complete and utter
hardship to force me to change schools I
know that switching is a personal choice
yet I feel extremely committed to both
programs the emotional hardship of
leaving either program would be
extraordinarily upsetting i will have
wasted a vastly productive year at
lincoln or an immensely inspiring near
with the jefferson dancers neither of
which contain any value if pursued for
only a single year my relationships with
teachers students and faculty would have
to start from scratch or would my dance
training and besides the dance program i
would be arriving into a completely new
atmosphere at jefferson that i would not
be prepared for I was not made aware of
this earlier than December third 2012
when I received a letter welcoming me to
Jefferson High School for the fall of
2013 it was not stated at my audition in
my acceptance letter or even in my
contract with the Jefferson dancers only
in a short undetailed message from the
principal of Jefferson High School that
i received on december 3rd giving me
less than eight weeks to make the
devastating ultimatum
for the rest of my high school career
under these taxing circumstances I
implore you to grandfather the remaining
six students into to the Jefferson
dancers program while still allowing us
to remain at our current high schools
thank you thank you hi my name is
Natalie Warren WA Rd I'm a thriving
student in the IB program at Lincoln
High School and I am on track to test in
3 I be subjects next year over my last
two years at Lincoln I've been preparing
to take my IV exams my June during my
junior year a switch in my educational
path is counterproductive to all the
hard work I put in to the Lincoln High
School IB program the Jefferson High
School middle college program is
beneficial for students entering
Jefferson High School as a freshman
because they are immersed in the plan
curriculum from the very start of their
high school education much like how
Lincoln has started me on a plan
academic path the middle college is
great however at this late in my
education without proper planning it is
not beneficial for me to switch gears
this leads me to my current hardship
facing the decision of abandoning my
current progress at Lincoln for the
excellence of the Jefferson dance
company this year I worked extremely
hard to maintain my high GPA and be a
part of the rigorous and rewarding
Jefferson dancers much like how the IB
program has prepared me academically
Steve Gonzalez of the Jefferson dancers
has contributed greatly towards my
growth as a dancer and artist the
company steve has created allows me to
truly express myself in a safe
environment through dance I am firmly
integrated in the academics at Lincoln
and a change at this point is
unnecessary I'm also learning how to be
a part of a preferred ish professional
dance company under the direction of
Steve Gonzalez which is invulnerable and
I am firmly integrated at Lincoln which
allows me to become such a great student
please grandfather us six students in
and allow us to decide if transferring
mid high school is most beneficial for
us I am torn apart to let go there go of
either Lincoln or Jefferson High School
this hardship is unfair for the six of
us caught in the middle of this
unexpected change please allow us six
students to continue to have a choice
for dual enrollment thank you for your
time thank you lastly we have Elise
cohen and Greg Burrell hi I'm Alice
Cohen coh en and I am a parent of a
second grader at Chief Joe elementary
school i'm also a middle school teacher
in the beaverton district and this is my
first time speaking to the board but I'm
here because I really believe in the
importance of our children's education
00h 15m 00s
as well as the future of our
neighborhood the Jefferson cluster has
seen schools closed and reconfigured and
reconstituted numerous times over the
past decade and we just heard some
students talking about those changes we
know that schools need stability for
success and that schools are the anchor
of communities and we feel like Portland
Public Schools has been cutting our
anchors and then wondering why our
schools are drift these changes in the
enrollment balancing we recognize that
there's going to be some short-term
hardships but we hope that there's going
to be some long-term gains for our
students and for our neighborhoods this
is our chance I believe to reverse this
pattern that we've seen in the Jeff
cluster and to find a way to have very
strong leadership across all of the
schools as well as a rigorous curriculum
for our students as we get them ready
for the 21st century I think this is a
big issue of inequity between the
schools and our cluster as well as
across the district our high school is a
work in progress we're the only cluster
in the district without a middle school
a comprehensive middle school and I
mentioned that I'm a middle school
teacher I've had XP
is teaching in both k aids and
comprehensive schools in the metro area
and I know from firsthand experience
that one type of school does not fit the
needs of all students the importance of
having our students career and college
ready is crucial and I know that a
comprehensive middle school can offer
the types of varied resources that will
meet the needs of a diverse population
more course offerings and services that
can help kids in all areas also the
opportunity to have a relationship with
our high school all of these things are
really developmentally appropriate for
middle school students Chief Joe is a
successful school we have trusted
relationships between the staff and
families and we want to see our success
replicated in schools across our cluster
we want to work with the district and
the parents of the other schools to see
this to fruition I realize that there's
no easy solutions but I hope that you
guys can look to the future and help our
cluster become the strong future that it
can be thank you thank you my name is
Greg Burrell that's be you are our I ll
and born co-chairs members
superintendent Smith ladies and
gentlemen thank you I am a teacher but
today I'm talking to you as an education
stakeholder I want to thank you all
first for the all the work that you do
I've been watching and learning about
how my school system works and I know
you all have a really difficult job
running a school district with less than
eighty percent of the dollars you had
available in 1990 implementing mandates
many of them unfunded from the state and
federal government I've been a Portland
Public School substitute since 2005 and
I have seen the most amazing students
parents teachers administrators
education support personnel coaches
volunteers in the community you name it
we do excellent
work in fact the vast majority of us are
doing a wonderful job considering the
circumstances so I come to you today not
to criticize any dedicated educators and
administrators but to point out a simple
fact the most important job of any human
being is raising and educating the next
generation of human beings there is no
one more important to the future of
America and humanity than parents and
teachers so given the importance of
educated citizens to the future of our
nation we can't continue to create so
many adults who lack the skills
necessary to succeed in a
knowledge-based economy you know when I
eaten faculty lounges and I go to a
different school most every day and my
colleagues don't recognize the letters
Oh eib Oregon in vegetation Investment
Board for those not up on the latest
acronyms I fear for the future of
Education in Oregon when I see how
little assessment can go on in high
schools where teachers have a hundred
and eighty students to grade watch
teachers have 90 students but only paid
for half the job they must do to make a
necessary difference in children's lives
I'm deeply saddened the answer is simple
we must adequately fund education so I'm
here to ask you to do three things first
and this is the hardest believe that
Americans can recover from the era of
talking about taxes as if government
steals taxpayers money and learn how to
00h 20m 00s
talk again about the things of free
people need to spend their tax money on
demonstrate lobby right to
representatives educate agitate for the
money we need for education Public
Safety Public Health and our
infrastructure and do not sit idly by as
the goal of making money overtakes the
value of the things our money pays for
I'll take me awhile to say all I have to
say in three minute increments but I'll
be back thanks for your time and
attention thank you
miss you soon that's it thank you thank
you all for your testimony tonight again
as I mentioned at the bigger beginning
we don't necessarily address and respond
to those things right right away but
they will be given consideration and
staff will also be looking into some of
those things that were raised our next
item on the agenda is the Cleveland
cluster presentation and tonight we will
hear the fourth in our series of high
school cluster presentation this
presentation station different high
school cluster each month we'll allowed
allows the board to conduct a deeper
dive on the milestone data at the school
level we have allocated one hour for
this item 30-minute presentation max 30
minutes for questions from the board and
discussion as a reminder that the
milestones are on the borsa work work
plan isn't as a monitoring I am for us
to pronounce Smith and I'll just start
by welcoming our Cleveland cluster
principles and they're totally
representing across the front of the rim
here so it's good to have you here and
Sue Ann Higgins I'll welcome up to the
front to introduce the presentation and
as director Gonzalez said this has been
our opportunity to really get a view of
what's going on in the cluster what are
the things that are really you're
feeling proud of and that are working
and that are getting really intentional
results for our kids and where are the
places you are feeling challenges so we
look forward to hearing the picture of
the Cleveland cluster Celia good evening
it's a pleasure to welcome the Cleveland
cluster administrators as well as trip
good all our high school director and
Larry Dashiel the Regional Administrator
for the Cleveland cluster Cleveland in
Southeast Portland comprises about 6,500
of our portland public schools students
more students than many whole districts
in our state so it's an honor to just
have them share some of their stores so
you'll see portraits
cific portraits from four of our schools
tonight and have the opportunity to hear
from leaders of those schools thank you
he makes a grant 10 min Smith or chair
Gonzalez and school board members it's
just an honor and a pleasure to be able
to be here tonight with the Cleveland
cluster this is my third year as are a
working with the Cleveland principles
and I also include the high school piece
of that because I had a long career in
the high schools important public
schools so I know the administrators at
Cleveland High School very well and also
put them on my visiting rotation when I
when I visit their environment as you
know the RAS have been visiting schools
and I try to get to them at least once a
month on a regular basis to talk about
equity talk about milestones talk about
discipline and talking about teaching
and learning and that's been a very very
pleasurable experience to be able to do
that I'm glad the job presents itself
that way and so tonight we will have two
elementary principals share and one
middle school principal and assistant
principal and in our high school
principal again it's great to be back
and number four so we're really looking
forward to being able to present
Cleveland so now i'm going to have what
i call the sweet 16 introduce themselves
and then we'll have a presentation from
Cerrejon it done away and Susan McElroy
at grout
good evening my name is Kevin Bacon I'm
the principal at hosford middle school
good evening I'm Maryland John assistant
principal at hosford middle school I
guess we'll stand kit ok mark sandy
lands principal at Winterhaven hello Tim
Lauer principal Lewis elementary Susan
McElroy principal at Daniel grout
00h 25m 00s
elementary school Kevin Taylor
vice-principal cleveland high school
vice-principal ahead cleveland high
school good evening I'm Paul Cook
principal cleveland high school good
evening I'm Sarah hon I'm the proud
principle of Dunaway elementary good
evening I'm Mary Patterson principal at
Woodstock elementary and I'm Lori Clark
I'm the principal at Whitman elementary
Seth Jones the assistant principal at
selwyn and I'm Charlie Russell I'm the
principal at southwood middle school
good evening Brian Anderson Buckman
elementary arts focus Tammy baron
principal and Abernathy steve bell
prints both Llewelyn
Thanks I'm Susan McIlroy and the
principal a Daniel grout elementary
school and so I just want to give you a
little snapshot of my school this
evening some of the things that we're
doing and some of the things that I'm
most proud of at my school we're located
not too far from hosford we have a huge
attendance area all the way from the
river 240th we are in an building that
looks like a lot of portland public
school buildings and we're pushing 90 at
this point but still in great shape
considering our how old our building is
one of the questions I frequently a mask
is where did you get that name and so
Daniel Alexander grout is an early
Portland superintendent from the 1920s
and he has a school named after him
after he passed away he was an early
advocate of something that we take for
granted now and that is having parks and
fields with our school but at the time
that was a novel idea the you've
probably had the demographics in front
of you I put them up here we are a very
diverse school and the demographics
themselves don't tell the whole entire
story we do have to refugee populations
our Somali bond to students came to us
in 2005 we also have a number of Burmese
refugee students our students represent
more than 24 different countries and
speak 20 different languages
our milestones are up there in addition
I've put our overall reading and math
scores and if you're looking at the
milestone data our largest gap is
between our black and white students and
our English language learners there's
quite a bit of overlap most of our black
students are English language learners
and then our special education students
one of our focuses it has been our
school climate we have participated in
both the foundations of safe and civil
schools and are currently participating
in the positive behavior intervention
supports intended to give staff the
skills and tools to work with all
students we do use steps to respect and
second steps as well as other
anti-bullying programs I do keep a
full-time counselor and we do have a
couple of social service interns they
provide social service supports to
families in need we are a play work
school play works is a program designed
to really help students with conflict
resolution so I have a full-time coach
who works with students so all of my
kids know for example the same games
with 20 different languages there's
certainly room for misunderstanding so
for us this really has been a excellent
school climate piece and a leadership
development piece for our students we
have a number of social service
partnerships and grout is a son school
so we have a Parks Department as a
partner providing after school academic
and other classes for the kids in
particular we have tried very hard to be
creative about maintaining an arts
program and arts focus even though we're
not a focus option school we do have a
theatre program for kindergarten through
fifth grade we have a strong visual arts
program and we support that
00h 30m 00s
through residency's and then we are
working with a group called the music
workshop to provide music for our
students we've also maintained a strong
science program particularly partnering
with Reed College and the city of
Portland environmental services and
Parks to provide some of our education
outside of our school we now have two
gardens both a vegetable garden and a
bioswale those are both courtesy of our
PTA and the grant writing done by the
PTA and then you know lastly I just want
to point out that as with most schools
we can't do it alone and so this just
gives you a little bit of idea the
number of community partnerships we have
that support grout the programs that
grout
evening I'm so excited to talk to you
about done away it's one of my favorite
topics so I decided in presenting to you
tonight then I'm going to focus the
entire time on my milestone data it
isn't by accident that we're a
high-achieving and high-performing
school there are a lot of systems and
structures that we have in place that
not only have gotten us to where we are
but our continued growth and so I'm
going to go through those so all of the
slides in the data you'll see I'm
isolated the third grade data so looking
at our third grade demographics data if
you look over the left two years this is
my third year it done away i started in
2010 the first cohort of third graders
that we had close to twenty-five percent
of my third grade students were students
of color and i think that's important to
recognize and Casilla of the
demographics data over the last three
years we have more third-grade students
now than we did when I came to Dunaway
although our our current cohort this
year and the kids were moving towards
milestone we do have fewer kids of color
in third grade this year we're at twelve
percent for our specialist students when
we talk and we think about the milestone
data it done away it isn't just about
third grade we know that starting early
and talking about kinder first and
second grade is just as important if not
more important than what we're doing in
third grade our milestone data for third
grade reading to learn we know that if
we're going to read to learn our focus
is on comprehension in our in reading
research you can see that connection
between vocabulary and comprehension we
focus a lot on vocabulary when students
know fifty percent or less or fewer
words in a passage their reading
comprehension drops and so if we're
talking about reading to learn and
students understanding what they're
reading we really want to focus on
vocabulary and we do that it done away
over the last two years last year for
the last two years we have an increase
in the number of students meeting or
exceeding our milestone benchmark an
eight percent increase for our white
students we have one hundred percent of
our Hispanics to
is that met standard last year and we'll
talk a little bit about the invisible
data that you don't see on here in just
a few minutes we've also had an increase
of five percent for all of our students
meeting milestone data in the last two
years so its expectation of
Superintendent Smith and Larry Dashiel
our Regional Administrator that we have
two things improved achievement for all
students it done way we've demonstrated
that narrowing the gap between groups
and when we compare our Hispanic
students to our white students at times
they're outperforming white students so
one of the things I want to point out
though and I'll of data and I really
liked data analysis is we're at a glance
you might look at the Dunaway data it is
something to celebrate be proud of but
I'm always looking to read between the
lines and what I do and I look and I
analyze our milestone day in the first
year that I was there what's important
to know is that it all of our students
and again this is two thousand ten to
eleven data we had 16 students of color
but when you look at the way the data is
presented when there's a subgroup a
racial subgroup where you have less than
six students represented the data
becomes invisible and so when you look
at that and you can see that from one of
the earlier slides there wasn't a graph
there although there were maybe five
students or for students in that racial
category and it's my expectation of
myself as an instructional leader I
think as a principle that we make sure
we don't let data become invisible
especially when we're talking about
racial data so we did have one hundred
00h 35m 00s
percent of the students Hispanic
students meet the milestone here's the
invisible data the ten students of color
that you didn't see on the graph which
represent fifteen percent of my
third-grade students they weren't
reported because the subgroup may have
had less than six kids so that's where
us tracking students individually and
having conversations monthly and data
teams is very important and we do that
it done away when we look at last year
here's where we read between the lines
again we did have one hundred percent of
our white students meet or exceed the
standard on a milestone but ninety-seven
percent of all students met or exceeded
so of course we can assume that the nine
students of course spread across racial
subgroups there are some students there
who didn't meet when we we isolate that
we want to know who these kids are we're
expected to know every student where
they're at and where they're going and
we know that when we look at that
invisible data for those students were
Hispanic and five of them were
multiracial students and some of them
didn't meet the milestone even though
they didn't show up on our data so how
do we respond it done away to visible
and the invisible data there's a lot
that we do we know where every child is
performing one hundred percent of the
time we use qualitative and quantitative
methods for collecting data on our
students I meet monthly with teachers
they're accountable for their data
they're accountable for their teaching
and we have conversations about that and
they're accountable to each other
although we have had reading support in
the past we don't this year but that
just means we need to work harder as a
team to get kids where they need to be
we focus the last two years on our
professional development for
differentiated instruction even though
we're a high-performing school we have
students who are on IEPs and have goals
we have students that don't speak
English or have limited English
proficiency and it's expected that all
teachers learn how to and implement
differentiated instruction in my role as
an instructional leader in the classroom
is providing feedback to them on what
they need to do to help move kids
forward in their learning and and we
spend time on that too so our largest
gap or our achievement gap it dead away
it lies between our general EDS students
and our students on IEPs and our special
ed students last year we had eight third
grade students on IEPs we worked closely
between our specialized staff and our
general Ludd staff and we had 75 percent
of those students being the milestone at
the end of the year this year we're on
track to have all nine students of our
third grade students that are on IEPs
meet the milestone so things that we do
to respond to our gap that exists have
to do with the connection between our
general LED staff and our specialized
staff and having consistency and our
program implementation so that staff
general Ludd staff and specialized staff
are working together on getting kids to
their goals and reaching their potential
we also involved parents in the
conversation of what we're doing and why
we're doing it we outline their role for
how to help help their child succeed and
how to work closely with the school so
and finally you know we want to continue
to grow as a school we want to move
every kid forward and and so there's
some things that we have in place that
create sustainable growth it's our
sustainable growth model so that each
year we're moving ahead and here's some
of the things specific to the milestone
data we're talking about reading we're
talking about literacy we maintain an
emphasis on quality instruction
especially at k2 of course school-wide
focusing on the big ideas the five areas
implementing our core reading program at
the district with fidelity one thing
that we've done it done away to is
evaluating what we do with kids well
we're in a guided reading group what are
they rest of the kids doing when they're
functioning and working independently in
the classroom we use research based
activities and tasks that we expect kids
we want kids to be able to work
independently but also know that they're
growing in their skills to get them
where they need to be even if they're
not working directly with the teacher or
volunteer we continue to collect a
variety of assessment data that helps to
inform our instruction especially in the
primary and we keep the invisible data
visible it's really important that we
know and where every kid is and and we
have systems in place that done a way to
do that and so when we look at our data
as a school it isn't by accident that
we've been able to grow its their grade
the number and the percentage of
students meeting the milestone we have a
very intentional plan as really excited
to share it with you tonight
00h 40m 00s
next we'll have solid middle school set
and Charlene but good evening I'm very
thrilled to be able to represent
sellwood middle school in its community
we have a very strong a tradition in the
sellwood community of connection with
our school our school is almost 100
years old the building was built in
nineteen fourteen so we're coming up on
our big anniversary we have very skilled
and committed staff who know and
appreciate mid-level learners we have
wonderful middle school students who at
time are utterly fabulous and a joy to
teach every day and also we have a very
strong parent community that is involved
in our school and has supported the
school and been involved along with the
community for a hundred years and we
have a strong academic program there our
percentage of students reading at the
benchmark level for six to eight is
about eighty-seven percent math is about
eighty percent and in addition to the
strong academic program that we've been
able to maintain its Elwood we have a
wonderful array of electives and the one
elective program is highlighted by a
fabulous instrumental music program they
were very happy and thankful for that
we've been able to hold on to we have
five different bands advanced
intermediate and beginning band jazz
band and two marimba bands fifty percent
of our students three hundred two
hundred thirty kids are and the students
are involved in and play an instrumental
instrument at sellwood and wonderful
concerts I'd love to have you join us
those bands perform all over the city
and the region they were the only
metropolitan we were the only
Metropolitan performed at the middle
school national middle school conference
in November and we're also really
thankful to be able to have a foreign
language we can offer Spanish for high
school credit and also Chinese we have a
strong visual arts program
and physical education a lot of our
challenge has to do with making sure
that every single student one hundred
percent of our students are ready for
high school and ready to be successful
in high school and we've put in place
increasingly put in places placed to
support all of the students at so what
we'll be hearing a little bit more about
that and particularly focusing on
eliminating the predictable achievement
gap that is at sellwood and with
children of color and also disabled
children we've been involved in
intensive equity work and are with our
staff last year and this year
particularly and and also have had psyop
training and we redesigned our master
calendar in the last two years and
reclaimed increased instructional time
it actually ended up being an increase
of 11 and a half school days of
instruction with the redesign of our
schedule we went to an a/b schedule for
the 6th and 7th grade so the 6th and 7th
graders have an additional language art
social studies period every other day
and that allows them to to focus in on
writing instruction and also reading
which will help as we try to meet the
standards in the new Common Core State
Standards it also allows the 6th and 7th
grade language arts social studies
teachers to only teach language arts
social studies and not an elective and
so that they have you know two classes
60 kids that they're focusing on so
that's quite an advantage for reading
and writing instruction and we also do
have done a mock writing test as you
probably under know that the state has
done on demand direct writing assessment
for years and has it in the last two
years because of funding problems so we
have hired a state score to come in paid
for it out of our consolidated budget so
that our students still have that direct
writing assessment in the fall and in
the spring helps inform instruction and
also gives feedback to students and
teachers and parents on how the kids are
doing
in writing scored by someone who's
totally objective in its uniform across
every single child in the 6th and 7th
grade to the writing information and we
have been working to quite extensively
on discipline and and also helping kids
the struggling students and Seth my
colleague Seth Jones who's assistant
principal is going to tell you more
about that alright thanks for lane so my
name is Seth Jones I'm the assistant
principal at so it and part of being an
assistant principal as you get to work
with discipline quite a bit and when
you're at a middle school and you're
with middle schoolers there's a lot of
00h 45m 00s
discipline issues that can come up so
what we try to have a positive spin on
it and I know we're trying to avoid
acronyms as much as possible but PD is
is positive behaviors interventions and
supports I know we talked about this in
schools a lot but it really comes down
to a four to one ratio where you want to
have for positive for every one
corrective bit of feedback this works
with your kids works with spouses to
from from what I'm told so a big part of
what we're doing is we're trying to do
this we're also trying to make our
expectations really explicit so we make
a big to-do of last year so this is the
second year that we've been involved
with student services and the PBIS
rollout another thing that we're just
really thankful for that I'm really
thankful for in the district is student
services and how supportive and and
reliable and proactively are so the
we've had Dru Lawrence as a PBIS coach
he comes out and he leads our staff
through the champs training champs is
another acronym but it's it's a student
management curriculum essentially so it
helps us helps our teachers helps us
think about how we set up our students
for success how we handle those
challenging questions as they come up so
that's been that's been a big help and
so we've done that during art our late
starts once a month we show discipline
slides so the slide over here looking at
our three-year discipline comparison
I'll get to momentarily but we do look
at our discipline data once a month and
then we talk about so where are students
getting in trouble what time of day
we look for other patterns and other
things that they have in common so we
can try to anticipate and catch kids
before they actually get into trouble we
have a great PBIS team it's myself or
counselor five fantastic teachers we
meet once a month and we talk about what
are ways that we can get positive
feedback to students what are we what
are ways that we can adjust our
practices to keep students from getting
into trouble so right after the winter
break we plan this out in December we
did something called a station rotation
activity so we had nine stations within
the building for nine common areas so
you've got your hallways your cafeteria
your gymnasium and the bus we've been
having troubles on our school bus which
I know it's it's unthinkable to middle
school buses and problems but we
actually the district was great we had a
bus pull up right out front when it
drops students off in the morning and
this was my station so I was on the bus
and there was another PBIS team member
in the hallways and Charlene was in the
cafeteria so then we had divided the
school up so they took the students
around in nine different groups and they
had seven minutes at each station so you
got all of the students in the school in
nine different times on the bus and I
was able to with a drive around there
show them there's a camera in front of
the bus there's a camera in the back of
the bus this is what you do this is what
you don't do and if you do this and if
you flick rubber bands you're going to
be suspended from the bus so it was just
a way of trying to keep it light and fun
at the same time serious because
everyone's got a right to feel safe on
the bus anyway we've been doing things
like this and we've been having
tremendous success so if you look up at
this slide over here we are the blue
line this year so the green line was the
year before the black line was year
before that so we've made great strides
as far as this year and I didn't include
our suspension data because I don't want
to take up too much time but this year
we've had five out-of-school suspensions
last year we had had 34 so is really
really working so we really appreciate
it and I think that's it thank you thank
you
just a reminder you have about five
minutes remaining Paul time to close it
out Cleveland four high schools five
minutes super ten Smith and board
members it is with considerable pleasure
that introduced Cleveland's principal
Paul Cook Paul has the distinction of
being the longest standing high school
principal and PPS but not the oldest and
I thought I was given this some
considerable weight there but the
laughters he served at Cleveland for
over 10 years and since arriving at
Cleveland over a decade ago Paul's
established strong partnerships with his
community in his alumni he's established
a robust IB program created successful
ninth grade academies to personalize
learning and created opportunities for
students needing additional assistance
in core content areas additionally he
led a successful campaign to redo the
athletic field and track he believes in
providing students with opportunities
inside and outside the classroom to keep
them engaged and committed to learning
00h 50m 00s
in 2012 US News and World Report
recognized Cleveland as a civil metal
awardee and as a high school in the top
10 of Oregon so truly it sees a
phenomenal person to work with a great
colleague Paul Cook Thanks trip um I
have a few minutes 5 10 minutes I I'll
go as quick as I can I know you have our
profile in front of you I want to review
a couple things there and try and give
you a best snapshot of Cleveland as i
can in just short amount of time as i
described the successes and challenges
at Cleveland High School please
understand the teaching and support
staff have had to adapt to some very
far-reaching types of reductions over
the past couple of years actually
several years but staffing through
staffing and budget and that they
continue to do great work on behalf
our students and Families so just as we
talked through these these points
obviously remember those points we have
a great staff enrollment characteristics
it's on it's on the profile our
breakdown of students as far as
ethnicity as well as our free reduced
lunch program and number of tags
students I won't go into that I do want
to say that by the senior year our
students make some decisions and they in
planning college for college six percent
of our students plan to go to a
four-year college in twenty-four percent
plan on going to a two-year college the
rest of the students are either
undecided military or into the workforce
I want to talk about assessment first of
all our state assessment scores on
meeting and exceeding as far as all
students in reading ninety-three percent
of our students have met or exceeded in
math seventy-six percent in science
seventy-two percent and writing
eighty-nine percent if I want to break
it down by ethnicity and I want to break
it down by just student numbers itself
not by percentages so you get the feel
of we're talking about actual students
that are not passing these these tests
so break down by ethnicity in reading
these are students that have not passed
so none of our african-american students
that have not passed the reading test is
66 students have not passed and has six
too many American indian/alaska native
to students asian five Hispanic seven
and white 12 students have not passed
yet in math using the same have not
passed african-american nine students
American Indian Alaska Native seven
Asian seven Hispanic 10 and white 63
students in special populations dll 114
students have not passed sped 12 and
free reduced 18 but I want to pay
particular attention to the PLL students
14 students have not passed we had one
student pass I'll get to that in our
challenges I want to talk more about
that but I really wanted to make that
visible in regards to writing scores the
number of students not passing they
compare very closely to our reading
scores our 10th grade milestone students
earning six credits and more as well as
reaching nine percent attendance and
better overall seventy-eight percent of
our students have met that benchmark
break down by ethnicity American Indian
Alaskan native sixty-three percent have
met the bench MIDI milestone Asian
Pacific Islander 91% african-americans
seventy-nine percent Hispanics
seventy-six percent multi-ethnic
eighty-one percent and white
seventy-eight percent our four-year
cohort graduation rate milestone overall
eighty percent of our students have met
or have graduated in four years break
down by ethnicity American Indian Alaska
Native eighty-six percent Asian Pacific
Islander eighty-three percent
african-american eighty-eight percent
Hispanic seventy percent multiracial
sixty-two percent and white eighty-one
percent even though we are highlighted
last year as one of the two high schools
in Portland debts I double-digit
increase in a graduation rate which is
great we still have a long ways to go
looking at the percentages they should
be a hundred percent academics I want to
talk briefly about our international
baccalaureate program we have been up
and running for about the past ten years
at Cleveland High School we've seen a
lot of growth in the number students
that have been rolling into ib classes
currently sixty-six percent of our
students enroll into at least one or
more Ivy classes and that's in the
junior senior year sixty-six percent
ninth grade academy or ninth grade
academy work has also helped prepare
students for the academic careers of IB
through their organization schools
skills they learn and they do
interdisciplinary work by writing across
00h 55m 00s
the curriculum in their Academy so is a
nice kind of precursor for ib ib is
recognized by colleges as a rigorous
academic program that prepares students
very well for college colleges have
noticed the skill the college readiness
and the retention rate has increased for
students who have completed IV
coursework in their high schools well
I'll talk briefly about a manager
immersion program we begin a Woodstock
elementary then they continue on to
hosford and then they come to us at
Cleveland High School the program offers
content based courses that are taught in
Mandarin with the aim of students
becoming bilingual and by literate with
a high level of multicultural
understanding our ninth grade academy
that's been in place for almost ten
years now we have five academies so
every freshman student is in an academy
the academies are not tracked meaning
there's not an honors honors academy
students can do an honors contract with
any one of the Academy's but they are
all mixed so we have all academic but we
spread out specialized students academic
priority kids re ll students that are
all spread out to the dura fiber
academies we have a very strong
performing visual art program we have
bad we have choir and we have drama we
have drama by the way everybody got to
say that when you're in a high school
don't say we also have beginning art
classes and go on and to intermediate
and advanced our classes as well as I be
art classes we also have ceramics last
year we began an avid program and
abbasids for advancement via individual
individual determination it's a
wonderful program we currently have a
ninth grade class and a split ten 11th
grade class ab a-- class that offers to
support in rigorous courses and all
content areas the classes help with the
opportunity gap giving students more
access seventy-five percent of students
in avid are students of color the goal
is to have 100 center students ready for
college entrance equity work with our
staff we've been working on our
professional developer the past year and
a half we have a strong equity team made
up of teachers and administrators ten of
us are on that committee that planned
professional development each month we
are making great strides in a lot of
awareness and
look at our instructional practices and
how it's affecting kids and we have more
work to do there pd on our professional
development on teacher grading practices
trip and I've had numerous discussions
discussions around great practices at
the high school level we begin our
professional development work around
that looking at grading practices for
example looking at the power is zero
when when students are zero on a written
exercise or homework and what does that
mean and what kind of impact does that
make on their grade so a lot more
discussion on that and a lot more
professional development our
instructional coach has been so valuable
John golden is a gym and I will speak
later about one of the challenges in
making sure that we continue with their
instructional coaches such as John Gould
netter school so two challenges I have a
few challenges that I want to just just
give to you and let you know and then I
want to finish it up with some honors so
while the challenges is been the cut in
special education we've had we had to
cut one and a half FTE last year we do
not have a B program all students are
our split or spread out within the
specialized teaching staff we have a
larger caseload for our special ed
teachers and it's making an impact it's
hard to get as personalized as we used
to we have a small number of ll student
population we have around 50 students
with less students you have less support
you have it less FTE and that makes a
difference too we're challenged with ll
students and without the newcomer
program has affected us we don't have
the sheltered classes as some schools
may have we don't have that and
obviously parvis do too just a smaller
number of students what we have
instructional coach like I've mentioned
before it is so important last year was
the first year we had an instructional
coach and we had
the whole for a full-time position he
did more than just professional
development for staff he's working with
teachers we're going to teachers
one-on-one something that teachers love
to have have another eyes in the
classroom besides an administrator but
one of their peers in a classroom
working with them and coaching them very
very important 9th grade support last
year we had in last few years we've had
01h 00m 00s
academic priority monies to support our
students and this year we we don't last
year we were able to use some of that
money to allow teachers to work with
students during intercessions
intercessions or times that the end the
quarter and the semester it helps
students give them that boost that maybe
they're there they're just failing a
class and get that extra boost to pass
the class and we had a lot of success
with that the also we lost our support
classes last year we had 15 ninth grade
support classes this year we have three
we can't keep up the numbers when you
look at comparing classes not just
compare ibeke an IV class has 40 kids in
there has support class that has 10 and
with the bit with the with the 180
number trying to balance out teacher
loads is pretty difficult so when you
have a comprehensive high school that
has all these things going with I be
with support classes with academies with
immersion with art that's great I'm
painting a good picture of a grid of a
very good conference of high school but
there's needs and we all know that i'm
not i'm a there's not a blame game I'm
just I'm just if you can wrap it up
would be really appreciated what's that
if you can wrap it up with big really
blows away Kevin time I will catch I'm
right here this is it
I want to end on a high note I kept that
challenges in the middle or at nearly
abut I'm going to end with a high note I
want to talk I want to say that the
organ part of Education released report
cards for every public school district
throughout the state we earned an
outstanding great reflection of our
staff and students recently the
oregonian ounce the top ten schools in
each classification the oregonian cup is
awarded to schools that exhibit a
combined excellence in academics
activities athletics and sportsmanship
this past fall in the 5a state we are in
6 and state last spring trip mentioned
we've earned top 10 in the state in the
US News and World Report and in top 4%
in the country and activities athletics
has been a great year for our
student-athletes we have around 900
student athletes compete in a fall
winter spring sport we currently have
over 30 active charter student clubs our
speech and debate team earned its third
district title and earned first and
state honors drama department for very
well this past fall winter and and and
we have a spring performances coming up
jazz band great job first and second
place finishes and very prestigious
competitions last spring our choir place
first and pio competition and also first
and state we have a great pair community
they support us they supports with the
oxygen with the foundation they do
everything they do they can do they sell
pepperoni sticks they sell everything
they can besides the clothes off their
back to support the school and our
alumni are amazing our alumni are just
fantastic and what they've helped us to
and like trip mentioned about some of
the bigger projects that we did they
were a major player in making those
things happen for Portland kids not just
for Clavin kids but for Portland kids
they use that field if you ever drive by
the Cleveland field just watch how many
kids are using that on the weekends or
after hours teams that are practicing on
that that have a muddy field to practice
for state playoffs like Grant High
School have come over user prac art term
for practice that's pretty dang cool and
then lastly this is it our students have
had some many successes of successes
over the past several years which is due
in part to this drunk preparation
from our elementary and middle schools
yes at our high school teachers the
staff have prepared them well for the
next journey into college military or to
work for Workforce along with the
continued support of the parents we can
expect our students have acquired a
solid foundation to become successful
citizens and thank you for your time
thank you so now for our time to be able
to ask some questions or to have some
discussion in regards to the
presentation compressor from Cleveland
or comment sir well I just like to say
thank you to all of you and Paul I want
to say thank you especially for pointing
out the challenges you don't have to
apologize for those we know that there
are challenges and it I think it helps
us when we're making our decisions
around budgeting to know what those
challenges are and how prior cuts have
affected your schools and so we really
do appreciate you highlighting those
things for us and we wish you didn't
have them thank you I had a general
question I'd love to ask sort of the k5
middle school in high schools maybe some
representative responses if our governor
01h 05m 00s
and state legislators came up with more
funding than is currently on the table
and you were each given another hundred
thousand dollars to play with you've
talked about amazing programs amazing
teachers and counselors and you know all
kinds of things if you could help us
understand what would have the most
impact if you had a little bit more
money at each of your levels I'd love to
hear that
thank you a great question Brian
Anderson Buckman I think the hardest
part in my four years at Buckman has
been the loss of our support staff we
when I first got there we had a reading
support and we had math support and you
know it really and with the difference
in the test scores changing the last
couple of years our kids have always
been one or two points away from the
next level and I think that our our
special I'd kids are doing very very
well in comparison to our genetic kids
which I'm really proud of but it's been
noticed by the teachers by the community
even by the students at that small group
support for the kids that are really
struggling I feel we're really tackling
the enrichment opportunities and I think
we're really tackling those middle level
kids that are succeeding but we have
really all the cuts have happened with
our support staff and they were amazing
and they met with the kids pulled them
out at times it didn't affect that
they're learning but it really helped
them and I really seen a difference in
the data and we've been focusing on
parent enrichment opportunities for kids
and support opportunities but it's just
not the same when it comes to having
those professionals in working with
those kids that's what I would thank you
beautiful and I'm Tammy Baron at
Abernathy and we've grown from a small
school to school now over 500 and I have
to say the same thing as Brian I have no
counselor I'm the counselor one
secretary of me no Peres and so you
we've made some incredible improvement
but that's because of our strong parent
population and we have parent tutors
throughout the building but what I don't
have I've no reading support what I used
to have was a reading teacher and those
are one of the things that is eaten away
at what we've been able to do and so
it's those kids
that are struggling both emotionally and
academically and even though there
aren't a lot of them there are enough
that makes it very difficult in that way
so when you ask what's really helps it
is that those extra adults in the
building that can give someone the time
to spend with them I'll speak for
Cleveland High School give me another
teacher a hundred thousand dollars a
teacher teacher and half I don't care
teacher and a quarter I need more
classes I need smaller class size and I
want to keep our special programs intact
like avid I need teachers to teach the
teacher kids and that's a support
program for kids I've already talked a
lot but I would also provide support for
summer school for those schools that
have high populations particularly of
English language learners to have kids
out of school for three months and not
getting any reading or English support
is only is a long time and it makes it
much more difficult for those kids to
catch up I am Tim Lauer Lewis you said
about a hundred thousand dollars I just
want to impress upon I mean I it's it's
helpful for us to hear it as we go into
the budget cycle but it's also I think
helpful for our governor and our
legislators to understand that this
money has a real impact and so that's
why I'm trying to be better Steve um our
particular program at first grade we
have 32 kids in each class we have 33 at
second grade so if I had that amount of
money I would buy a teacher and do a
blend at 12 Lewis is one of the eight or
nine schools that used to be a title one
school and as a result of that we have
of our 63 kindergarten students we have
I believe 11 or half day so they're
dermis lead out on a full day experience
and in the class size and because of the
adjustments in such we've had to make
those kind of shifts thank you all the
questions thank you data a lot of semis
01h 10m 00s
test scores and clue you guys doing
pretty well but I would like to hear
more about your school's I don't think
these are necessarily representative of
your student body what their interests
are what students are working on
Cleveland mentioned there's Speech and
Debate team and other various programs
and I'd like to hear more about those
sort of things in schools so I have the
mic I'm very uh all of our students at
Lewis have music twice a week we have a
tremendous music teacher who with before
and after school programs probably works
with about 120 students with quarter
Club strings instrumental band in an
orphan sambal guys fantastic
Mary Patterson at Woodstock so we have
the Mandarin immersion program at
Woodstock which feeds into hosford and
then Cleveland and so it's a unique
school in the sense that we have a
neighborhood school that comes from
people who live within our catchment
area and then we have people from all
over the city who come in for the
lottery so the Mandarin program pulls in
after-school activities which include a
Chinese dance class which really lends
itself to teaching more widely about the
culture of China and then students who
are in the neighborhood program we have
teachers who join us as exchange
teachers from China and I make a point
of having them go into the neighborhood
classrooms and teach the children some
basic Mandarin and a little bit about
the culture so that we try to operate as
one school and not two schools within
one building but linking both questions
your question Bobby about what to do I
think it's very similar story across the
district in terms of as we lose staff
then as principals we're faced with what
do we cut do we cut music do we cut PE
do we cut our counselor for a building
with over 500 students a neighborhood
program and an immersion program when
work Hut I'm trying to balance the
immersion staff with my neighborhood I
can control the numbers coming into the
immersion I cannot control the numbers
coming in to my neighborhood and that's
growing cebit kindergarten class of 33
in the neighborhood how do i balance
that with my immersion classrooms I have
a half time counselor now with 500 and
some kids no music but i do have PE so
we have lots of different activities
going on in each school is very rich and
what it can provide I think we're all
struggling to continue to provide that
level of richness
yeah okay sorry want to hear more about
the different activities between light
of the time I want to just call out and
commend sellwood on your outstanding
results on the discipline and I know
we're waiting to hear is aboard the
update from the discipline policy in
terms of results district-wide and by
cluster so looking forward to more
hopefully similar data soon so I guess
it's more just a comment and maybe a
question out to your regional
administrator or and or the
superintendent just in terms of are we
seeing the same level of you know a the
ability to invest sounds like the
professional development has been key in
this but also be just the accountability
of the focus that we're clearly seeing
it solvent in terms of really focusing
in on getting this type of result which
is what exactly what we're looking for
yes one of the things that I talked with
all the principles about and their AP
its disciplined and we go over what
happened last month and how many and you
know looking at the decrease and we also
look at the students who are your
students students of color you know are
they right students as you know the
Cleveland region population we have a
combination and many of them in their
situation would be white students
because it's a larger part of the
population or they special needs
students in the different classrooms
that you may have so we have good sit
down we look at the discipline we look
at the situation that may have happened
and some of them at the elementary level
don't have much discipline at all others
it starts to creep up as they get older
and other things start to come into play
thanks and do you have a sense in terms
of the investment in the challenges in
terms of the budget that it's going to
have an impact as well in other words
are we going to have challenges and
being able to maintain the professional
development and the other pieces that
have really been key yes some of the
schools are able to do PB is at one time
we were doing sorry safe and civil
schools sometime back and a lot of shoes
got involved but it didn't continue so
now we're moving into the positive
behavior intervention supports but
that's also depends on how
principles are able to balance their
money if they can do that or not do that
some of our title one schools and last
01h 15m 00s
year we had a few people who are sitting
here we're title one schools and had
some additional funds and services and
they're no longer title one schools
anymore not so much that they don't have
a different student population but that
we changed the formula and so that took
funding away from them when we had to do
that and in programs that they had in
place aren't there and I just have to
say I greatly appreciate the efforts of
the high schools of having been a high
school principal and knowing you have a
couple assistance to back you up I
greatly appreciate the middle schools
haven't been a middle school principal
and knowing you have a couple of ApS or
at least one to back you up and usually
at least a half time counselor but many
of the elementary folks it's them in
their secretary and then maybe the next
person who is able to be at about is
their custodian you know and then the
kitchen help and when you're dealing
with four or five plus hundred students
that's a lot of little bodies with a lot
of little issues that come with that and
so I think the job is getting extremely
challenging especially for people who
are running solo in a lot of these
buildings with some of the challenges
that are just coming up when we don't
have those supports in place
that's you from I want to go back to
T'Pol and the the cohort graduation rate
I mean this is a really great chart of
with really big games last year and I
and some fantastic games with kids of
color and so can you give us a couple of
lessons learned what is there something
that you could point to where you went
this is what we did that really made a
difference with these kids this class
specifically that the senior class was
the one of the years when we as ninth
graders as in their ninth grade
academies they were signed to mentors
teachers of the ninth grade academy as
well as administrators and counselors we
all had four to five kids that we
mentored and we checked in all year long
and we felt like that made a real impact
and set them it was a connection that we
had all four for the whole four years I
knew four to five students very very
well more than I ever knew him before
because I met with him all the freshman
year and then continued on to throughout
the rest of yours also I have to say our
credit retrieval program helped it
allows students to stay at Cleveland to
retake classes and earn credit that they
had failed before it's not that they
hadn't taken him they they failed him
and they were very close to passing so I
didn't have to go to night school and
change your whole schedule around to
make that fit because he also made him
worked or in other activity so they
stayed engaged to the high school and we
kept him there and that was that was a
great part so I think both of those
things really really made a difference
so have you continued those things going
forward I mean he said well that clumsy
were able to heart yeah part you know
with the mentoring piece there was some
obviously some hours involved in paying
teachers you know yeah it was only a
couple hours and they put in many many
many more hours in that that was part of
it the credit retrieval we have a few
classes and credit retrieval this year
but again it's a staffing issue
how many classes can we really afford to
offer you're doing your intensive again
to you made that decision oh we had our
intensive last year we had 15 and this
year we have three so what is that this
support classes freshman support classes
that our academic priority kids are
usually in our intensive classes getting
extra help from ninth grade academy
teachers we just don't have as many this
year compared to last year you don't
have as many classes of support but you
use have this same number of acne mostly
kids ocean oh yeah and you just couldn't
get the class numbers right high enough
right you know they intentionally
smaller so last year I think the average
was probably around 10 students a class
but when you lose that ft it's really
difficult to offer classes of 10
students so the other difference to
those we made a difference we made a
choice to have more academies this year
we have five academies in the past we've
had a lower number or maybe we had five
academies but more students so we we
just said as a ninth grade academy we're
going to make our academies smaller if
we can't have all the support classes
that we knew we couldn't have let's try
to make our academies a little smaller
and so we did that by having less
students coming into cleveland as
freshmen and then spreading those
students that was in five academy so
instead of having 35 kids in an academy
01h 20m 00s
they're more like 28 29 so that helps
that that will help this year for sure
when they don't have that double block
class of support i'm gonna you know
thank you for your you know for that
information because that you know we
were here at that point i think when
we're beginning to have those
interventions you know for 9th grade but
i'm not sure that we have gotten folie à
in understanding in regards to what was
effective in regards to you know the
different strategies that were applied I
remember your presentation when you came
to the board and that you know
excitement i think in regards to the you
know saying i'm going to have 45
students that I'm going to get to know
and that other adults in the building
are also you know making that commitment
to do that and I think it does make a
difference is i also want to thank you
and appreciate the fact that you you
know mention the actual numbers of
students in regards to what that means
because sometimes we you know we get
kind of comfortable with the idea that
you know percentages you know are you
know that that looks better but yes it
doesn't it doesn't have a better outcome
for those other students that are not
making it within that percentage and I
think that we we lose you know quite a
bit of that in way in regards to I think
the continued commitment to those 12
students that are not making it because
we know we say you know we we made the
target but right at what cost right so
thank you I don't know if they're all
her comments I mean one of the things
that I saw in and I seen this it other
reports is the drop in math in some of
the schools 5th grade math and I haven't
gotten this early a an explanation that
that well not that it's trying to
satisfy me but you know trying to get an
analysis in regards to what it is
because you know and there was no
mention regards to whether the adoption
of the new math had anything to do with
that so I'm wondering whether
why sure so do you want me to mention
the school that I still saw that often
just made a good thing it just one thing
that I'd like to comment about that is I
do feel that the first year our teacher
I'm a big fan of bridges I was also a
fan of investigations but I really
understand how much bridges really is
covering those things that the kids were
missing but the teachers had a learning
curve you know we were doing math a lot
more than we ever have as well as our
number corners in the morning I really
foresee that this is going to be an
incredible adoption and I think it's
going to make a big difference for kids
I know if I had learned this kind of
math when I was a kid I would have a lot
more confidence so I feel it's that and
I also feel that the change in scores
for the state tests really made a
difference for a lot of kids that were
so close that the cut scores and so I
think there's a combination of things
happening at the same time common core
standards a new adoption a teacher
learning curve but I go into those
classrooms now and I've never seen the
commitment to math like I'm seeing any
excitement level of the kids and those
kids that used to just own out so I do
believe that it's a work in progress and
we are going to see much growth in the
future thank you again and thank you
again for that commitment to the one
hundred percent I think that we need to
I think strive for that even more and I
think you know if we set that as a gold
I think that we can meet it but we have
to do that stretch so thank you all for
for sharing all this information and
going wait for my presence on the TV
okay
I'm Kevin Bacon I'm from Hofstra in
middle school and I know one thing
that's really important to the
superintendent and also to the board has
been the over referral of black and
brown boys to self contain special that
classrooms and I just want to say that
at hosford we have what's called Abby
Abby room program and to explain an
acronym so I don't get in trouble later
that's what's called a behavior room
it's called a special learning center
for behavior kids kids with IEPs for
behavior challenges and we have our
fabulous 14 of those students and with
the help of the district you know we
01h 25m 00s
decided that we were just going to blow
that model up and those kids were going
to return this fall with full schedules
like every other student and I got to
say that in doing that we had to prepare
the parents we had to prepare the
students we had to prepare ourselves
myself and Marilyn for for that
transition but you know the staff has
really embraced that and those kids are
100-percent mainstreamed we've been
working with Mary Pearson the director
special add along with Jeff Brown who's
our program administrator and of course
Larry and you know we've seen a little
bit of a rise in our discipline data as
a result of this mainstreaming but far
and away far and away the benefits that
we've seen from the students who who
were not getting core instruction from
highly qualified teachers you know they
were getting self-contained instruction
and once you move into the middle the
middle level you know that that
instruction is just more than one
teacher can really handle to try to
deliver science language arts social
studies and math so those kids are out
in those classes and in doing well and
so we just want to want to highlight
that and let you know that that that
some of that work that you wanted to see
done is
happening and those kids are are
thriving and they're going to be better
prepared for high school because once
they left hosford in eighth grade and
went to their various high schools all
of a sudden they were sort of turned
loose into those academies which are
real supportive but at the same time
it's just that was the first time they
were really out there with their peers
and so I just want to highlight that and
say that before before we adjourned
thank you for stepping up and if we all
can come to the front we're going to
take a photo s we usually do and then
Event 2: PPS Board of Education, 01/14/13 Study Session Part 2 of 2
00h 00m 00s
we're going to resume our meeting so if
folks that they need to continue the
conversation if they can do that on the
outside will be greatly appreciated we
are next on our agenda is the enrollment
balancing for Jefferson and pk-8 and
superintendent Smith there's two this
one i'm going to call up Judy Brennan
who is our director of enrollment
transfer Harriet Adair who is the
executive director of schools and
operational support and Antonio Lopez
who is our regional administrator for
the Jefferson cluster and these three
have been leading this process that
actually began last summer and we have
the most recent stage in the process
we've had six and six potential
scenarios that were really making
visible all the potential ingredients
that would could go into what may become
the final scenario and we then went out
and listen to people's response
throughout the community both internally
and externally I think we've had more
than a thousand people weighing in on
just what the various features what the
impact is what we're trying to
accomplish with this is a number of
classes offered at each grade level that
lets us provide the most robust program
and access to program for students so
that's our primary driver particularly
at the middle grades where we've got
schools that have been too small to have
the kind of robust programming we want
to offer tonight we will have two
scenarios that come before you that
really now bring that both of which
could be viable both of which are still
a work in progress and will feed the
next the next period of public input
that now I become the listener to that
will inform a proposal I come back and
present to the board on februari first
or release at februari first for
president
to the board in February forth so we're
again still in process you're going to
hear two proposals that have features
it's not a vote on one proposal or the
other it's really putting forward here
are the ingredients that get us the
thing we were shooting for which is
robust access to robust programs for
every kid in that cluster that
adequately prepares them for high school
so before I actually go to the meat of
the presentation what I want to make
visible is just what the processes and
opportunities for input because the
public will again have a lot of
opportunity to weigh in so today before
actually bringing this to make this
public before the board staff at each
one of the schools that were impacted
we're presenting to the school staffs at
each of those schools we have
school-based informational sessions for
families that will be held on January
17th and january twenty second we'll be
having a session that specifically for
partners pastors and policymakers on
January 18th we'll have a community
input session for language specific
communities on january 24 and then
another community input session on
january 26 which is a saturday at one
o'clock and we will have various members
of the board myself and the team that's
been leading this as well as principals
and leadership from the schools at all
of these sessions listening but all of
that then feeds what will become the
final proposal so we're really looking
for response to any aspect of the
proposals that people want to respond to
so with that I will turn it over to our
team to get into the specifics of what
are now the two proposals Thank You
superintendent Smith ah co-chairs
Gonzalez vallejo two Raptors the student
representative and superintendent my
name is Antonio Lopez I'm the Regional
Administrator for Franklin and Jeff
person and tonight in the hour that we
have we have three objectives and the
objectives to review the enrollment and
balancing process the second to describe
that two options for a dye Jefferson
pre-k a cluster the community engagement
plan and lastly to listen to your
questions and feedback so we're going to
start with this is a cycle that you have
seed and right now we are in that
listening and proposal we will move into
the decide and eventually to the
implementation and then we start the
cycle again in terms of assessing
whether the employment issue was
successful so as you can see we're in
00h 05m 00s
the right in the middle where we're
ready for the next step and like a
superintendent Smith described there is
a process and that eventually it will be
coming to this wall for a for a boat for
a decision okay we do have this set up
in a process for how we're going to do
this basically what we're going to talk
about today in terms of the process of
how we came down to the two scenarios we
looked at after listening to all of the
input from the variety of audiences
internal external stakeholder groups and
multiple in multiple venues and forms we
did decide on a couple of things and
prioritized around a couple of things
but things to keep in mind is that we
know that the enrollment balancing of
the balancing of enrollment by itself is
not going to improve student achievement
that what we're looking for our numbers
that would get to the point in the
Jefferson cluster so that every year
annually would not have to be reducing
staff because we don't have sufficient
numbers in the building to be able to
maintain the programs that we have in
place so in setting the priorities for
these last two options we basically came
up with a way of balancing enrollment in
two different strategies that would give
us a significant enough
numbers so that the resources that go
with the numbers once you get them could
be stabilized no matter which one of the
two processes the focus is on academic
achievement in the acceleration of
achievement and the elevation of
achievement the other focus is on making
certain that all students have access to
programs that we have already know will
prove to be effective across the cluster
so we're not looking at new things some
new idea that we dreamt up but ideas
that have proven to be effective in this
cluster and we are also looking at
establishing a sense of having students
recognizing that pre-k through 12 is the
trajectory for college choices and
post-secondary options that you don't
start at ninth grade to begin talking to
students and getting them to start
thinking about how what they might want
to do once they exit the k-12 arena so
over the years because the numbers in
the in the cluster have fluctuated that
has led to programmatic instability
staffing instability and the inability
to get these programs that we know are
good things for kids in place long
enough to get the results that we would
like to have happen so the cluster once
again to remind you are the eight
schools that have guaranteed enrollment
to the Jefferson middle college and we
are also talking about the Humboldt and
Humboldt buildings King and aqua green
has low enrollment at all the grades
fabien Vernon and woodland lower upper
grade enrollment and Beach Chief Joe
fabien limited class space across the
building and boise le and humble has the
potential for crowding in future years
without changes we would see that
constant up and down and sway that has
been impacting this cluster for a number
of years now so once again as I said we
are going to try and right size these
two proposals right size to school to
make certain that we have strong
academic support the emphasis is on the
quality of middle schools across all of
the input that we got consistently one
of the things that we heard was things
are great we like our primary grades or
we really like this but
every school every audience spoke to
needy to strengthen even if they were
pleased with what was happening they
knew that they needed to have a much
more robust middle grades program in all
of the schools we also want to make sure
that the enrollment changes will result
in something that's an outcome outcome
of equitable and high quality academic
programs in other words why do the
change if it isn't going to improve the
academics in the building and as I said
linkages to the high school curriculum
and access to colander college and
post-secondary opportunities of course
we would like all of our students in the
Jefferson cluster to feed Jefferson High
School we proud of that school we
support that school but if they make
other choices we obviously want to be
successful no matter where they go and
so we're looking at Advanced Placement
and other high school options and other
higher education partners are linking
with us like the PhD two three piece
with Concordia we are looking for kids
to be able to be academically successful
so they can take advantage of any option
that comes their way and of course we
want to nurture college-going
college-going cluster across oh this is
hard to say college-going culture across
the cluster okay who but that sends in
00h 10m 00s
there all right so here's the process do
you want to do the process Judy okay so
as superintendent Smith said we began
the process in the summer but actively
since the fall we've held a number about
20 formal meetings we release six
scenarios for feedback we received about
250 written comments on those scenarios
alone and over 600 comments written
comments so far all of those comments
are documented in binders that are in
the board office and as we continue to
get them we'll continue to update that
body of information we now are at the
point as you heard that and we'll be
talking about tonight we have two
options where we've called down the
feedback on the scenarios to to workable
sets of infirm we're proposing six
meetings and will run through that list
again there's a few things that that
maybe are even change
since since earlier looking towards the
superintendent's recommendation and then
your actions coming next so this is just
a quick reminder that we have different
types of tools that we can can use an
enrollment balancing that make different
kinds of changes and some of them such
as changing the transfer policy
tightening down transfers or making
boundary changes are what we call slow
change so it can right size over time
but it doesn't bring a lot of immediate
impact particularly when you're looking
at the middle grades because we start
things like boundary change at
kindergarten and that's it has the
biggest impact at the lower grades it
takes years in a cave school before you
see that impact in the upper grades
other things such as grade
reconfiguration consolidation enclosure
does cause existing students to move so
it's more impact immediately it's more
disruption but you get bigger results
and of course we always look at things
like facility changes options as well
but as we know we're limited due to cost
and so that's just the framework of
changes that we're designing these
options with it and finally I just
wanted to mention as you've heard we're
focused on strengthening strengthening
the middle years we're looking at having
at least two classrooms for grade level
in a k-8 even in those grades six seven
and eight which means you need more kids
at the lower grades so trying to
right-size schools in an effective way
is an important part of this and in a
way that crosses all of those grades we
would look at it having at least six
classrooms per grade level in a middle
school which is three to four feeder
schools and at this point there's no
middle school in the cluster now okay
all that preamble we would now like to
describe for you the two options you've
received a packet of information that
includes maps and hopefully those will
be visible where you are i'm going to
put some on the screen here i don't know
how helpful i'm going to be so let me
know later if any of this information up
here isn't visible okay so in the first
option our focus is on maintaining the
KH
show that it exists in the cluster now
but consolidating in a couple of
particularly taking three schools and
consolidating down to two in order to
increase access to programs for students
so in this change Chief Joseph oakley
green and woodlawn come together next
year as a single pre-k school that
operates on two campuses with this the
Woodlawn building would close after that
point the boundary for Woodlawn would be
divided between Chief Joseph aqua green
king and access or sorry King and Vernon
and additionally the access program
currently at Saban would move to King so
visually here's what this looks like
with not sure that's going to work very
well so you see the Woodlawn campus
closing the boundary the potential
boundary change in the portion of the
Woodlawn boundary that would become part
of the Chief Joseph ugly green boundary
the portion that would become part of
the king pounder II and the portion that
would become part of the Vernon boundary
and you see ockley green and Chief
Joseph of becoming a dual campus single
school that yes that would sort of
probably grades pre-k through eight you
see access coming into King and a small
boundary change that over time builds
enrollment at Vernon one of the
questions that you may have is why would
Woodlawn be the school that we would
look at for a closure in this scenario
we visited Woodlawn a couple of times
this fall made many other visits there
the Regional Administrator the former
regional administrator there are a lot
of strengths and values in Woodlawn
teachers parents students working very
hard on achievement other factors that
we see though are that a capture rate in
00h 15m 00s
their neighborhood area that's
chronically low that's hovering around
forty percent so more than half of the
students who live in their neighborhood
continue to make other choices and even
though they've seen growth at the lower
grades it's still it's still so low and
so suppressed it's going to take a long
time for those changes to impact the
upper grades where the sizes are
smallest in addition we see continuing
low achievement data and we understand
that that means that we we have to
accelerate and elevate our academic
efforts in that school it makes it much
much harder to do that at the middle
grades when their numbers are really low
so we see that we need a more immediate
change in order to give students the
access to programs that will nurture
that academic success there are other
possibilities we want to quickly mention
aligned with this option as you can see
we have no direct change for Beach Boys
ele and Humboldt or Fabien in this
option however there are possibilities
in the future there could be immersion
changes that are aligned with the
district's immersion plan and that could
have an impact on on beach in some way
Boise Elliot humble could look at moving
to the tub tub and campus in the future
Fabien is slated to receive portable
classrooms in advance of its full
modernization and continuous partnership
with Concordia and 32 PhD there are
additional boundary changes that we
could look at in the future to
right-size neighborhoods within those
schools so there are some unusual
aspects to their neighborhoods that we
we would be happy to go in and clean up
once we get these major all structural
decisions made Humboldt could become a
regional early learning center in 2014
or later we want to align that overall
Early Learning Center plan for the
Jefferson cluster and the rest of the
district with state objectives and that
and you'll see more of that coming later
in the interim we believe that all the
schools that have pre-k now will
maintain pre-k so long as funding is
still available for that and finally we
want to say that it's important to
probably look at our high school duel
assignment choices for future students
and make sure that they're appropriately
lined again once we make these important
structural decisions these are the types
of changes that could come behind
quickly by the numbers
here are estimated enrollment impacts
you can see what the current enrollment
is at each school what the estimated
enrollment would be if we did nothing
and what the change would be I probably
should have just highlighted the schools
that change and let those that say the
same but you can see particularly the
Chief Joseph line is the line for the
combined Chief Joseph ugly green and
woodlawn so about 1100 students divided
between though between the teachers of
an aqua green campus allows us to fully
utilize both of those schools off the
green would be full for the first time
in a long time Chief Joseph would not be
overcrowded so long as we could make
grade structure changes that made the
most of a larger building still serving
Chief Joseph serving for the lower
grades you see King growing both from
the inclusion of access and from the
beginning effects of the boundary
changed 636 we still believe that
there's some room for growth between the
the King boundary and the access program
and then Vernon continuing to grow
through through an enlarged neighborhood
and also through increased capture rates
so what you've seen then is we have
immediate and program access
improvements particularly for Woodlawn
Chief Joseph oxy green and Kings
students we have slow but steady growth
for Vernon this option does require that
we close the school it requires that we
develop a strong shared campus model and
it'll mean that we'll have additional
transportation needs including some
students who are now walkers to their
current school other specific resource
impacts will be modeled if this option
becomes the superintendent's
recommendation so we would imagine that
there are many more questions that you
might have a community members might
have and we will do our best to resolve
those questions as soon as we were able
to sort out which of these options
indeed is going to be moving forward so
that's my brief summary on option 1 i'd
like to turn to option 2
this is another way of leading to
similar outcomes but using different
structures and impacting different
schools so it brings a middle school
back into the cluster as well as ensures
that the remaining k age are
programmatically strong certainly if
you're bringing strong middle grades
competition to schools nearby you want
to make sure that the caïds that are
left are ready to stand up to that
00h 20m 00s
competition in this the current ugly
green school we close at the end of this
year and then reopen in 2014 as a junior
middle college school serving grades 6
through 8 so that would require a
planning year and during that time
current aqua green students would move
to Woodlawn many of them are from other
neighborhoods because in grades K
through 5 it's a focus option choice so
the students would also have the right
to return to their neighborhood school
they preferred that we also would need a
location for the aqua green neighborhood
6th grade so the kids that are from the
Chief Joseph neighborhood for fifth
grade and that could be woodland there's
also the option if that doesn't work of
portables on the Chief Joseph campus but
that comes with cost in addition to that
change that is to setting a middle
school at aqua green that's fed by four
schools that slide name the four schools
no why don't I name those four schools
they would be Beach Boys II Elliot Chief
Joseph and woodlawn in addition to that
king and Vernon would consolidate into a
single school an International
Baccalaureate school both of those
schools currently have that program it
would be a larger and more robust school
under this change we envision two ways
that that consolidation could happen the
first the most abrupt the most
traditional is that one of the schools
closes the other all the students go to
the to the largest building that would
likely be king and then we would do
boundary changes to make sure that that
neighborhood was right size to fit that
one building but we also want to
continue some of our out-of-the-box
thinking and recognizing the
programmatic alignment
that always already happen to those
schools and that we'd like to find
another home for access which is right
now at Saban we would also proposed that
it's possible to have both campuses
remain open in a shared campus model
similar to what I just described her
aqua green and Chief Joseph and that the
access Academy their grades one through
aid would exist on one of those two
campuses and as I said if we go with a
traditional consolidation we would have
to do boundary changes so I'm going to
flip to the map here and you see the for
feeder schools feeding into aqua green
you see the one you're the shift for
aqua green current students on to the
Woodlawn campus beginning next year and
then aqua green open in 2014 you see our
either/or way of consolidating King and
Vernon that may include access or may
not and you see the potential for some
boundary changes that might have to be
made if we go through traditional
consolidation King becomes the new
school the Vernon building closes though
boundary changes would likely have to
move through fabien and fabien isn't a
school that can accept more students for
several years so there's some
complexities that could come with that
one of the questions that you might have
or I just wanted to spend another minute
on this detail that's in this particular
option of our request for a planning
year to develop our middle school model
it's a traditional method for opening a
new school where you take the time to
hire your administrators select your
curriculum build your relationships both
with your feeder schools and what the
high school that you're going to be
sending students to build up your
marketing strategy give your feeder
schools time to adapt and then you go
ahead and open the school so those are
some of the things that we're looking
for here we believe that that time will
be extremely valuable in getting that
new school off to a strong start
again some future possibilities that I
mentioned before exist as well with this
plan including future possible changes
with immersion the fabien plan remains
largely the same under this as it did
what I described before we might still
have additional boundary changes between
some smaller in some smaller
neighborhood areas the Early Learning
Center potential exists and the need no
doubt to realign our high school duel
assignment choices or at least examine
them make sure that they're still
appropriate after we decide these
structural changes the impacts that we
believe come with this option are
improved access to our middle grades
programs and to high school and beyond
that it really galvanizes the notion of
a junior middle college as a theme that
drives that college ready culture what
cluster wide you're right that's hard to
say across across the the area that
there's strength in a planning year but
it does require additional staff and
student movement it requires us to
decide to either closer school or
00h 25m 00s
develop a dual campus model that'll be
additional transition and transportation
for many students and there are other
specific resource impacts that will be
modeled if this is the option that
becomes the superintendent's
recommendation finally by the numbers
you see Beach Boys II Elliot Chief
Joseph and woodlawn as our feeder
schools as k5k fives that doesn't
include their pre k if you look at for
example chief joseph at 513 Woodlawn at
444 like if under this model that's a
that's a place where a boundary change
might make sense might be just enough to
build Woodlawn right to the size that we
would want and provide a little more
space at Chief Joseph which is full
right now so that's an example of how a
future boundary change might support
this overall structure change you see
the the middle school in 2015 with 522
students in it what's going on in the
cluster right now is that you have
significantly high
numbers of students in grades four and
below so for that first year I mean we
can count how many kids are attending
the schools and those clusters and we
see that it may start with a relatively
small like sixth grade but it'll grow
over time so starting with about 480 in
the first year 522 on the way up to 600
this would have an opening sixth grade
class of about 200 students which is
what we look for in our middle school
model okay so that is the place summary
and then we quickly go over where we are
with ya so today we met with the staffs
of our schools aqua green chip Joseph
Wald lon and further the princess will
work out a talk to the other schools and
what you have right now is the plan in
terms of how we're going to take these
options to the community and as you can
see we're going to be pretty busy in the
next two weeks so we have a variety of
meetings in the different schools we
have on january twenty second we meeting
with the planning team to help us in the
beginning in terms of the planning we
meet around that one hitter with the ESL
families you see that we meeting with
King and access and then in January 26
we have the community forum that will be
at Jefferson we also have a meeting with
all the special education families we
have our online survey that runs through
the 28th if wishes the communique give
us ideas of P back parties process and
one thing that the wheel with that we
keep in mind is how do we make sure that
we hear from the families that that for
some reason or another historically we
have now heard from special you know
families of color I mean everyone but
how do we
how do we intentionally go and look for
the families that historically have not
cannot be now represented how do we also
engage our partners and we have a
meeting with a with the partners with
our ministers in that community in terms
so we want to hear their voice and also
including that different organizations
like the local churches sei the Latino
network airco and those organizations
all right so we're ready for any
questions suggestions concerns
thank you very much I guess it just a
couple of questions off the bat I'm in
option one I see some still having some
some middle grade issues with King and
Vernon I know the King numbers were
increased because of the access program
but is that program going to operate
separately from the other middle
programs I mean we'll have students
under that you know under the roof but
that may not be exactly what we're
looking for we might be looking for
students within those particular middle
gear classrooms so I'm not really sure
how that program is going to integrate
so we may still see some number issues
within King I think the same is true
with Vernon I mean we're looking I think
the comment was slow and steady I don't
know if slow and steady is is where we
00h 30m 00s
need to be at this point i i i think the
other the other piece I'm not going to
touch the shared campus issue because I
think some of my colleagues might but
the the beach essentially leaving beach
alone in this case which which some
might seem think is being appropriate
you know I'm not quite sure how how we
can continue to support with the size of
that space support both a version of the
community portion of the school and the
immersion portion of the school
particularly with with goals of the
district moving towards increasing
immersion as an option so those are some
of the initial questions pardon me
initial questions that I have with with
option one
I can throw some questions out so a
couple questions this one would be
around the emirate again around the
immersion piece and when we would see
recommendations or what some scenarios
or ideas for that could be because it's
pretty unclear open-endedness
information here so that would be
helpful to be clear on that obviously
the dual campus models leave an area for
a lot of questions from a lot of folks
I'm sure what type of grades split and
numbers and what would make sense yeah
mmm and then another piece would be just
additional detail and I understand that
maybe for some of this you're wanting to
wait and is that wait and see how much
how deep at the detail you go on which
scenario when you're not sure which
scenario you're proceeding with but
having said that in that one that has a
middle school I think would be really
helpful at what as soon as possible or
feasible to have more detail about what
exactly that program could provide and
what that would look like so there's
just I'll stop there and let others way
I know director no sent a bunch a
question so I know she wants to
articulate and them I can just give you
guys my list of questions that i shared
with board members yesterday i think it
was him but i will bring up a couple of
them one had to do with immersion very
similar to the questions that Ruth tour
director Adkins was asking another one
had to do with Concordia i still havent
some of these questions or questions i
asked about a month ago when we were all
together and I still haven't heard an
answer on any of them so one of them had
to do with Concordia and what kind of
discussions are going on and what do
they think about a k5 versus a k-8 I
think that'd be helpful and then of
course there's the question of k 5 vs k
8 and i know that you know the original
intent intent which was before i was on
the board was that the k-8 were supposed
to be better or serve students better
and so i am again asking for information
about k 5 vs k 8 someone left me a sheet
from december of 2011 so I wonder if we
have any updated information about a
comparison of how our kids are doing in
the K fives versus the K aids and how
they were doing those students who are
in k aids now what's the history on
those students before how are they doing
before I know they're not the same
students but what kind of a difference
has it made in that neighborhood having
a k-8 versus a k5 so I'm looking for
things like test scores milestone
comparisons discipline referrals
attendance records all of those kinds of
things and high school success what it's
looking like when those students get to
high school k aids versus the K fives
I'm a I'm a little concerned about the
split campus to me it just seems like a
bigger middle school with a few more
grades in it is it going to be a 48 or
is it a 38 or is it a 58 or
what is it going to be and then I also
you know my own experience with the
split campus is the Holyrood one because
it's in my district and I haven't heard
much good about that so I'm just a
little concerned about that whether it's
really the best thing for children and
00h 35m 00s
then I be again what's our policy how's
it going to go in elementary schools is
this something that provides so much
benefit for students that we should be
converting all of our schools is it a
matter of cost and if it's a matter of
cost is it something that we want to put
as a priority for in these constrained
budget times for access same question
kind of the same question as around
Concordia what's been the conversation
with the parents there what are the
interested in what the requirement is
for access is it 99th percentile and is
it every student there has to be at
least 99th percentile poor plus ok I
knew it was hi I'm just thinking 99 plus
ok there's no criteria as well that's
right yes so what's the criteria and
then I had a question around utilization
because I couldn't find my book that had
how big each school wasn't how
overcrowded some of them are and whether
we could actually fit a k-8 into some of
those buildings or no is that just an
impossible dream for us to put a K a
full-sized kade in there and then I
guess for my colleagues on the board if
we're talking about size of schools and
one of the issues is the size what do we
need to start thinking about for the
next bond I know that we've been focused
on high schools but if we really are
having these kind of issues with our k
eights maybe there's some question about
we can do something in addition to just
our high schools or or some little tweak
into that so I don't have any I don't
have any really strong feelings about
either one of the options right now i
just have as you could just tell a lot
of questions and i think some of these
questions are questions that we need to
deal with on a policy level as a board
and I would like to see us be able to do
that before we make a decision on this
but I think that we're probably now
getting a little cramped on time for
that so but answers to the questions
would be fabulous so thank you that's
just a one question you said k 5k pies
and cakes or did you mean middle school
in case um middle schools in Cades okay
that's re okay so that's just an answer
well I suppose it would be a good both
would be the best I mean rk5 students
doing better in a k-8 or then this you
know so you could use you could do vote
especially in comparison to how they
were doing before they were k aids so
very good um thank you for all this work
and I think I I do immediately have a
preference at this moment in time for
the first option seems like it makes a
little bit more sense to me but I'm
excited to hear kind of what the
community reaction is to it as hard as
it is I think it's good that we're
looking at potentially closing one
building to try to make sure that we
have enough kids in the rest so in
either option that works I think an
option one my biggest concern is I think
what director Morton said which is the
actual size of King and what really is
the benefit in terms of the curriculum
or the enrichment opportunities by
putting access in that building i'm not
sure that there would necessarily be a
lot of overlap with the kids maybe
there's a benefit in terms of teachers
being close but i have big concern about
the size of the Kings student population
still under this scenario and would love
to have more information on that and I
guess I also am curious to know whether
we looked at providing access with its
own building because again I think when
you have two programs that are so
different sharing a building it ends up
often times having difficult
consequences so I'm just curious whether
or not we looked at I was curious why
access was thrown into this whole
conversation to start with and I'm still
curious about how it benefits in this
case the students at king or the program
at King maybe is what I should be saying
a couple of other just more general
questions I love the fact that we have
the IB program at a couple of our
schools here I would still like to
understand if we're considering an ib
high school option for those kids as
00h 40m 00s
they matriculate I think there's an
assumption here that are that our pre-k
kids would stay put for a year and then
potentially move to the early learning
center I still don't feel like I have my
arms around whether that's a good idea
or a bad idea to have an early learning
center I think it's a different
conversation perhaps but at the same
time it impacts the numbers in all of
these buildings and it may impact
whether or not families feel a
connection to the school right from the
start so I just have a general question
still about the direction we're going
there and again it may potentially be
another conversation but it certainly
impacts this conversation and then i
guess i do want to understand a little
bit more the benefits of the shared
campus model I mean I see it at Eastern
myself and it it works it's it's fine i
think there's some benefits and there's
some real challenges and so as we as we
look at a potential chief joe aqua green
shared campus i think it would be
worthwhile for us to all be very
transparent and what's good and bad and
difficult and challenging and beneficial
to that model so
so just following up on that one of the
you know you said you've got these two
options and so you don't want to go too
deep on each one until you decide what
structure you're going to go but I think
for people to understand these options
you may have to go a little deeper than
this and so the idea about the shared
campus at an option one that's a really
big number of kids how would you split
that and what would that look like
because I think for families to have a
strong opinion they'd really have to
have more information about what that
would look like and that's it that's a
big number kids 1100 kids I don't think
we have another school with this shared
campus with that many students you know
maybe it's fine because it split between
two schools and it's manageable but how
does that work so I think a little more
development on that is important and
then you know the idea of a junior
middle college program what does that
offer what's you know what is that we
haven't had any discussion about that
before so in order to choose between
these things you have to know something
more about what's what's the appeal of
that and and then we have to have some
pretty strong understanding about the
numbers that you could support the
numbers in a middle school and in the
its remaining pre-k programs because
we're not solving the middle grade
problem with you if you weakened the
remaining ka program so I have a you
know strong concern about that that we
go for one of these options or some mix
whatever wherever we end up we want to
end up with strong programs in all of
our schools I'm the on the IB question
it's intriguing to me to combine the
resources for those Ivy programs in one
building so that that seems like a plus
because those are resource intensive
and require a lot of staff development
so if you have that in one place that
that could be a real a real plus in
terms of staffing I would think so i
think that we need a little more a
little more information to go on for us
and for the community to understand what
the choices really would mean what they
would look like so when I guess I just
want to highlight director Knowles your
question about I be and whether or not
it's we know that it's rigorous and we
know that it's also resource intensive
and I think that in some ways it's
rigorous because its resources intensive
and so whether or not like as a
discussion is this what we're
prioritizing i think is a good question
just across the cluster and i'm not sure
i was talking with one administrator and
they were saying there there hasn't been
a lot of research done an ib is equity
how it works with different populations
and so it'd be interesting discussion i
think at some point um there i'm going
to give some of what I kind of like I
the shared campus like again director
Knowles it seems like just renaming a
middle school in an elementary school
and maybe saying its share campus
because it doesn't fit the exact
00h 45m 00s
enrollment grade configuration and I'm
not sure that I'm i guess i need to be
sold a little bit on unshared campuses I
appreciate the boundary changes in
option 1 i'm curious why we didn't i
know that a lot of fob ians isn't
developable land but i'm curious why we
wouldn't look at that option and then to
director knowles brought up the bond but
when we're going to rebuild fabien i'd
be curious what size were rebuilding it
for and i don't want us to have
to build a new school in three years in
sale by that way by the way that means
we're going to automatically close to
more schools around i'd like to make
that a really full campus and then again
and our budget constraints i feel like
we do have to be looking at building
utilization as far as we have to be
putting the most number of kids in the
most in the biggest schools that we have
and so you know i know that oakley I
don't know how big opera greens facility
is off the top of my head but that's
something that I like about option two
is combining two ib schools that are
already on progress Vernon and King into
a much bigger school like when I what I
heard from from community members is
that yeah what work we'd be happy to
have a middle school if we could open a
middle school with aiming for nine
hundred because whether some people will
leave or whether or not but they would
feel really good about those options if
you can't do that then it's almost like
well then we'd rather prefer we'd rather
stay with what we have and I'm not sure
and some of these options that we get to
a level that that folks would be excited
about and the last thing I guess I'll
say about option two is it it feels a
little bit like what what what people
who don't have to make the decision um
get to imagine like we'll do a little of
this a little less and there's a couple
areas on here where we're not quite sure
where they go we'll have to figure that
out but we have to figure that out and
specifically I'm thinking about those
boundary change areas where it doesn't
seem that they fit in this school and
they don't fit in that school an option
that I'll just toss out there ganks I
heard in the community that if you're
looking at option to building that aqua
green middle school or maybe it's the
middle junior middle college i'm going
to get confused with all those names i'm
going to tell you but that there was at
one point a discussion if if beaches for
example immersion program there middle
grades would then move would there be
benefit too
at grabbing peninsula folks and i don't
know what you know peninsula hasn't been
engaged in this conversation i don't
want to freak folks at pendants allowed
but what would that make would that make
sense to bring those two together and i
don't know i don't remember what's on
our list the next time but so i guess
those are those are some of my reactions
i do think that there will have i prefer
a school or to closing in those options
because i'm not sure that we're right
sized in this cluster and that's always
hard but i want to thank you for your
plan to outreach from here on out
because i think there have been
significant sections of our population
that we have not been engaged with when
i look at the proposed closures or when
I look at it affects really strongly one
demographic of our population and that
that just doesn't sit well with me so we
need to figure that out so they get to
loosen more today right but but there
was a you know activities one mighty so
my children went to school was a middle
school what was the size at that point
in time for probably about six energy 50
and 80 something right and that was
their capacity I don't know that it was
it at full capacity but it was pretty
close to capacity 17 hundred yeah
remembering what it was a little boy I
know my car gone I can hear you fine
it's just her okay um can I jump in with
a couple go ahead here looking so option
two it just a couple of court just maybe
clarifying questions that I'd like to
hear a response from if tonight is
appropriate that'd be great but that I
think director Belial men talked about
the Spanish Immersion peace at beach if
this is now a k5 is there any sort of
Spanish Immersion post k5 what that what
that looks like might be curious about
that I think too
00h 50m 00s
eyes wise you look at the shared campus
or consolidation of Vernon Vernon in
King and you know 2015 projections with
access is 985 does that can King hold a
thousand students no no that's it that
would they would have we would have to
use two campuses in okay in that model
exactly and if I could just really
quickly the intent of the k5 beach k5 is
that both neighborhood and murs and then
go to grade 6-8 at oxy green the
immersion program would then continue to
feed into Roosevelt Beach neighborhood
students also have the right of either
attending Roosevelt or Jefferson middle
college they have a guarantee table
right so the immersion program would
continue to oakley as well absolutely
okay thank you director working can I
just double check so King he could hold
735 well is that correct when I was the
principal at Kean our number was around
800 so yes King can hold seller 1935 and
the neighborhood facility was not part
of the configuration at that point so
the answer is yes okay i'm hearing yes
and I'm seeing body language that might
challenge that not from you from
somebody else well the reason i would
say that is because remember when i was
principal there it was a pre-k five
school so now you have six if he had 6
7th and 8th graders there you have the
science lab that you have to put into
the configuration we had computer labs
and so forth and so on one of the things
that we've talked about doing is having
a neutral which i do not consider myself
to be educator who has familiarity with
those grade levels walk the building
with a facilities person to really get a
better sense of it because when they
look at it with one eye and an educator
looks at it with another I you get a
different kind of an answer but I I
believe you could get 700 students in
that building and our practice something
of a different right in terms of all
this year some in terms of what people
are doing this tastes based on the
complexity of the program that was I was
running when i was there actually it was
a much more complex comprehensive
program than in terms of some of the
additional services we were providing
and actually what's in the building
right now is when we actually had money
well we had more money from different
kinds of sources we had the deseg money
we had the what they used to call state
disadvantage money he had title 1 money
plus you had general fund monday and the
way that the buildings were staffed was
different at that point in time so it
was a much different configuration but
we had music and strings and no but all
kinds of different kinds of things I
want to be mindful the time that there
and provide an opportunity for our stone
represent to say something there but I
want to take also my colleagues further
bringing up the the dual language
immersion you know one of the I guess
the challenging things is you know the I
guess from where we start I mean that
that involvement does not guarantee
necessary increasing and academic
achievement and conversely you know more
numbers doesn't necessarily without
changing the academics you know there
are taught in that building does not
necessarily guarantee that they're going
to continue to maintain those numbers as
we have seen I think in the in the in
some of the schools i think within the
cluster in the I guess the discussion I
me a part of it is that that you know
the timing of planning and those things
but you know changing in regards to the
whole thing at beach I mean for example
there are a number of folks that apply
that get turned away because there is
not enough capacity there and yet you
know there is no immediate plans or that
have come forth in regards to
considering other schools within that
cluster that would be interested I know
that there at least from what I hear
from parents at King there were some
discussions at these and some interest
from some of the parents there and and I
haven't had those kind of discussions
with other
parents in that area but I think what
the graphic Belial says I mean it's also
if if we are feeling this now me the
feeder pattern is that it you know they
go to Roosevelt for for that you know
what are what are other neighboring
schools that can also be considered when
that within that process I think would
be important the challenge part of
course we only dealing with numbers
right now not programs but the argument
00h 55m 00s
that I keep hearing from people outside
in the community is that ok but what are
you actually doing to to entice people
to remain in their in their neighborhood
with with programmatic work that is you
know that is of interest and I'm not
sure that even with some of the proposed
changes that are here even you know that
there is mixing of of things that that
will be sufficient to to guarantee that
that enrollment that that we're looking
for the greatest potential I mean I
think in I think more than any other
cluster it's in the Jefferson cluster
and particularly I think that corridor
of MLK are close to it in regards to
including I mean increasing enrollment
but I think we still have to talk about
program and I'm not sure that you all I
mean at what point I mean you're you're
looking at that right well and I mean I
mean I right but the way our system is
set up right now right and this is
community right it's this team's tasked
with coming up with how to get the
numbers right there's another team with
how do how do we get the academics and
how do we have a district-wide strategy
for the programs but i agree but but if
it could it just be in terms of the
examples of what we could provide a
different
numbers what are this what if the
program's could look like I think that's
the level what is a program that would
draw numbers to these schools right
there plenty kids in this cluster the
question is what what are the programs
that people would say I want my kids to
stay here in the middle grades but I
think you heard Harriet speak to this a
little bit and this has been a
conversation that's been laced in with
this but again we're not doing program
development on this many models however
what you did here is building programs
that are college going building a
college-going culture across the cluster
you've got one that's a Spanish
Immersion that you've got another one
that's I be you've got voice Elliot
Humboldt that's starting a stem program
yeah I mean you've got like we've got
the concept of the the junior middle
college which would be like preparing
students to be ready to enter a college
prep kind of high school experience so
you've got concepts they or things that
are already in motion and number of
schools across the cluster that do weave
together in a how do you do a cluster
wide college-going culture so I think
you have that much of a concept and then
you keep building but this has been a
very robust conversation internally with
our pre k-12 cabinet with our immersion
folks with the principles at the schools
with the community so I think it's kind
of concentric circles of conversation
that when we zero in on which one of
these then you start to take the other
conversation deeper I think we really
what I'm thinking is that we need in
order to be able to for the community
and others to give input as to which of
those you should select there we need
that additional information we need we
need greater detail what you know the
same things we miss any way so things
you outlined tonight yeah and I think
thought that can we can do on some of
the ones that the questions that you
raised tonight but my point is it hasn't
been absent conversation about program
it's been very much conversation about
program and what are the drawers and
whether the places we're building on
strengths of existing program so yeah
just so I would say
that I think that's the most important
piece or those some of the most
important pieces I think we've had a lot
of focus on community input and I think
that's important but I think that as the
board we need to look and see what do we
know is the best thing for kids and fit
that with what the community says and
I'm a little concerned about the
conversation around aqua green as a
college junior college prep program
because i like to think and at least in
the schools that i've been in in the
cluster and in other clusters i'm
finding in the k-8 and in the middle
schools that they focus a lot on college
going I mean there are college banners
all over there's discussion about
college in the classes and so I wouldn't
want people to think that we're not
looking for a college bound or career
bound students and every single one of
our middle schools they don't need and
it's not necessarily a junior middle
school where you have to go if you want
to go to college so I would just be a
little careful about using that language
rope real quick but i can't i'm and I
and again if you can explain this
tonight that would be great but so
options A&B that you had you showed us
01h 00m 00s
in December show a Woodlawn k5 estimated
2015 enrollment at route 389 tonight as
3 or 4 43 how do we account for the
extra 50 plus students in the last month
if you recall in order to create aqua
green recreated as a middle school the
current students that are there have to
have options to call source so in this
scenario you have a cohort of woodlawn
students joining in with woodland k 5
students so you've got aqua green and
woodlawn coming together then the middle
grades splitting off in 2014 the
difference of those additional k 5
students that are currently at aqua
green going woodland is the difference
that you see in the numbers is that
right okay mm-hmm thank you you will any
other questions comments
I just had one more in terms of having
aqua green an option to become a middle
school is it necessary to wait a full
year is that a nice to have er is that a
must-have and I guess I'm asking because
we have lots of middle school models we
we know what the general curriculum is
I'm I guess I'm asking the why why why
wait a year and why wouldn't we be able
to pull this off next year well there's
many reasons why I don't think you could
pull it off by sep tember of next year's
if you went with that option if you were
thinking he'll need a full year I'm
thinking that the disruption it would
cost and then after the year had begun
you know that I wouldn't suggest right I
don't so I think that's why you end up
with a full years because I don't think
if between februari and sep tember you
could conceptually get the piece
together because you want to do a couple
of things that we haven't done one is
that you want to have as much potential
input from the communities as possible
to answer the question of why would I
want to send my student here and part of
the reason they we want to send their
student there is is that they would have
some input into the programmatic base
that ultimately gets put in place and in
addition one of the things that also
became very clear in terms of some of
the conversations that we had is that
organizationally there tended to be a
sense that we don't fully plan out what
it is we intend to do before we do it
and then once implementation begins the
lack of planning that came before ends
up in the implementation not being as
robust in as full-blown as it needs to
be which ultimately then leads to lack
of commitment to the follow-through
which doesn't make the program go where
it needs to go so it's really more of
that than anything else
I just had one more piece of information
that might be helpful or maybe you've
decided that it's about what reason but
that in one of the options are in a
couple of the options it talks about
more kids being on a bus and buses in my
head I mean extra expense and so I'm not
sure obviously there are costs
associated but it be as we as we reduced
bus service produce bus service that be
curious to find out what what additional
cost that is especially as we talked
about portables and temporaries and I
just want to compliment the staff on
getting this down to two options i think
the six options were confusing and
frustrating for the community so i think
this gives us the opportunity to to
really understand what we're all talking
about so thank you for that thank you
for your questions thank you yeah I hope
that was able to provide some useful
information to you I think that this
point there's at least my sense there is
quite a bit of hesitation on either
model that that is being proposed and I
think that it's much more parotid that
we have into some other questions they
got pose I think we'll be able to move
forward or not and so I think looking
forward to the next updated report thank
you very much thank you thank you we
have the next on the business agenda
so the warmer now considered business
gendarmes Houston is there any changes
live is magenta yo do I have a motion a
second to adapt to business gender sir
moved director Reagan moose and director
sergeants no no director Regan director
knows that correct I heard it this way
01h 05m 00s
ok let's whatever is there I think the
cat who got it first and so if I don't
say it is there any board discussion
twisting agenda misuse the journey
public comment on lavista genta the ball
now boat on on the business gentlemen
favorite fish indicate by saying yes yes
i'll post basilica by saying no the
business Janice approved by the world 70
was doing representing us here holding
yes wanted to announce before we
adjourned that 2012 Oregon School Board
Association elections have been
conducted and I am pleased to announce
that director regan has been elected to
serve in the position number 17 in the
OSB a board Doug Montgomery is also
representing malama County he will serve
position number 19 congratulations to
both the next meeting of the borokii
estate session on Tuesday generated 22nd
2013 at 6pm this meeting is adjourned
thank you
Event 3: PPS Board of Education Study Session - Enrollment Balancing Excerpt
00h 00m 00s
my name is Antonio Lopez I'm the
Regional Administrator for Franklin and
Jefferson and tonight in the hour that
we have we have three objectives and the
objectives to review the enrollment and
balancing process the second to describe
the two options for a dye Jefferson
pre-k a cluster the community engagement
plan and lastly to listen to your
questions and feedback so we're going to
start with this is a cycle that you have
seed and right now we are in that
listening and proposal we will move into
the decide and eventually to the
implementation and then we start the
cycle again in terms of assessing
whether the employment issue was
successful so as you can see we're in
the right in the middle we're ready for
the next step and like that
superintendent splitter described there
is a process and that eventually it will
be coming to this world for a portable
for a decision oh okay we do have this
set up in a process for how we're going
to do this basically what we're going to
talk about today in terms of the process
of how we came down to the two scenarios
we looked at after listening to all of
the input from the variety of audiences
internal external stakeholder groups and
multiple in multiple venues and forms we
did decide on a couple of things and
prioritized around a couple of things
but things to keep in mind is that we
know that the enrollment balancing of
the balancing of enrollment by itself is
not going to improve student achievement
that what we're looking for our numbers
that would get to the point in the
Jefferson cluster so that every year
annually we did not have to be reducing
staff because we don't have sufficient
numbers in the building to be able to
maintain the
that we have in place so in setting the
priorities for these last two options we
basically came up with a way of
balancing enrollment in two different
strategies that would give us
significant enough numbers so that the
resources that go with the numbers once
you get them could be stabilized no
matter which one of the two processes
the focus is on academic achievement in
the acceleration of achievement and the
elevation of achievement the other focus
is on making certain that all students
have access to programs that we have
already know will prove to be effective
across the cluster so we're not looking
at new things some new idea that we
dreamt up but ideas that have proven to
be effective in this cluster and we are
also looking at establishing a sense of
having students recognizing that pre-k
through 12 is the trajectory for college
choices and post-secondary options that
you don't start at ninth grade to begin
talking to students and getting them to
start thinking about how what they might
want to do once they exit the k-12 arena
so over the years because the numbers in
the in the cluster have fluctuated that
has led to programmatic instability
staffing instability and the inability
to get these programs that we know are
good things for kids in place long
enough to get the results that we would
like to have happen so the cluster once
again to remind you are the eight
schools that have guaranteed enrollment
to the Jefferson middle college and we
are also talking about the Humboldt and
humboldt buildings King and aqua green
has low enrollment at all the grades
fabien Vernon and woodland lower upper
grade enrollment and beach chief Joe
Fabian limited class space across the
building and boise le and humble has the
potential for crowding in future years
without changes we would see that
constant up and down and sway that has
been impacting this cluster for a number
of years now so once again as I said we
are going to try and right size these
two proposals right size the school to
make certain that we have strong
academics
or the emphasis is on the quality of
middle schools across all of the input
that we got consistently one of the
things that we heard was things are
great we like our primary grades or we
really like this but every school every
audience spoke to needing to strengthen
even if they were pleased with what was
happening they knew that they needed to
have a much more robust middle grades
program in all of the schools we also
want to make sure that the enrollment
changes will result in something that's
an outcome outcome of equitable and high
quality academic programs in other words
why do the change if it isn't going to
improve the academics in the building
and as I said linkages to the high
school curriculum and access to college
00h 05m 00s
college and post-secondary opportunities
of course we would like all of our
students in the Jefferson cluster to
feed Jefferson High School we proud of
that school we support that school but
if they make other choices we obviously
want to be successful no matter where
they go and so we're looking at Advanced
Placement at other high school options
and other higher education partners are
linking with us like the PhD two three
piece with Concordia we are looking for
kids to be able to be academically
successful so they can take advantage of
any option that comes their way and of
course we want to nurture college-going
college-going cluster across oh this is
hard to say college-going culture across
the cluster okay who but that sentence
in there all right so here's the process
do you want to do the process Judy okay
okay so a superintendent Smith said we
began the process in the summer but
actively since the fall we've held a
number about 20 formal meetings we
release six scenarios for feedback we
received about 250 written comments on
those scenarios alone and over 600
comments written comments so far all of
those comments are documented in binders
that are in the board office and as we
continue to get them we'll continue to
update that body of information we now
are at the point as you heard that and
we'll be talking about tonight we have
two options where we've called down the
feedback
on the scenarios to to workable sets of
infirm we're proposing six meetings and
will run through that list again there's
a few things that that maybe are even
changed since since earlier looking
towards the superintendent's
recommendation and then your actions
coming next so this is just a quick
reminder that we have different types of
tools that we can can use an enrollment
balancing that make different kinds of
changes and some of them such as
changing the transfer policy tightening
down transfers or making boundary
changes are what we call slow change so
it can right size over time but it
doesn't bring a lot of immediate impact
particularly when you're looking at the
middle grades because we start things
like boundary change at kindergarten and
that's it has the biggest impact at the
lower grades it takes years in a cage
school before you see that impact in the
upper grades other things such as grade
reconfiguration consolidation enclosure
does cause existing students to move so
it's more impact immediately it's more
disruption but you get bigger results
and of course we always look at things
like facility changes options as well
but as we know we're limited due to cost
and so that's just the framework of
changes that we designing these options
with it and finally I just wanted to
mention as you've heard we're focused on
strengthening strengthening the middle
years we're looking at having at least
two classrooms for grade level in a k-8
even in those grades six seven and eight
which means you need more kids at the
lower grades so trying to right-size
schools in an effective way is an
important part of this and in a way that
crosses all of those grades we would
look at having at least six classrooms
per grade level in a middle school which
is three to four feeder schools and at
this point there's no middle school in
the cluster now okay all that preamble
we would now like to describe for you
the two options you've received a packet
of information that includes maps and
hopefully those will be visible where
you are i'm going to put some on the
screen here i don't know how help
all kind of piece so let me know later
if any of this information up here isn't
visible okay so in the first option our
focus is on maintaining the KH structure
that exists in the cluster now but
consolidating in a couple of
particularly taking three schools and
consolidating down to two in order to
increase access to programs for students
so in this change Chief Joseph aqua
green and woodlawn come together next
year as a single pre-k school that
operates on two campuses with this the
woodlawn building would close after that
point the boundary for Woodlawn would be
divided between chief joseph aqua green
king and access or sorry King and Vernon
and additionally the access program
currently at Saban would move to King so
visually here's what this looks like
with
not sure that's going to work very well
so you see the Woodlawn campus closing
the boundary the potential boundary
change and the portion of the Woodlawn
boundary that would become part of the
Chief Joseph ugly green boundary the
portion that would become part of the
00h 10m 00s
king pounder II and the portion that
would become part of the Vernon boundary
and you see ugly green and chief joe to
becoming a dual campus single school
that yes that would serve probably
grades pre-k through eight you see
access coming into king and a small
boundary change that over time builds
enrollment at Vernon one of the
questions that you may have is why would
Woodlawn be the school that we would
look at for a closure in this scenario
we visited Woodlawn a couple of times
that this fall made many other visits
there the regional administrative former
Regional Administrator there are a lot
of strengths and values in Woodlawn
teachers parents students working very
hard on achievement other factors that
we see though are that a capture rate in
their neighborhood area that's
chronically low that's hovering around
forty percent so more than half of the
students who live in their neighborhood
continue to make other choices and even
though they've seen growth at the lower
grades it's still it's still so low and
so suppressed it's going to take a long
time for those changes to impact the
upper grades where the sizes are
smallest in addition we see continuing
low achievement data and we understand
that that means that we we have to
accelerate and elevate our academic
efforts in that school it makes it much
much harder to do that at the middle
grades when their numbers are really low
so we see that we need a more immediate
change in order to give students the
access to programs that will nurture
that academic success there are other
possibilities we want to quickly mention
aligned with this option as you can see
we have no direct change for Beach Boys
ele and Humboldt or Fabien in this
option however there are possibilities
than the few
sure there could be immersion changes
that are aligned with the district's
immersion plan and that could have an
impact on on beach in some way Boise
Elliott humble could look at moving to
the tub tub on campus in the future
Fabien is slated to receive portable
classrooms in advance of its full
modernization and continue its
partnership with Concordia and 32 PhD
there are additional boundary changes
that we could look at in the future to
right-size neighborhoods within those
schools so there are some unusual
aspects to their neighborhoods that we
we would be happy to go in and clean up
once we get these major all structural
decisions made Humboldt could become a
regional early learning center in 2014
or later we want to align that overall
early learning center plan for the
Jefferson cluster and the rest of the
district with state objectives and that
and you'll see more of that coming later
in the interim we believe that all the
schools that have pre-k now will
maintain pre-k so long as funding is
still available for that and finally we
want to say that it's important to
probably look at our high school duel
assignment choices for future students
and make sure that they're appropriately
lined again once we make these important
structural decisions these are the types
of changes that could come behind
quickly by the numbers here are
estimated enrollment impacts you can see
what the current enrollment is at each
school what the estimated enrollment
would be if we did nothing and what the
change would be I probably should have
just highlighted the schools that change
not those that stay the same but you can
see particularly the Chief Joseph line
is the line for the combined Chief
Joseph aqua green and woodlawn so about
1100 students divided between though
between the teachers of an aqua green
campus allows us to fully utilize both
of those schools off the green would be
full for the first time in a long time
Chief Joseph would not be overcrowded so
long as we could make grade structure
changes that made the most of a larger
building still serving Chief Joseph
serving for the lower grades you see
King growing both from the inclusion
access and from the beginning effects of
the boundary changed 636 we still
believe that there's some room for
growth between the the King boundary and
the access program and then Vernon
continuing to grow through through an
enlarged neighborhood and also through
increased capture rates so what you've
seen then is we have immediate and
program access improvements particularly
for Woodlawn Chief Joseph oxy green and
Kings students we have slow but steady
growth for Vernon this option does
require that we close the school it
requires that we develop a strong shared
campus model and it'll mean that we'll
have additional transportation needs
including some students who are now
walkers to their current school other
00h 15m 00s
specific resource impacts will be
modeled if this option becomes the
superintendent's recommendation so we
would imagine that there are many more
questions that you might have a
community members might have and we will
do our best to resolve those questions
as soon as we were able to sort out
which of these options indeed is going
to be moving forward so that's my brief
summary on option 1 i'd like to turn to
option two this is another way of
leading to similar outcomes but using
different structures and impacting
different schools so it brings a middle
school back into the cluster as well as
ensures that the remaining k age are
programmatically strong certainly if
you're bringing strong middle grades
competition to schools nearby you want
to make sure that the caïds that are
left are ready to stand up to that
competition in this the current oakley
green school would close at the end of
this year and then reopen in 2014 as a
junior middle college school serving
grades 6 through 8 so that would require
a planning year and during that time
current aqua green students would move
to Woodlawn many of them are from other
neighborhoods because in grades K
through 5 it's a focus option choice so
the students would also have the right
to return to their neighborhood school
they preferred that
we also would need a location for the
oxy green neighborhood sixth grade so
the kids that are from the Chief Joseph
neighborhood for fifth grade and that
could be woodland there's also the
option if that doesn't work of portables
on the Chief Joseph campus but that
comes with costs in addition to that
change that is to setting a middle
school at aqua green that's fed by four
schools that slide name the four schools
no why don't I name those four schools
they would be Beach Boys II Elliot Chief
Joseph and woodlawn in addition to that
King and Vernon would consolidate into a
single school an International
Baccalaureate school both of those
schools currently have that program it
would be larger and more robust school
under this change we envision two ways
that that consolidation could happen the
first the most abrupt the most
traditional is that one of the schools
closes the other all the students go to
the to the largest building that would
likely be king and then we would do
boundary changes to make sure that that
neighborhood was right sized to fit that
one building but we also want to
continue some of our out-of-the-box
thinking and recognizing the
programmatic alignment that always
already happened to those schools and
that we'd like to find another home for
access which is right now at Saban we
would also proposed that it's possible
to have both campuses remain open in a
shared campus model similar to what I
just described her aqua green and Chief
Joseph and that the access Academy their
grades one through aid would exist on
one of those two campuses and as I said
if we go with a traditional
consolidation we would have to do
boundary changes so I'm going to flip to
the map here and you see the for feeder
schools feeding into aqua green you see
the one year the shift for aqua green
current students on to the Woodlawn
campus beginning next year and then aqua
green open in 2014 you see our either/or
way of consolidating King and Vernon
that
include access or may not and you see
the potential for some boundary changes
that might have to be made if we go
through traditional consolidation King
becomes the new school the Vernon
building closes though boundary changes
would likely have to move through fabien
and fabien isn't a school that can
accept more students for several years
so there's some complexities that could
come with that one of the questions that
you might have or I just wanted to spend
another minute on this detail that's in
this particular option of our request
for a planning year to develop our
middle school model it's a traditional
method for opening a new school where
you take the time to hire your
administrators select your curriculum
build your relationships both with your
feeder schools and with the high school
that you're going to be sending students
to build up your marketing strategy give
your feeder schools time to adapt and
then you go ahead and open the school so
those are some of the things that we're
looking for here we believe that that
time will be extremely valuable in
getting that new school off to a strong
start again some future possibilities
that I mentioned before exist as well
with this plan including future possible
changes with immersion the fabien plan
remains largely the same under this as
it did what I described before we might
still have additional boundary changes
between some smaller in some smaller
00h 20m 00s
neighborhood areas the Early Learning
Center potential exists and the need no
doubt to realign our high school duel
assignment choices or at least examine
them make sure that they're still
appropriate after we decide these
structural changes the impacts that we
believe come with this option are
improved access to our middle grades
programs and to high school and beyond
that it really galvanizes the notion of
a junior middle college as a theme that
drives that college ready culture what
cluster why'd you write that's hard to
say across across the the area
that there's strength in a planning year
but it does require additional staff and
student movement it requires us to
decide to either closer school or
develop a dual campus model that'll be
additional transition and transportation
for many students and there are other
specific resource impacts that will be
modeled if this is the option that
becomes the superintendent's
recommendation finally by the numbers
you see Beach Boys II Elliot Chief
Joseph and woodlawn as our feeder
schools k 5k fives that doesn't include
their pre k if you look at for example
Chief Joseph at 513 Woodlawn at 444 like
if under this model that's a that's a
place where a boundary change might make
sense might be just enough to build
Woodlawn right to the size that we would
want and provide a little more space at
Chief Joseph which is full right now so
that's an example of how a future
boundary change might support this
overall structure change you see the the
middle school in 2015 with 522 students
in it what's going on in the cluster
right now is that you have significantly
higher numbers of students in grades
four and below so for that first year I
mean we can count how many kids are
attending the schools and those clusters
and we see that it may start with a
relatively small like sixth grade but
it'll grow over time so starting with
about 480 in the first year 522 on the
way up to 600 this would have an opening
sixth grade class of about 200 students
which is what we look for in our middle
school model okay so that is the place
summary and then we quickly go over
where we are with ya so today we met
with the staffs of four schools aqua
green chip Joseph Wald lon inverter the
princess will work out a talk to the
other schools and while you have right
now is the plan in terms of how we're
going to take these options to the
community
and as you can see we're going to be
pretty busy in the next two weeks so we
have a variety of meetings in the
different schools we have on january
twenty second we meeting with the
planning team that helped us in the
beginning in terms of the planning we
meet around that when ether with the ESL
families you see that we meeting with
cleaning and access and then on january
26 we have the community forum that will
be at jefferson we also have a meeting
with all the special education families
we have a online survey that runs
through the 28th it wishes the community
can give us ideas of be back about this
process and one thing that that we
always that we keep in mind is how do we
make sure that we hear from the famil is
that that for some reason or another
historically we have now heard from
special you know families of color I
mean everyone but how do we how do we
intentionally go and look for the
families that historically have not
gonna be now represented how do we also
engage our partners and we have a
meeting with a with the partners with
our ministers in that the community in
terms so we want to hear their voice and
also including that different
organizations like the local churches
sei the Latino network airco and those
Sources
- PPS Board of Education, Archive 2012-2013, https://www.pps.net/Page/2225 (accessed: 2022-03-24T00:57:54.937864Z)
- PPS Communications, "Board of Education" (YouTube playlist), https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL8CC942A46270A16E (accessed: 2023-10-10T04:10:04.879786Z)